Which Insurance Agency Should You Choose in Pittsburgh, PA?

Review 19 local insurance agencies in Pittsburgh, PA and check what each business offers. Read customer feedback, compare agency information, and shortlist providers who can help with the types of personal or business insurance you need.
5 reviews
Monica Bonacci
24 Years
Emergency
5 reviews
Monica Bonacci provides personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Pittsburgh, PA. Established in 2002, we combine State Farm's industry leadership with local expertise to deliver tailored protection plans. Our customer-centric approach focuses on building long-term relationships through transparent communication and 24/7 accessibility.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Exceptional service Knowledgeable staff 24/7 assistance
4 reviews
PV Settlement
10 Years
4 reviews
PV Settlement provides comprehensive title insurance and closing services for residential and commercial real estate transactions. Our company specializes in protecting property owners and lenders from financial loss due to title defects through meticulous title searches and insurance policies. With operations in Pennsylvania and Ohio, we combine industry expertise with personalized service to deliver efficient, cost-effective solutions for all parties involved in real estate transactions.
Title Insurance Closing Services Title Search
Smooth transaction Professional team Seamless closing
4 reviews
Steve Metzler
Emergency
4 reviews
Steve Metzler provides personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Pittsburgh. Our agency focuses on protecting clients' assets and future through customizable coverage options and competitive rates. With decades of industry experience and 24/7 customer support, we deliver trusted insurance services tailored to individual and commercial needs.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Excellent customer service Knowledgeable and patient staff Quick response times
Cusumano Insurance Agency provides comprehensive personal and business insurance solutions to clients in Pittsburgh, PA and Western Pennsylvania. As an independent agency since 1958, we offer tailored insurance products from multiple carriers to protect clients from financial risks. Our experienced team delivers personalized service for life, health, and specialty insurance needs.
Personal Insurance Business Insurance Life & Health Insurance
Quick response Coverage options Long-term reliability
Pierson & Scott Insurance Agency is an independent Pennsylvania-based insurance provider offering personalized coverage for individuals and businesses. We specialize in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, helping clients secure tailored plans at competitive rates. With decades of local expertise, we prioritize customer service and long-term partnerships.
Auto Insurance Homeowner Insurance Life Insurance
3 reviews
George O'Korn
Emergency
3 reviews
George O'Korn provides customizable auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Pittsburgh, PA. With over 40 years of local expertise and State Farm's nationwide resources, we offer personalized coverage options and exceptional claims service. Our customer-centric approach combines technical expertise with community knowledge to deliver comprehensive protection strategies.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Highly recommend Fast response time Customer service exists
Kelly Insurance Group specializes in custom commercial insurance solutions for high-risk and unconventional industries. We provide tailored coverage for specialized operations including crane operators, arborists, film productions, and contractors. With access to top-rated carriers and 24/7 client support, we deliver reliable protection and personalized service backed by decades of insurance expertise.
Business Insurance Cyber Insurance Personal Insurance
Highmark Direct offer personalized health insurance services, including Medicare, ACA, and individual/family plans. Our licensed associates provide in-store, phone, or virtual consultations to simplify enrollment, billing, and plan selection. With 12 locations in Pennsylvania and New York, we combine expert guidance with community-focused wellness programs.
Medicare Consultations ACA Enrollment Individual Insurance
Single Source Benefits provides comprehensive personal, commercial, and health insurance solutions in Pittsburgh, PA. With over 30 years of experience, we offer tailored coverage options including auto, home, life, and Medicare plans, alongside financial planning services. Our team prioritizes client education, community engagement, and cost-effective insurance strategies for individuals and businesses across southwest Pennsylvania.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Accommodating, professional, helpful Surprisingly flexible and in-touch Strong ties with the community
Affolder & Associates is a locally-owned independent insurance agency providing comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions. With over five decades of experience, we specialize in customizing coverage plans through multiple carriers to meet individual client needs. Our services include home, auto, business owners, cyber liability, and specialized insurance products across Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Ohio, and West Virginia.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Owners Insurance
Palmieri & Associates is a Pittsburgh-based financial advisory firm specializing in tax planning, estate preservation, and retirement strategies. We help clients protect assets through customized insurance solutions, long-term care planning, and wealth transfer techniques. Our services combine personalized guidance with proven expertise to create tax-efficient financial roadmaps.
