Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
26 Years
experience
Custom Jewelry & Artisan Metalwork in Wauwatosa
Magpie Jewelry & Metals Studio was founded in 2000 by Kristen Fogtman-Faust, Terese Millmann, and Christopher Stephens. Our shared retail and studio space in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, combines decades of collective experience in jewelry design and metalwork. We specialize in custom creations, from engagement rings to artisanal metal pieces, while curating a selection of finished jewelry and gift items. Our team of three partners brings distinct expertise in fabrication, forging, and hand engraving, with a focus on materials like mokume gane, precious metals, and natural gemstones.

We collaborate with regional artists to expand our offerings, ensuring clients access both in-house craftsmanship and curated collections. Our approach emphasizes personalized service, technical mastery, and a commitment to transforming client visions into wearable art. With over two decades in operation, we maintain a reputation for quality, innovation, and community engagement in the Midwest jewelry scene.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design Handcrafted Metalwork Artisan Engraving Gemstone Setting Jewelry Repair Mokume Gane Fabrication Precious Metal Forging Bespoke Wedding Bands Artisan Jewelry Retail Metal Sculpture Creation
Details
  • Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 20 years of specialized expertise in custom jewelry design and metal fabrication.
  • Our team includes three master artisans with distinct skills in forging, engraving, and mokume gane techniques.
  • We collaborate with regional artists to provide diverse, high-quality curated collections.
  • Our custom process prioritizes client collaboration from concept to finished piece.
  • We maintain strict quality control using ethically sourced precious metals and gemstones.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
We create one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces tailored to client specifications. Our process begins with concept sketches and material selection, followed by precise fabrication techniques including wax carving, metal forging, and gemstone setting. Clients receive detailed guidance on metal purity, stone quality, and design feasibility throughout the creation process.
Artisan Metalwork
Our metalworking services include crafting intricate metal components using traditional techniques. We specialize in combining different metals through soldering, welding, and mokume gane layering to create unique textures and patterns. Projects range from functional objects to decorative metal sculptures with precise finishing details.
Gemstone Setting
We offer professional gemstone setting for both new and existing jewelry pieces. Our expertise includes prong, bezel, pave, and channel settings using various precious metals. We work with natural and lab-created stones, ensuring secure placement while maintaining the stone's integrity and visual impact.
Jewelry Repair
Our repair services address damaged or worn jewelry through meticulous restoration techniques. We handle chain re-linking, clasp replacement, ring resizing, and stone replacement while preserving original design elements. Repairs maintain the piece's structural integrity and aesthetic value using matching materials.
Mokume Gane Fabrication
We specialize in creating mokume gane patterns by laminating and manipulating different metal layers. This traditional Japanese technique produces distinctive woodgrain-like patterns in metal. The process involves precise temperature control and hand forging to achieve unique visual effects in rings and decorative objects.
People
Kristen Fogtman-Faust
Partner
Co-founder with over two decades of experience in jewelry design and business management. Specializes in client consultation and overseeing studio operations while maintaining quality standards.
Terese Millmann
Partner
Master artisan specializing in metal fabrication and gemstone setting. Creates intricate jewelry pieces using traditional techniques while mentoring emerging artists in the studio space.
Christopher Stephens
Partner
Skilled metalsmith with expertise in hand engraving and mokume gane techniques. Focuses on complex custom designs and maintains technical excellence in all studio production processes.
Questions
What custom jewelry services do you offer?
We create custom rings, bracelets, pendants, and earrings using precious metals and gemstones. Our process includes design consultation, material selection, and handcrafting to client specifications.
Do you work with existing jewelry materials?
Yes, we incorporate heirloom metals and stones into new designs. This includes repurposing old jewelry while maintaining sentimental value through updated craftsmanship.
What metal combinations can you work with?
We specialize in gold (yellow, white, rose), platinum, palladium, and sterling silver. Our mokume gane technique combines different metals for unique patterns in rings and decorative pieces.
How long does custom jewelry creation take?
Custom projects typically require 4-8 weeks depending on complexity. Simple designs may complete faster, while intricate pieces with multiple stones require additional fabrication time.
Do you offer jewelry repair services?
Yes, we provide resizing, stone replacement, clasp repair, and structural restoration. Our repair process maintains original design elements while ensuring durability for continued wear.
Can I collaborate with specific artists?
We connect clients with represented artists for specialized projects. This includes regional jewelers and metalworkers whose unique styles complement our in-house capabilities.
Reviews (5)
Nicole Mueller
Sep 21, 2021 Report
I needed a custom wedding band and they knocked it out of the park! I got a beautiful saffire band that is stunning! Highly recommend them! You can see how the band "clicks" under the engagement band. I didn't want to solder together and this works perfect!
Valerie Troutman
May 27, 2021 Report
Answered all of my questions, very knowledgeable and extremely kind! Would highly recommend them to others for jewelry repair.
Mary Ellen Fitts
Sep 30, 2020 Report
Therese is very helpful and talented! We redesigned our 25th anniversary rings to accomodate our 50th! Beautiful art items as well as jewelry in the store!
T. S.
May 19, 2019 Report
Highly recommended. I purchased a custom engraved gold wedding band from Chris at Magpie and had a wonderful experience. I gave him an idea of what I wanted (theme of the ring, images I liked) and he crafted them into a composition that spoke well in ring form. He was kind and seemed to care a great deal. There was an issue with the order of the band from the gold supplier, but Chris stepped in and made it right. Chris does excellent work and I would definitely recommend Magpie to a friend. Plus the shop dog is cool.
Emilie Williamson
Dec 31, 2018 Report
I love Magpie, cute shop, friendly team and they do amazing work. They replaced a broken prong and made this sentimental item (my moms belt buckle) look new again.