Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Fire Island Real Estate Specialists
William J. Newman Realty has served Fire Island's western communities since 1969, offering unparalleled expertise in real estate sales, rentals, and development projects. Our team combines over four decades of local market knowledge with a commitment to personalized service, understanding the unique challenges of Fire Island's barrier beach environment. We specialize in connecting clients with exclusive properties across Fair Harbor, Lonelyville, Saltaire, and Dunewood, ensuring every transaction reflects our deep understanding of zoning regulations, seasonal dynamics, and coastal property management. Our brokers maintain year-round availability to guide clients through property selection, mortgage pre-approval processes, and contract negotiations. With a focus on transparency, we provide detailed property listings including pricing, square footage, and location specifics to streamline decision-making.Our construction division leverages extensive experience in Fire Island-specific building projects, from renovations to new developments, while our rental services include luggage delivery and curated inventory of vacation properties. We prioritize client education about Fire Island's distinct real estate ecosystem, including investment potential, rental market trends, and regulatory considerations. Our reputation as trusted advisors is built on consistent representation of both buyers and sellers through documented procedures that verify client credentials and property authorization. Through generations of service, we've cultivated relationships that transform first-time visitors into lifelong property owners on this unique coastal destination.
Services
Real Estate Sales
Vacation Rentals
Property Development
Construction Services
Market Analysis
Details
- Year established: 1969
Highlights and features
- We offer 54 years of continuous Fire Island real estate expertise since 1969
- Our team maintains exclusive listings across 4 western Fire Island communities
- We provide transparent pricing with full property details upfront
- Our associates are available 7 days a week for client support
- We combine real estate brokerage with in-house construction capabilities
Services
Real Estate Sales
Specializing in Fire Island residential transactions since 1969, we facilitate purchases of cottages, beachfront properties, and investment homes. Our brokers provide market analysis, contract negotiation, and regulatory guidance for Suffolk County's barrier beach communities. With exclusive listings across western Fire Island, we connect buyers with verified properties meeting strict documentation requirements.
Vacation Rentals
Offering curated inventory of fully documented vacation properties, we provide transparent pricing and 7-day support for weekly rentals. Our services include luggage delivery assistance and access to exclusive listings in Fair Harbor and surrounding communities. Properties range from 2-5 bedroom cottages to luxury oceanfront homes with detailed amenity descriptions.
Property Development
Our in-house construction team manages coastal development projects adhering to Fire Island's unique zoning regulations. Services include site selection, renovation of historic properties, and new builds incorporating climate-resilient design. With 54 years of local experience, we navigate permitting processes and environmental considerations specific to barrier island construction.
Market Analysis
Providing data-driven property valuations based on 40+ years of local transaction history, we help sellers price homes competitively and buyers make informed offers. Our analysis considers seasonal rental potential, location specifics, and recent comparable sales across Fire Island's distinct neighborhoods.
Client Verification
We implement standardized procedures to verify government-issued identification for clients and confirm property authorization status with listing agents. This ensures all transactions maintain proper documentation and exclusive agency agreements are respected throughout the buying/selling process.
People
William J. Newman
Licensed Broker and Contractor
Founder with 54 years of Fire Island real estate expertise, combining brokerage and construction knowledge to guide clients through complex coastal property transactions and development projects.
Nicholas J. Newman
Associate Broker
Second-generation real estate professional specializing in western Fire Island properties, leveraging family experience to assist clients with sales, rentals, and investment strategies since 1990.
Stacy Newman Riley
Associate Broker
Licensed broker with extensive local market knowledge, focusing on Fair Harbor and Saltaire properties while providing personalized service to seasonal and year-round clients.
Phyllis Schiller
Associate Broker
Experienced real estate professional connecting clients with exclusive Fire Island listings, offering insights into community dynamics and property management considerations.
Jean Ufer
Licensed Salesperson
Dedicated sales associate with specialized knowledge of Dunewood and Lonelyville properties, assisting clients with vacation home purchases and rental investments.
Questions
What Fire Island communities do you serve?
We specialize in Fair Harbor, Lonelyville, Saltaire, and Dunewood properties with exclusive listings across these western Fire Island communities.
Do you offer year-round real estate services?
Our associates provide real estate services 7 days a week throughout the year for property inquiries and transactions.
What rental services do you provide?
We manage vacation rentals with transparent pricing, luggage delivery services, and curated inventory across all bedroom configurations.
Do you handle property development projects?
Our construction division manages Fire Island-specific projects including renovations, new builds, and zoning-compliant developments.
How do you verify property listings?
We follow documented procedures to verify exclusive agency status and property authorization before showing any listed homes.