Tax Preparation Estate Planning Life Insurance
A For The People Insurance Agency is a Pittsburgh-based independent insurance provider offering personalized auto, home, life, health, and business insurance solutions. Established in 1991, we serve clients across eight states, prioritizing transparent, budget-friendly coverage. Our team leverages relationships with multiple carriers to deliver tailored insurance strategies that balance protection and affordability.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Commercial Property Insurance
Great service Found us coverage Community involvement
Pennsylvania Land Titles provides expert title insurance and real estate settlement services across Pennsylvania. Our core mission ensures smooth property transactions through thorough title examinations, secure escrow management, and personalized client support. With extensive experience handling thousands of closings, we serve buyers, sellers, lenders, and realtors with transparent communication and professional expertise.
Title Insurance Title Search Closing Services
Easiest closing ever Professional and friendly Seamless experience
Don Panigall
18 Years
Emergency
4 reviews
Don Panigall
18 Years
Emergency
4 reviews
Don Panigall provides personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Pittsburgh, PA. Our agency combines State Farm's national resources with local expertise to deliver tailored coverage. We prioritize customer satisfaction through competitive rates, 24/7 support, and community-focused service.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Quick response times Competitive rates Personalized service
Clare Agency
50+ Years
Emergency
2 reviews
Clare Agency
50+ Years
Emergency
2 reviews
Clare Agency provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions across Western Pennsylvania. Specializing in auto, home, life, business, and specialty coverage, we partner with top insurers to deliver customized protection. Our family-owned agency combines 75+ years of collective expertise with personalized service to meet evolving client needs.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Pennsylvania Health Insurance provides comprehensive health coverage solutions for individuals, families, and businesses across Pennsylvania. We specialize in Marketplace plans through Pennie, Medigap policies, Medicaid eligibility, and off-Exchange options with multiple carriers. Our services include free plan comparisons, federal subsidy optimization, and expert guidance through enrollment processes.
Health Insurance Plans Medicare Supplement Medicaid Assistance
Free quotes Expert guidance Multiple carriers
Not rated yet
Ifft & Palmer
50+ Years
Not rated yet
Ifft & Palmer provides tailored personal and commercial insurance solutions, employee benefits, and private client services. As an independent agency since 1969, we prioritize client needs by leveraging a network of top-rated carriers to create customized coverage. Our expertise in risk management and asset protection ensures clients receive strategic, comprehensive solutions aligned with their financial goals.
Personal Insurance Commercial Insurance Employee Benefits
Liberty Insurance Agency provides commercial, employee benefits, and personal insurance solutions tailored to businesses and individuals. Specializing in risk management, claims advocacy, and customized coverage plans, we serve diverse industries with expertise in construction, healthcare, manufacturing, and more. Our client-centric approach combines personalized service with access to over 25 major insurance carriers.
Business Insurance Employee Benefits Personal Insurance
Excellent service Knowledgeable staff Timely responses
National Health Agency provides customized health insurance solutions for individuals, seniors, and businesses across 13 states. We specialize in matching clients with affordable plans that adapt to life changes, offering expertise in Medicare supplements, group policies, and individual coverage. Our licensed team prioritizes personalized service and transparent guidance.
Health Insurance Medicare Supplement Plans Group Insurance
Carnegie (5.1 mi) McKees Rocks (4.1 mi) Bridgeville (8.4 mi) McKeesport (9.5 mi) Oakmont (9.8 mi) Coraopolis (10.5 mi) Monroeville (11.0 mi) Wexford (13.2 mi) Venetia (13.6 mi) Warrendale (15.3 mi)