Which Restaurant Should You Choose in Nantucket, MA?

Review 2 local restaurants in Nantucket, MA and check what each location offers. Read customer feedback, compare menus and dining details, and shortlist places that serve the type of cuisine or dining experience you want.
5 reviews
Pi Pizzeria
25 Years
5 reviews
Pi Pizzeria serves authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and classic Italian-American cuisine on Nantucket Island. Using time-honored techniques and fresh ingredients like imported San Marzano tomatoes and house-grated mozzarella, we deliver an immersive Italian dining experience. Our warm ambiance and commitment to quality make us a destination for both locals and visitors seeking traditional flavors with a personal touch.
Wood-Fired Pizza Italian Cuisine Take-Out Orders
Not rated yet
The Chanticleer
23 Years
Not rated yet
The Chanticleer offers an exceptional dining experience in Siasconset, MA, blending historic charm with modern culinary innovation. Located in a rose-covered cottage adjacent to self-sustaining gardens, we serve seasonal menus developed by Executive Chef Andre Miller. Our five elegantly appointed dining rooms and lush outdoor garden accommodate romantic dinners, family gatherings, and special events.
Lunch Service Dinner Service Private Dining
Chatham (28.4 mi) New Bedford (49.6 mi) Edgartown (22.7 mi) Oak Bluffs (26.7 mi) Falmouth (32.3 mi) Brewster (32.9 mi) Eastham (38.3 mi) Wellfleet (44.8 mi)