Business Details
Insurance That Puts You First
At MMA Insurance Agency, we take pride in offering a client-first approach to insurance solutions. With over 90 years of combined experience, our independent agency specializes in personal, business, Medicare, and employee benefits insurance. Headquartered in Pickerington, Ohio, we serve clients across Ohio and several other states, including Florida, Georgia, Illinois, and Texas. Our team of licensed advisors is committed to helping clients protect their futures through tailored coverage options.We prioritize proactive service, regularly reviewing policies to ensure competitive pricing and optimal coverage. As a multi-award-winning agency, we combine industry expertise with personalized attention to deliver exceptional service. Our heritage of leadership and community focus drives us to exceed client expectations daily. Whether you're an individual, family, or business owner, we're here to provide comprehensive insurance solutions that meet your unique needs.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Medicare Plans
Business Insurance
Employee Benefits
Health Insurance
Commercial Bonds
Long-Term Care
Disability Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer 90 years of combined insurance expertise and industry knowledge.
- Our independent agency status provides access to multiple insurance carriers.
- We prioritize proactive policy reviews to ensure competitive pricing annually.
- Our client-first approach focuses on personalized service and tailored solutions.
- We serve clients across 16 states with localized insurance expertise.
What people say
Excellent service
Best coverage options
Proactive renewal shopping
Great guidance
Positive experiences
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies provide comprehensive protection for personal and commercial vehicles. We offer customizable coverage options including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Our experienced agents help clients find competitive rates while ensuring adequate protection for their specific needs.
Home Insurance
We provide homeowners insurance policies that protect against property damage, liability claims, and additional living expenses. Our coverage options include standard homeowners policies and specialized coverage for unique properties. We work with multiple carriers to find the best protection at competitive rates.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance solutions include term and permanent policies designed to protect families and businesses. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on financial obligations and future needs. Our advisors provide guidance on policy selection and beneficiary planning.
Medicare Plans
We offer Medicare Advantage, Part D prescription drug plans, and supplemental insurance options. Our specialists help seniors navigate Medicare enrollment and coverage choices. We provide personalized comparisons to help clients select plans that meet their healthcare needs and budget.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions include commercial property, liability, and specialized industry coverage. We offer surety bonds, builders risk policies, and industry-specific protection for contractors and medical offices. Our team helps businesses assess risk exposure and implement comprehensive insurance programs.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer personal insurance (auto, home, life), Medicare plans, business insurance, employee benefits, and specialized industry coverage.
Do you serve clients outside Ohio?
Yes, we serve clients in 16 states including Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Texas, and Virginia.
How do you help clients save on insurance?
We proactively shop policies annually and compare multiple carriers to find competitive rates while maintaining appropriate coverage.
What makes you different from other agencies?
Our 90-year heritage, independent status, and client-first approach with personalized service set us apart from competitors.
Can you help with Medicare enrollment?
Yes, our specialists provide guidance on Medicare Advantage plans, Part D coverage, and supplemental insurance options.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Visit our Service Center online or contact us directly at 614-834-6624 to report a claim immediately.
Reviews (2)
Tom S.
Apr 09, 2015
Report
I have been engaged in a lengthy dispute with Mark Matthews and MMA insurance. Short version is that the agency left the my detached garage uncovered. I didn't find out until the garage was severely damaged in a crash a few years later. The carrier told me the garage was never included in the list of coverages. I'm sure this move saved me a few dollars to give me a low premium, but it cost me thousands for trusting their guidance. They like to say they work for YOU and not an insurance company. They sure wern't working for me when they've fought me every step of the way to
Branda K.
Apr 22, 2014
Report
Bad service, never return calls, only time they will call you is when you miss a payment, it took over two weeks to cancel my insurance, in the end, I had to call the insurance company myself to cancel it. After you buy the deal through them, they would never do service for you again. Thank you, never again!!
