Business Details
47 Years
experience
Trusted Local Insurance Solutions in Circleville, OH
Founded in 1979, Anderson Insurance has served families, farms, and businesses across Circleville, Ohio, and surrounding communities. As an independent agency rooted in trust, we prioritize personalized service, offering a wide range of affordable insurance solutions tailored to real-life needs. Our commitment to honesty and local expertise ensures clients receive coverage that protects homes, vehicles, health, and livelihoods. Led by John Moats, our team combines over 15 years of industry experience with a client-first philosophy established by founder Terry Anderson.We specialize in homeowners, auto, life, farm, and commercial insurance, emphasizing transparency and support beyond policy sales. With 45+ years of collective experience, we provide practical guidance from quote to claim, serving Fairfield, Ross, and Fayette Counties. Our mission remains unchanged: treat clients like neighbors, delivering peace of mind through reliable, customized coverage. This dedication has earned us a reputation as a trusted, community-focused agency since our inception.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Automobile Insurance
Life Insurance
Farm Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1979
Highlights and features
- We're an independent agency that works for you, not insurers.
- Our team has 45+ years of combined insurance expertise.
- Local agents provide personalized guidance tailored to your needs.
- We partner with top-rated insurance providers for reliable coverage.
- Client-first philosophy prioritizes transparency and long-term support.
What people say
Best experience ever
Wonderful service
Nedra is the best
Personalized guidance
Trusted coverage
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Protect your home and belongings with flexible, affordable policies tailored to your needs. We offer comprehensive coverage for houses, personal property, and liability, ensuring peace of mind for Circleville residents. Our local agents provide personalized guidance to match your budget and future goals.
Automobile Insurance
Secure coverage for cars, trucks, RVs, and motorcycles with customizable plans. Our policies adapt to your driving habits and priorities, offering protection that moves with you across Ohio. We simplify finding affordable rates while maintaining essential coverage for daily commutes and weekend trips.
Life Insurance
Create a lasting legacy with personalized life insurance policies designed to protect loved ones. We help clients choose term or permanent coverage that aligns with income protection, family needs, and long-term security goals. Our approach emphasizes thoughtful planning for future financial stability.
Farm Insurance
Safeguard farming operations with specialized policies for land, equipment, and livestock. Tailored for Ohio family farms, our coverage addresses daily risks while providing practical, durable protection. Local expertise ensures policies meet unique agricultural needs and long-term operational security.
Commercial Insurance
Protect your business with customizable commercial insurance covering property, liability, and employees. We serve small shops to growing operations, offering responsive service and real-world risk management solutions. Policies adapt to specific industry needs while supporting long-term business stability and growth.
People
John Moats
President
With 15+ years in property, casualty, life, health, and annuities, John leads with integrity and hands-on service. He holds a Bachelor of Science from Ohio Northern University and prioritizes client-first solutions.
Relinda Kessler
Licensed Agent
Bringing 27 years of customer service and insurance expertise, Relinda specializes in farm, home, auto, life, and health coverage. Her deep experience ensures comprehensive solutions for clients across multiple insurance sectors.
Brandy Phifer
Licensed Agent
With 20+ years in the industry, Brandy guides clients through life and health insurance with warmth and expertise. She focuses on creating personalized, affordable coverage plans that meet individual and family needs.
Nedra Betts
Licensed Agent
Nedra supports clients with health and life insurance solutions, combining 8 years of experience with a practical approach. She helps individuals navigate complex insurance processes to find affordable, effective coverage options.
Questions
What types of insurance does Anderson Insurance offer?
We provide homeowners, auto, life, farm, and commercial insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs in Ohio.
Is Anderson Insurance a local agency?
Yes, we're a locally rooted, independent agency serving Circleville and surrounding Ohio communities since 1979.
Do you offer 24/7 insurance support?
Our office hours are Monday-Friday 8 AM-5 PM, but we provide dedicated support during business hours and by appointment.
What areas does Anderson Insurance serve?
We serve Circleville, Chillicothe, Lancaster, and communities across Fairfield, Ross, and Fayette Counties in Ohio.
Can I manage insurance policies online?
While we prioritize personal service, we offer digital tools for bill payment and policy management through our client portal.
Reviews (2)
Dustin Mahrt
Sep 02, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
You get A+ service from this long-established community oriented agency ran by forward thinkers. They even have a "chat" feature on their website. 10 out of 10, would recommend!
You get A+ service from this long-established community oriented agency ran by forward thinkers. They even have a "chat" feature on their website. 10 out of 10, would recommend!
Jacob Campbell
Jun 13, 2018
Report
By far the best experience i've ever had with ANY insurance company i've dealt with. Nedra is the best! Thanks again!
