Business Details
Your Destination for Unforgettable Waterfront Dining in Stuart
At Sailor's Return Restaurant, we bring decades of culinary expertise and a passion for exceptional dining to Stuart, Florida. With 27 years of experience in the food and beverage industry, including ownership of Stuart's renowned Jolly Sailor Restaurant, Bob Davis and his wife Tracy envisioned a destination where waterfront elegance meets world-class cuisine. Our 8,000-square-foot venue, nestled on Sunset Bay Harbour, offers guests a meticulously crafted menu featuring seafood, steaks, and American fare, including signature dishes like pan-seared blackened snapper and Pork Chop Milanese. Under the leadership of General Manager Michael LaMattina and Chef Keith Meyers, we combine technical precision with warm hospitality to create unforgettable experiences. Whether dining al fresco, hosting a private event, or enjoying live music, our team ensures every detail reflects our commitment to quality.We pride ourselves on sourcing fresh ingredients, maintaining rigorous kitchen standards, and fostering a culture of service excellence. Our 220-seat space with two bars accommodates both intimate gatherings and large celebrations, complemented by customizable banquet menus. From the first reservation to the final course, we prioritize consistency, innovation, and guest satisfaction. Our waterfront location, featuring 930 feet of courtesy docking, invites patrons to arrive by boat and immerse themselves in Florida's coastal charm. As a locally owned establishment, we remain dedicated to evolving with our community while upholding the traditions that define our culinary identity.
Services
Seafood
Steaks
American Fare
Banquet Menus
Happy Hour
Live Music
Gift Cards
Reservations
Custom Events
Dockside Dining
Highlights and features
- We offer 27 years of expertise in creating memorable dining experiences.
- Our waterfront location provides a unique tropical harbor setting.
- Signature dishes highlight our chefs' culinary innovation and technical skill.
- Collaboration with seasoned professionals ensures top-quality service.
- Customizable banquet menus cater to events of all sizes and themes.
What people say
Awesome service
5 star food
Reasonably priced
Everything was Amazing
Thanks @ Patrick
Services
Seafood
Our seafood menu features locally sourced, sustainably caught fish prepared using time-honored techniques. Signature offerings include pan-seared blackened snapper and lobster tail specials. Every dish emphasizes natural flavors through precise preparation methods.
Steaks
We serve premium aged beef cuts including 16oz and 18oz ribeyes. Meats are hand-selected for marbling and cooked to perfection using high-heat searing methods. Complemented by house-made sauces and seasonal sides.
Banquet Menus
Customizable banquet options accommodate groups from 10 to 200 guests. Our culinary team creates tailored menus for weddings, corporate events, and private celebrations while maintaining restaurant-quality presentation and service standards.
Happy Hour
Enjoy handcrafted cocktails, premium wines, and specialty drinks during daily happy hour sessions. Featured items include the Blazin Apple Cider with Fireball and Stoli Vanilla Vodka served with cinnamon-sugar rimmed glasses.
Live Music
Regularly scheduled live performances enhance the dining atmosphere. Our calendar features local musicians across multiple genres, creating an engaging backdrop for both casual meals and special occasions.
People
Bob Davis
Co-Owner
With 27 years in the food and beverage industry, including ownership of Stuart's Jolly Sailor Restaurant, Bob brings extensive hospitality expertise to Sailor's Return Restaurant's operations and strategic direction.
Tracy Davis
Co-Owner
As co-creator of Sailor's Return Restaurant concept, Tracy contributes hospitality industry knowledge and event planning expertise to ensure exceptional guest experiences and venue management.
Michael LaMattina
General Manager
Michael oversees daily operations, maintaining service standards and coordinating between culinary and front-of-house teams to deliver consistent quality across all guest interactions.
Keith Meyers
Chef
Chef Keith develops menus featuring innovative preparations of seafood and American classics, combining technical expertise with creative presentation to elevate traditional dishes.
Questions
How can I make a reservation at Sailor's Return?
Reservations can be made online through our website or by calling (772) 872-7250 during operating hours.
What special dining events do you offer?
We host weekly events including Wednesday Lobster Night and Thursday Prime Rib Night with specially priced menus.
Can I bring my boat to Sailor's Return?
Yes, we offer 930 feet of courtesy docking space available for guests arriving by boat.
Do you accommodate large groups or private events?
Our venue offers customizable banquet menus and seating for up to 220 guests with dedicated event coordination.
What happy hour specials are available?
Daily happy hour features specialty cocktails like Blazin Apple Cider and discounted wine selections from 11:30 AM to closing.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Jillian Boyd
Jan 02, 2022
Report
Every time we come here, the food is always fantastic and so is the service! The Lobster and the Filet Mignon are favorites, but the their Sailor Burger and their salads are equally delicious!
Rita Brohman
Jan 02, 2022
Report
We spent New Years Eve at Sailors Return and it was sooooo much FUN!! The food was fabulous and hot when it arrived! The service was outstanding, Jake was our server.. so great! The topper was the incredible live band, Sierra! This has been one of our favorite restaurants since we moved here a year ago but we could not be more happy we chose it to spend our New Year with oh, forgot to say they handed out complimentary champagne, hats and noisemakers for midnight! There was no additional cover charge but we did tip our servers 30%, they earned it!!
Dee Gee
Dec 15, 2021
Report
We had a retirement luncheon there for 30 people on December 4th. Seating outdoors they set up the tables perfectly. The event planner was so kind and informative. The weather was perfect and the view amazing. The whole staff was very warm and accommodating. Our waiter was very attentive and had a great personality. Food was excellent, generous portions and arrived quickly.
Price's during lunch are great. Valet parking is well worth a tip in and out as street parking is difficult. Thank you Sailors Return for making us feel very welcome and for making this day very memorable for our guest of
Price's during lunch are great. Valet parking is well worth a tip in and out as street parking is difficult. Thank you Sailors Return for making us feel very welcome and for making this day very memorable for our guest of
Doug Gamlin
Dec 13, 2021
Report
The staff was extremely friendly and very honest about the menu. I had one of the best fish and chips I've ever had there. Great batter that was nice and golden crispy. The view is excellent with lots of big boats all the time. Can dock right at the restaurant. Also there is parking very close to the building. Excellent place to have a few drinks with friends on a nice day.
LynnMarie Boltze
Nov 25, 2021
Report
Considered a high-end restaurant they must have had an off night. The server was kind however none in our group could recall the offer for appetizers which we missed out on. The Chilean Bass was amazing the others at the table said their meals were quite good to ok. Being a connoisseur of bourbon and whiskey I asked for an Old Fashioned. The old fashioned came with a slice of Orange and loose ice. The server was honest to say the bartender and the bar not so much.
$15 a drink they did not offer high-end whiskey or bourbon. Just the lower end. Overall not the experience I anticipated
Cheers
$15 a drink they did not offer high-end whiskey or bourbon. Just the lower end. Overall not the experience I anticipated
Cheers
Sam M.
Sep 13, 2021
Report
We had an ok experience, when we came the indoors was largely empty, we asked for a window seat but a reservation was required to sit there so we were sat next to the loud bar. The waitress was great. The food was ok, nothing special for the price tag.
Joni Crane Keller Williams Of The Palm Beaches
Aug 29, 2021
Report
This has become my favorite restaurant in this area. This past month I arranged for a group of friends to meet for dinner. The manager and bartender were so accommodating for everyone. They held our table open while we had a little Happy Hour and did not rush us. We felt that we were their honored guests. The food and service was more than excellent.