Business Details
Authentic Italian Dining in Boca Grande, FL
Welcome to Sisters Restaurant, where passion for authentic Italian cuisine meets decades of culinary expertise. Founded by twin sisters Lisa Ianitas and Paula Marums, our establishment brings over 30 years of combined dining industry experience to Boca Grande, FL. Our head chef, Monty Caputo, studied in Napoli, Italy, and has honed his craft for over three decades, ensuring every dish reflects traditional Italian flavors with modern flair. We prioritize fresh, premium ingredients daily, creating overflowingly generous portions that consistently exceed customer expectations. Our commitment to exceptional service is evident in our carefully trained staff, who treat every guest like royalty during their dining experience.Whether you're craving classic Italian dishes or seeking new culinary delights, our menu offers something to satisfy every palate. We take pride in being a local favorite for both residents and visitors, delivering unforgettable meals in a welcoming atmosphere. Our dedication to quality, experience, and customer satisfaction has made us a cornerstone of the Boca Grande dining scene. Come experience why generations of patrons have chosen Sister's for their Italian dining needs.
Services
Italian Cuisine
Dine-in
Takeout
Lunch Menu
Dinner Menu
Children's Menu
Appetizers
Salads
Pizza
Seafood Dishes
Highlights and features
- We offer over 30 years of combined culinary expertise from Chef Monty Caputo.
- Our owners Lisa and Paula bring 30+ years of dining industry experience.
- We use only fresh, premium ingredients daily for authentic Italian flavors.
- Our trained staff provides exceptional, personalized dining experiences.
- We guarantee generous portions that consistently exceed customer expectations.
What people say
Best Italian cuisine
Passionately created dishes
WOWED by meals
Exceptional service
Fresh premium ingredients
Services
Italian Cuisine
Our Italian cuisine features dishes crafted from fresh, premium ingredients daily. Chef Monty Caputo's expertise ensures authentic flavors with a modern twist. Guests enjoy generous portions of classic and innovative Italian dishes in a welcoming atmosphere.
Lunch Menu
The lunch menu offers sandwiches, wraps, baskets, and salads from 11 AM to 4 PM. Options include meatball subs, grilled paninis, and fresh seafood. All meals come with house-made sides for a complete dining experience.
Dinner Menu
Dinner features pasta dishes, seafood, veal, and chicken entrees with house-made sauces. Signature items include baked seafood lasagna and lobster pasta. Dishes are prepared to order using traditional Italian techniques and fresh ingredients.
Takeout
Takeout service provides full menu access for meals to enjoy off-site. Orders are carefully packaged to maintain quality. Guests can call ahead or order in person for quick pickup of freshly prepared Italian dishes.
Children's Menu
The children's menu offers kid-friendly Italian dishes like chicken tenders, mac and cheese, and pasta marinara. Meals are served in appropriate portions with house-made sides, ensuring quality and taste for younger guests.
People
Lisa Ianitas
Co-Owner
Lisa Ianitas brings over 30 years of dining industry experience to Sister's Restaurant. She focuses on customer service and menu development, ensuring every guest receives exceptional treatment and quality Italian cuisine.
Paula Marums
Co-Owner
Paula Marums co-owns Sister's Restaurant with her twin sister Lisa. With decades of hospitality experience, she oversees daily operations and staff training to maintain the restaurant's high service standards.
Monty Caputo
Head Chef
Chef Monty Caputo has over 30 years of culinary expertise, including formal training in Napoli, Italy. He creates authentic Italian dishes using fresh ingredients daily, ensuring every meal meets traditional standards.
Questions
What are Sister's Restaurant hours of operation?
We're open Monday through Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM.
Does Sister's offer takeout options?
Yes, we provide full menu access for takeout orders during regular business hours.
What type of cuisine does Sister's serve?
We specialize in authentic Italian-American dishes made from fresh, premium ingredients daily.
Are there vegetarian options available on the menu?
Yes, we offer several vegetarian dishes including salads, pasta marinara, and vegetable calzones.
How experienced is the restaurant's chef?
Chef Monty Caputo has over 30 years of culinary experience, including formal training in Napoli, Italy.
Does Sister's have a children's menu?
Yes, we offer a dedicated children's menu with kid-friendly Italian dishes available daily.
Reviews (5)
Nancy O.
Jan 08, 2022
Report
What a wonderful place! I was on a bike tour today of the island. The sisters accommodated our group of 22 with great service and fantastic food. I'd strongly recommend the blackened grouper. Delicious. I'll return again!
Maria R.
Jan 03, 2022
Report
We went for lunch as a party of 9. The grouper fingers were the star of show, perfectly battered, the fish was fresh and the portions were generous. There was less satisfaction with the ultimate fish sandwich, which had the same fish but a lot less of it for the same price. Others ordered burgers and pizzas, which were pronounced OK. The only disappointment was the Caesar salad, which had mass produced dressing and croutons and was quite expensive for the portion. Service was friendly and attentive.
David Parker
Dec 30, 2021
Report
Terrible customer service. Called ahead two hours before closing on multiple attempts. The phone just rang with no answer. Walked over to order carry out or dine in. I was told no more service and as pointed out previously I had called two hours before closing. At that time the counter lady pointed at the phone and showed me that she had unplugged the phone. If I was your owner I would be taking a real close look at my staff. My order potentially would have been a large cheese pizza and jalapeo poppers. Seems this could be done in two hours but not by people that dont want to work. Guaranteed
Jp Allen
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Nice restaurant. We had lunch and the food was quite nice. The Stromboli has more onions that I would have liked but the meatball sub was incredible.
Sara G. G.
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Food was amazing ! Ordered the BLT , very fresh ! We brought in our two pups , they immediately got them two iced water bowls and made them feel comfortable. Definitely will be returning !