Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Family-Owned Jewelry Store Since 1935
Shallow Jewelers is a fourth-generation family-owned business established in 1935, dedicated to providing exceptional jewelry services and products. Our expertise spans on-site jewelry repair, custom design, and curating high-quality engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. With over 85 years of combined experience, our team of certified professionals prioritizes personalized service, treating every customer like family. We specialize in unique diamond selections, including GIA-certified natural and lab-grown diamonds, while maintaining a commitment to transparency and integrity.

Our reputation for excellence is built on decades of satisfied clients who trust us with their most cherished pieces. We pride ourselves on combining traditional craftsmanship with modern innovation to meet evolving customer needs. Our local knowledge of the West Allis community ensures tailored solutions that resonate with our clientele's values. Every interaction reflects our dedication to preserving the tradition of exceptional customer care that has defined our business since its inception.
Services
Jewelry Repair Engagement Rings Custom Design Watch Repair Diamond Sales Wedding Bands Ring Sizing Pendant Creation Jewelry Appraisals Watch Battery Replacement
Details
  • Year established: 1935
Highlights and features
  • We offer 4th generation family-owned expertise since 1935
  • Our on-site jewelry repair specialists complete most jobs in a week
  • We provide custom design services with certified gemologists
  • Our team maintains 100% customer satisfaction with lifetime guarantees
  • We source GIA-certified natural diamonds and IGI-certified lab-grown diamonds
What people say
Best customer service Fast repairs done Honesty and personal attention Lifetime guarantees Family-like treatment
Services
Jewelry Repair
Our expert jewelers specialize in comprehensive repair services including ring sizing, chain soldering, prong replacement, and stone setting. With on-site capabilities and a typical one-week turnaround, we restore both modern and heirloom pieces to their original condition. Our meticulous process ensures all repairs maintain structural integrity while preserving aesthetic value, with lifetime guarantees on completed work.
Custom Design
We create bespoke jewelry pieces tailored to individual preferences and occasions. Our designers collaborate closely with clients to develop unique engagement rings, wedding bands, and statement pieces using CAD technology and hand-drafting techniques. From concept to completion, we guide customers through material selection, gemstone choices, and production timelines, ensuring personalized creations that reflect each client's vision and budget.
Engagement Rings
We offer an extensive selection of engagement rings featuring GIA-certified natural diamonds and IGI-certified lab-grown diamonds. Our inventory includes designer collections from Gabriel & Company alongside custom options in various metals. Certified gemologists assist with diamond grading, setting styles, and ethical sourcing considerations, providing expert guidance through one of life's most significant purchases.
Watch Repair
Our watch maintenance services include battery replacement, band adjustments, and comprehensive mechanical repairs. Certified technicians work on both modern and vintage timepieces, using specialized tools to service water-resistant models and restore functionality to heirloom watches. We maintain original components whenever possible while offering transparent pricing for all repair options.
Diamond Sales
We provide a curated selection of natural and lab-grown diamonds with full certification documentation. Our inventory includes various cuts, colors, and clarities with options for different budgets and preferences. Certified gemologists educate customers about the 4Cs (carat, color, clarity, cut) and help select stones that balance quality with value, ensuring informed purchasing decisions for significant jewelry investments.
People
Dean Shallow
Owner / Gemologist / Sales / Designer
Fourth-generation jeweler with over 30 years of experience, specializing in gemology and custom design. Maintains family tradition of personalized service while overseeing daily operations and client consultations.
Michael Mapes
Sales / Designer
Experienced jewelry designer with 15+ years in custom creation and client relations. Known for patient consultations and innovative design solutions that balance aesthetics with practicality for everyday wear.
Renee Brunelli
Office Manager / Sales / Designer
Manages administrative operations while contributing to sales and design projects. Combines organizational expertise with creative input to ensure smooth customer experiences from consultation to delivery.
Jennifer Shallow
Ring Maintenance and Polishing
Specializes in detailed jewelry maintenance and restoration. Ensures all pieces meet quality standards through meticulous cleaning, polishing, and inspection processes before customer delivery.
Holly Shallow
Outside Sales / Accounts Payable Specialist
Manages vendor relationships and financial operations while supporting sales initiatives. Balances back-office responsibilities with client outreach to maintain business partnerships and service quality.
Questions
What jewelry repair services do you offer?
We provide ring sizing, chain soldering, prong replacement, and stone setting services with most repairs completed within one week.
Can you create custom jewelry designs?
Yes, our designers work with CAD technology and hand-drafting to create bespoke pieces tailored to your preferences and budget.
Do you sell certified diamonds?
We offer both GIA-certified natural diamonds and IGI-certified lab-grown diamonds with full documentation available.
What are your business hours?
We're open Tuesday-Friday 10am-5pm, Saturday 10am-3pm, and closed Sunday & Monday.
How long have you been in business?
We've been serving customers since 1935 as a fourth-generation family-owned jewelry store.
Do you offer watch repair services?
Yes, we replace watch batteries, repair bands, and service mechanical timepieces with specialized equipment.
Reviews (7)
Casey Flewellen
Nov 03, 2021 Report
Dean and the Shallow team did an amazing job on updating my setting for my ring! When all other jewelers told me it wasn't possible, Dean was able to take my idea to a sketch to reality. I could not be more pleased with the result!
Lauren Arne
Oct 14, 2021 Report
Highly recommend Dean and Shallow Jewelers for all of your jewelry needs including repair and cleaning. My husband picked out my engagement ring at Shallow Jewelers after the recommendation from his parents who are also loyal customers. We then went together and picked out my matching wedding band and his wedding band. The customer service is great, and Dean made us feel comfortable and excited about our big purchases. We later brought in a family ring that I was given, and Dean was able to clean and repair this ring within 1 week prior to the wedding, and cleaned up our rings to "showroom" ready
Tyler Petrovich
Aug 03, 2021 Report
Dean helped me greatly, finding the perfect ring for my soon to be wife. Couldn't ask for better service, or a more quality diamond with his help. The service and prices were remarkable. Glad to have found what I needed with people who care about their customers and jewelry
Karen Raasch
Aug 03, 2021 Report
Shallow Jewelers is a friendly, experienced and talented store. They go above and beyond excellent customer service. Mike was especially accommodating. They are my go-to jeweler!
Dennis Yoerin
Jun 03, 2021 Report
Family owned, free standing building in a neighborhood thats passed through Shallow family for generations. This is our jeweler of choice for purchases, repairs, insurance appraisals and other needs. Staff knows their product and if they don't have in stock what you seek, they will bring it in. It's great to see the same faces in a business. Dean Shallow is on site along Mike M and others. This is a solid and trustworthy retail jewelry store that lives by referrals and repeat clients. Employees have tons of longevity and experience in jewelry. Management wants a sale but just as important is they
Thomas Sturino
Feb 17, 2021 Report
Love the quality and customer service. My dad used Shallow for decades and I loved coming in when I was a kid. When the time came for my big ring purchase, it was an easy choice to go with Shallow. They recognize me and wife every time we come back and the always take such great care of us. It's worth a visit just for the quick ring polish! Can't wait to visit again
Erica P.
Feb 26, 2019 Report
If I could give Shallow Jeweler 10 stars I would! Dean Shallow was amazing to work with!! I came into his shop randomly one day with an idea in my head and loose stones. He worked with me right away to come up with a design that I was envisioning. I'd highly recommend Shallow Jewelers for any of your jewelry needs.