Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Lambertville's Oldest Family-Run Italian Restaurant Since 1968
Nicola Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of Lambertville's dining scene since 1968. Our story began with Nicolo Maltese, a young immigrant from Italy who brought his passion for authentic Italian cuisine to New Jersey. Over five decades, we've evolved from a small pizzeria into a beloved family-run establishment serving handmade pasta, fresh antipasto, and legendary pizza made with dough mixed daily. Under the leadership of Sal MalteseNicolo's sonwe continue the family tradition with three generations working side-by-side.

Our commitment to quality ingredients like Boars Head meats and house-made sauces has earned us a loyal following. While anchovies may no longer dominate toppings, our dedication to traditional methods and community values remains unchanged. From our kitchen in historic Lambertville, we serve both classic favorites and modern creations, maintaining the same warmth that has welcomed generations of diners.
Services
Pizza Delivery Italian Entrees Takeout Service Homemade Lasagna Catering Options
Details
  • Year established: 1968
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1968 with three generations working together
  • Homemade lasagna and fresh mozzarella made daily
  • Delivery to Lambertville and New Hope areas
  • Uses premium Boars Head meats in all antipasto dishes
  • Maintains original 1968 pizza-making techniques while modernizing menus
Services
Pizza Delivery
We offer delivery to Lambertville and New Hope areas with a $3 fee. Service ends one hour before closing. Our single driver handles deliveries, with priority given to central locations during busy periods. Freshly made pizzas travel well in our insulated bags.
Italian Entrees
Our menu features classic Italian dishes including baked ziti, manicotti, and homemade lasagna. Every entree comes with house salad and garlic bread. Vegetarian and meat-based options available daily.
Takeout Service
Takeout available during all operating hours. Customers receive fresh, made-to-order meals packaged for convenient transport. We maintain food quality standards for both dine-in and takeout orders.
Catering Options
We provide catering services for local events featuring our signature pizzas and Italian specialties. Orders require advance notice and include delivery within our service area.
Homemade Lasagna
Our house-made lasagna uses fresh pasta sheets layered with homemade sauce and cheeses. Each serving contains five meat layers with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheeses baked to golden perfection.
People
Nicolo Maltese
Founder
Founded the pizzeria in 1968 after arriving in America at age 19. Brought authentic Italian pizza-making techniques to Lambertville and trained his family in traditional methods.
Sal Maltese
Current Owner
Second-generation owner who has worked in the pizzeria since childhood. Maintains his father's traditions while overseeing daily operations and menu evolution through four decades of service.
Wendy Maltese
Co-Owner
Supports business operations alongside husband Sal. Helps manage front-of-house operations and customer relations with the same hospitality that built our community reputation.
Alex Maltese
Family Member
Third-generation team member working alongside parents and aunt. Learns all aspects of restaurant operations while continuing the family's commitment to quality and service.
Stella Maltese
Family Member
Active in daily operations and representing the family's continuing legacy. Works with her brother and cousin to maintain standards while preparing for future leadership roles.
Questions
What areas do you deliver to?
We deliver within Lambertville, New Hope, Mount Airy, Stockton, and West Amwell NJ. $3 delivery fee applies.
When did the restaurant open?
Nicola Pizzeria opened in 1968 and has remained family-owned for over 55 years.
What makes your lasagna special?
Our homemade lasagna uses fresh pasta sheets layered with house-made sauce and five cheeses for a rich, authentic flavor.
Do you accept credit cards?
Yes, we accept major credit cards with a 3.5% surcharge to cover processing costs.
Are there vegetarian options?
Yes, our Stuffed Veggie Pizza and Eggplant Parmigiana are popular vegetarian choices.
What are your hours on weekends?
We're open Friday and Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM for lunch and dinner service.
Reviews (6)
Chris G.
Oct 31, 2021 Report
This place was great. I totally recommend stopping by and checking them out - and grabbing a slice, calzone, or even a full pie. Their Sicilian pizza pie was delicious, and a must try! Their calzone, we did sausage and ricotta on it, blew us away! The sausage was ground on the fine side, which was perfect for us - we have a Infant learning to eat. The ricotta tho... oh my god. The texture was so incredible. You gotta have one of their calzones!!! We got to chat a little bit with the owners as we sat and ate in their lil dining room area and they were really nice. I wish we had pizza like this
Warren B.
Oct 18, 2021 Report
The best cheesesteak I've had in NJ. Just the right amount of savory to sublime. Worth the drive from Morristown. Nothing else compares.
Mc Tucker
Sep 28, 2021 Report
Nicole's Pizza is a Lambertville institution and rightfully so. They have excellent food and are a family. Their pizza sauce isn't acidic and their pizza is delicious. Their dinners are a good value, I usually order their eggplant parm, it is yummy and has never been greasy.
Rick K.
Sep 11, 2021 Report
Worst pizza i've ever tasted. Honestly. The staff conveys the message directly to the customer that they are not happy to be there.
Steven Hall
Jul 13, 2021 Report
This is the spot to grab a pie in Lambertville. Thin crispy crust and the sauce isnt too sweet but rather has zest and fresh taste. The staff was great in fixing an ordering late even though I order close to closing they didnt raise any issues. I will definitely be ordering from here again.
Caroline Buckley
May 28, 2021 Report
New to the area and so happy to have found our pizza place! Delicious pizza with any toppings. Veggie and the pepperoni are our favorites. Also, super happy about the excellent cheesesteaks. Any Philly fan knows its gotta start with a good roll...