Business Details
50 Years
experience
Your Trusted Real Estate Partner in San Marcos, TX
Since 1976, our family-owned business has combined deep market expertise with personalized service to deliver exceptional real estate solutions. As third-generation realtors, we leverage over four decades of combined experience in property management and sales. Our specialized knowledge of the San Antonio, New Braunfels, and Kyle markets ensures clients receive tailored guidance through every transaction.Our team maintains active memberships in multiple local realtor boards and MLS systems, upholding industry standards while prioritizing client needs. With a legacy built on trust and professional integrity, we continue to adapt to modern real estate demands while maintaining our founding commitment to personal service.
Services
Property Management
Home Sales
Leasing Services
Featured Properties
Sales Category
Tenant Portal
Details
- Year established: 1976
Highlights and features
- We have 48 years of combined real estate experience in local markets
- Our team maintains memberships in multiple regional realtor associations
- Specialized property management expertise for residential investments
- Third-generation family ownership ensures personalized client service
- Active participation in San Antonio and Central Texas MLS systems
Services
Property Management
Our property management service handles residential rental properties across San Antonio to Kyle. We provide tenant screening, maintenance coordination, and rent collection while maintaining 45 years of industry expertise. Our team ensures compliance with local regulations while maximizing property value for owners.
Home Sales
Specializing in home sales across San Marcos and surrounding areas, we offer expert market analysis and strategic pricing. Our agents provide comprehensive marketing solutions and negotiation expertise. We maintain active listings in both San Antonio MLS and Central Texas MLS systems.
Leasing Services
We streamline residential leasing processes with qualified tenant placement and lease administration. Our service includes property marketing, tenant screening, and lease agreement management across diverse property types in the New Braunfels region.
Featured Properties
Our featured properties showcase premium homes and apartments in San Antonio and New Braunfels. Each listing undergoes careful selection based on quality, location, and market appeal. We provide detailed property information and specialized marketing for premium real estate assets.
People
Becky Kelly
Realtor/Property Manager/Owner
With 22 years in New Braunfels real estate, Becky combines generational expertise with modern market insights as she manages daily operations alongside her mother, Peg McNicholas-Langen.
Peg McNicholas-Langen
Realtor, Broker/Owner
A licensed broker since 1977, Peg has dedicated her career to client-focused real estate services. Her academic background in real estate and philosophy informs her approach to property transactions and client education.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We serve San Marcos, San Antonio, New Braunfels, and Kyle areas with comprehensive real estate services.
What real estate services do you offer?
We provide home sales, property management, leasing services, and featured property listings across Central Texas.
How experienced is your team?
Our team combines 48 years of family real estate expertise with current MLS system participation and multiple association memberships.
Do you manage rental properties?
Yes, we've successfully managed residential rentals for 45 years across the San Antonio to Kyle corridor.
Are you a family business?
Yes, we're a third-generation family-owned firm with Becky Kelly and Peg McNicholas-Langen actively managing operations.
Reviews (4)
Philip Layton
Jan 20, 2022
Report
Ive been in the military for over 10 years and have rented the entire time and this is by far the WORST company I have ever worked with. No communication from Becky when we were moving out had to call the actual landlord to get answers and to have her contact us back. Took 2.5 months to get the deposit back and when we received the deposit (they made us turn keys in and did their own inspection without us there) it was less than half of the deposit for repairs we were never told of and that were there when we moved in. I have never not received my full deposit back but this is the first. Most
Britney Simpson
Jul 15, 2021
Report
If I could give a zero for my rating I would. Rebecca Kelly was not the ideal agent I wanted to conduct business with. Upon contacting her and leaving voicemails, emails she didnt do a great job at responding to them or getting back to me. I found her to be unprofessional and rude when I spoke with her to inquire about a property I was interested in renting that had been on the market for 20 days, she claimed there were 3 applicants already. However, I was informed previously that there were none but based on Rebeccas tone and attitude she clearly was not trying to service me so i would not
John Ensley
Dec 26, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness
I rented from McNicholas Realtors for 2 years. The AC went out and was fixed within 24 hours. Any time we brought concerns to Peg she scheduled maintenance promptly. We returned the house as found, and received our full deposit back. The house wasn't perfect, but was priced accordingly, so I was happy with the experience.
I rented from McNicholas Realtors for 2 years. The AC went out and was fixed within 24 hours. Any time we brought concerns to Peg she scheduled maintenance promptly. We returned the house as found, and received our full deposit back. The house wasn't perfect, but was priced accordingly, so I was happy with the experience.
Janet Foy
Jun 09, 2020
Report
Would not recommend.
Listed a home that we sold after managing a rental that we owned. They approved a $1000 A/C repair and NEVER told us about the charge. Not in text or email... nothing. We happened to see the charge on the final settlement statement AT CLOSING. It was then explained that they made an executive decision since they didnt think they could reach us since we were on a cruise. I was reachable while on the cruise and my husband wasnt on the cruise. Very much reachable. Didnt even attempt.
THEN they explained that they were charging worse case unexplainable final
Listed a home that we sold after managing a rental that we owned. They approved a $1000 A/C repair and NEVER told us about the charge. Not in text or email... nothing. We happened to see the charge on the final settlement statement AT CLOSING. It was then explained that they made an executive decision since they didnt think they could reach us since we were on a cruise. I was reachable while on the cruise and my husband wasnt on the cruise. Very much reachable. Didnt even attempt.
THEN they explained that they were charging worse case unexplainable final
