Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Source for Diamonds and Custom Jewelry in Milwaukee
Robert Haack Diamonds has been a trusted name in the jewelry industry since 1948, specializing in diamonds, custom jewelry, and cash-for-gold services. Our commitment to professionalism and expertise ensures clients receive expertly crafted, high-value diamonds and personalized service in a welcoming environment. With two locations in Wisconsin, we offer a vast selection of engagement rings, wedding bands, estate jewelry, and colored gemstones, alongside appraisal, repair, and custom design services. Our team of certified gemologists and master goldsmiths provides tailored solutions, including 3D design technology for custom pieces and insurance replacement assistance.

Recognized by prestigious accreditations like the Gemological Institute of America, we prioritize transparency, fairness, and customer satisfaction. For over six decades, we have served Milwaukee, Greenfield, and surrounding areas, building lasting relationships through integrity and exceptional craftsmanship. Whether you seek a unique custom creation or a trusted buyer for gold and diamonds, our family-owned business combines tradition with innovation to meet your needs.
Services
Custom Jewelry Cash for Gold Diamond Appraisals Jewelry Repair Lab Grown Diamonds Estate Jewelry Insurance Replacement Custom Engraving 3D Design Consultation Gemstone Recycling
Details
  • Year established: 1948
Highlights and features
  • We offer 64+ years of expertise in diamonds and custom jewelry.
  • Our 3D design technology enables personalized, one-of-a-kind creations.
  • We guarantee fair pricing and transparency in our cash-for-gold program.
  • Certified gemologists provide accurate, detailed jewelry appraisals.
  • Locally owned and committed to Wisconsin community values.
Associations and certifications
  • Gemological Institute of America
  • American Gem Society
  • American Society of Appraisers
  • Appraisal Institute
  • Certified Appraisers Guild of America
  • European Gemological Laboratory
Services
Custom Jewelry
Robert Haack Diamonds creates one-of-a-kind jewelry using 3D design technology and traditional hand-carving methods. Clients collaborate with master goldsmiths to transform ideas into unique pieces, with production timelines ranging from four to six weeks. This service caters to those seeking personalized engagement rings, heirlooms, or statement pieces.
Cash for Gold
We offer competitive cash payments for gold, silver, diamonds, and unwanted jewelry, including estate pieces and dental gold. Our transparent process includes on-site evaluation and immediate payment, with options to trade items for new jewelry or recycle materials for custom designs.
Diamond Appraisals
Certified gemologists provide detailed appraisals for insurance, estates, or divorces, with reports completed in four days or less. Services include assessing diamonds, gemstones, and fine jewelry, regardless of purchase origin, ensuring accurate valuations for replacement or documentation purposes.
Jewelry Repair
Our master goldsmiths handle repairs from simple fixes to complex restorations, with most jobs completed within a week. Clients receive free estimates and transparent pricing, ensuring quality craftsmanship for resizing, polishing, or reconstructing damaged or sentimental pieces.
Lab Grown Diamonds
We offer certified lab-grown diamonds in various shapes and sizes, including round, oval, and princess cuts. These ethically sourced stones are priced competitively, with options for engagement rings, investment pieces, or custom settings, available for viewing at both Wisconsin locations.
People
Bret Eulberg
Owner
Bret Eulberg, owner of Robert Haack Diamonds, is a respected figure in the jewelry industry. Known for his expertise and fairness, he has been featured in local news segments on gold selling and appraisal practices. With over six decades of combined experience, he upholds the company's tradition of integrity and customer-centric service.
Questions
What services does Robert Haack Diamonds offer?
We specialize in diamonds, custom jewelry, cash-for-gold, appraisals, jewelry repair, and lab-grown diamonds. Our services also include insurance replacement, estate jewelry sales, and personalized engraving.
Do you buy gold and diamonds?
Yes, we pay cash for gold, silver, diamonds, and unwanted jewelry, including coins, dental gold, and estate pieces. We also offer trade-in options and recycling for custom designs.
How can I sell my jewelry?
Visit our Greenfield or Brookfield location, where our experts will evaluate your items and provide a fair, on-the-spot offer. No obligation to proceed, and payment is immediate if accepted.
Do you offer custom jewelry design?
Yes, our master goldsmiths use 3D technology and traditional methods to create bespoke pieces. Bring your ideas for a consultation, and we'll guide you through the design and production process.
Are your diamonds certified?
Our lab-grown diamonds are independently certified, and we provide appraisal documentation for natural diamonds. We work with trusted certification bodies to ensure quality and authenticity.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Milwaukee, Greenfield, Waukesha, and northern Wisconsin communities, with two convenient locations offering the same inventory and services.
Videos
Reviews (5)
Dena Rubnitz
Sep 17, 2021 Report
Great customer service! Leslie is quite knowledgeable wonderful to work with. I would recommend Robert Haack to anyone!!
Kathy Mudrock
Aug 14, 2021 Report
No pressure sales … having a gold allergy (yep, I’m allergic to gold) Leslie took her time to listen and understand what was important to me when deciding on a new ‘platinum wedding band and engagement ring’!… With a little research and great recommendations I’m in love with my new bling - thanks to my Hubby and Team Robert Haack💍❤️
Dmitar Jovic
May 20, 2021 Report
No pressure, very professional and helpful. My selection for my wife was brought to mine and my wife’s satisfaction and upon returning for getting next size bigger result was same. D. Jovic
Susan Scott Stanford
Mar 05, 2020 Report
I was very pleased from start to finish. They were professional, helpful, knowledgeable, and also sent me on my way with a beautifully polished and buffed ring. I hardly remembered that it could look as beautiful as it did! I would definitely go there again for my jewelry or estate needs.
Mallory Ann Umar
Jan 05, 2020 Report
I just discovered Robert Haack Diamonds this week and I absolutely LOVE the company. The owner, Brett, and his staff are patient and personalize the shopping experience. I’ve gone back four times in a week and… I bought 8 pieces and counting. I don’t think I’ll shop anywhere else for my jewelry again. The deals are so great, but the people-centered atmosphere keeps me coming back. The way a company treats you is important. Thank you for making me feel like family ❤️ 💍 💎. I’ll be back soon!