Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Modern American Restaurant in Fayetteville
Since 2025, Craftsman Wood Grille & Tap House has redefined modern American dining in Fayetteville, NY, combining rustic charm with culinary innovation. Our culinary team meticulously sources local ingredients daily, crafting menus that celebrate regional flavors through wood-fired grilling and house-made specialties. As a recipient of the title Best Restaurant in Fayetteville, we maintain a dual identity as both a dynamic tap house and a refined dining destination. Our open kitchen concept, fire-lit ambiance, and award-winning wine program featuring Finger Lakes vintages create an immersive experience.

With over a decade of collective expertise in hospitality leadership, our team ensures every event, from casual meals to private gatherings, reflects our commitment to quality. We prioritize transparency in ingredient sourcing, maintain a dedicated fryer for dietary needs, and continually refine our craft through seasonal menus and curated bourbon pairings. This approach has established us as a community anchor where culinary tradition meets contemporary innovation.
Services
Wood-Fired Grilling Private Dining Catering Services Craft Beverage Program Seasonal Menus Event Hosting Wine Pairing Events Bourbon Dinners
Details
  • Year established: 2025
Highlights and features
  • Voted Best Restaurant in Fayetteville by local patrons
  • Specializing in wood-fired, locally sourced seasonal menus
  • Award-winning wine program featuring Finger Lakes vintages
  • Private dining spaces for special events and gatherings
  • Catering services with customizable rustic-inspired menus
What people say
Delicious food Attentive service Beautiful decor Extensive gluten-free options Award-winning wine list
Services
Wood-Fired Grilling
Our signature wood-fired grilling technique transforms locally sourced meats and seafood using traditional ember-roasting methods. Every cut of beef, fresh catch, and seasonal vegetable undergoes this process in our open-concept kitchen. The result combines smoky depth with precise temperature control for optimal texture and flavor.
Private Dining
The Craftsman offers fully equipped private dining spaces that accommodate social gatherings and corporate events. Our dedicated room maintains the restaurant's rustic elegance while providing customizable banquet menus and full bar service. Staff coordinate every detail from floral arrangements to audio-visual requirements.
Craft Beverage Program
We curate an evolving beverage program featuring 40+ craft beers, 15 signature cocktails, and 100+ wine options. Our mixologists create seasonal cocktails using house-made syrups and regional spirits. The wine list prioritizes Finger Lakes producers while maintaining global representation across varietals.
Seasonal Menus
Menus change quarterly to reflect local agricultural cycles, featuring fresh produce from Central New York farms. Current offerings include wild mushroom ragout in fall and tomato-burrata salads in summer. Chef-designed tasting menus accompany seasonal wine pairings during special events.
Catering Services
Our catering division provides full-service event dining for weddings and corporate functions. Available menus range from passed appetizers to multi-course plated dinners using the same wood-fired techniques as our restaurant. On-site coordination ensures seamless execution at external venues.
Questions
What makes The Craftsman's wood-fired cooking unique?
We use traditional ember-roasting techniques in an open kitchen, combining oak and hickory woods to enhance natural flavors of locally sourced ingredients.
Do you offer gluten-free dining options?
Our kitchen maintains a dedicated fryer and offers gluten-free alternatives for multiple menu items including burger buns and pasta substitutes.
Can I host private events at The Craftsman?
Our private dining room accommodates up to 50 guests with customizable menus, AV capabilities, and exclusive beverage service for weddings and corporate events.
What is the restaurant's dress code?
We maintain a casual-chic environment where business attire is welcomed but not required, aligning with our refined yet approachable dining philosophy.
Do you provide catering beyond the restaurant?
Yes, our award-winning catering service delivers wood-fired dishes, craft cocktails, and full bar setups to locations across Central New York with on-site preparation.
Reviews (4)
Ondraya De Los Santos
Jan 30, 2022 Report
The ambience of the wood grill and lighting make it cozy and relaxing !! The specials were amazing ! Lobster corn dog is a must, Ribeye with grill shrimp is also a absolute , the dipping sauces chimmiechurrie and bearnaise sauce were perfect with the steak and seafood! Pricey but absolutely worth it.
Nicole Huggler
Jan 13, 2022 Report
The manager, Dan, exceeded our expectations tonight. He was kind and generous! Shayna (sorry is spelling is off), our server, was attentive and personable. This is one of our favorite local spots !
Katrina Kapustay
Nov 30, 2021 Report
All style no substance. Its as if youre paying for the ambiance more than anything. I didnt think that the service was terrible. The food wasnt horrible but it definitely was not worth the prices. The lobster cornbread was three pieces of claw meat deep fried in cornbread, the sea bass was pretty good but the crispy potatoes, they were more display then anything. The burger was a good size but not a $20 burger and then $3 for toppings.
Jordan Angerosa
Nov 22, 2021 Report
Not super impressed, based on the prices the food wasn't particularly at par - some of it was actually pretty mediocre. Much of the food was good, I enjoyed my burger and sweet potatoes fries but, the Cole slaw was terrible and the soup special was bland. The beer menu wasn't super well balanced, some of the descriptions didn't make sense and the prices made me think I was in NYC.