Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Cleveland's Oldest Italian Restaurant Since 1898
Guarino's Restaurant has been a cornerstone of Cleveland's culinary scene since 1898, when Vincenzo Guarino established this beloved institution in Little Italy. Our commitment to authentic Italian cuisine remains unwavering, with generations of the Guarino family perfecting time-honored recipes like our signature marinara sauce and 50-year-old lasagna. We take pride in creating memorable dining experiences through our historic Victorian decor, romantic garden patio seating for 100 guests, and exceptional service that has welcomed everyone from local families to Metropolitan Opera stars.

Our private dining rooms, the Victorian Parlors, continue to host special occasions ranging from intimate gatherings to weddings. While our trumpet vine from Sicily still graces our property, we've maintained modern relevance through strategic expansions and by preserving the warm, cozy ambiance that transports guests to an Old World family home. The third and fourth generations of the Guarino family, including Rachel, Scott, and Scott Jr., personally oversee daily operations to ensure our century-old traditions thrive in contemporary times.
Services
Italian Cuisine Private Dining Catering Live Music Valet Parking Historic Ambiance Garden Patio Wedding Receptions Wine Service Takeout Delivery
Highlights and features
  • We serve century-old Italian recipes perfected by four generations of the Guarino family
  • Our romantic garden patio seats 100 guests and has been named among the city's best outdoor dining spots
  • Private dining options include two Victorian-style parlors accommodating 8-40 guests
  • Live music enhances the dining experience with performances from local musicians
  • We offer valet parking service during peak hours in Cleveland's busy Little Italy neighborhood
What people say
Authentic Italian cuisine Romantic garden patio Historic ambiance Exceptional service Century-old recipes
Services
Italian Cuisine
Our Italian cuisine features house-made pasta, seafood specialties, and classic entrees using recipes perfected over four generations. Dishes like our 50-year-old lasagna and house-seasoned calamari showcase traditional techniques with modern presentation. The menu balances classic Italian flavors with contemporary culinary expectations.
Private Dining
Private dining options include two Victorian-style parlors accommodating 8-40 guests and an outdoor garden seating 100 guests. These spaces feature antique decor, china collections, and flexible configurations for weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations with full catering service.
Live Music
Live music performances enhance the dining experience with regular appearances by local musicians. The lounge band and other acts create an authentic Italian ambiance while maintaining conversational volume levels. Musical programming varies nightly to suit different guest preferences.
Garden Patio
Our expanded garden patio seats 100 guests under a climate-controlled tent system that operates year-round. The space features trumpet vines planted by the founder and combines historic charm with modern comfort. Reservations recommended for weekend evenings.
Catering
Catering services provide authentic Italian cuisine for off-site events with menu options mirroring our restaurant offerings. The team handles events ranging from office gatherings to wedding receptions with full service including setup, service staff, and equipment provision.
People
Vincenzo Guarino
Founder
Sicilian immigrant who established the restaurant in 1898, introducing authentic Italian recipes that remain on the menu today. His legacy continues through family members who maintain his culinary traditions.
Sam Guarino
Second Generation Owner
Vincenzo's son who expanded the business in the 1950s-60s, creating the garden dining area and Victorian decor that define the restaurant's character today.
Nancy Phillips
Third Generation Owner
Continued family tradition after Sam Guarino's passing, maintaining authentic Italian cuisine while modernizing operations to meet contemporary dining expectations.
Rachel Guarino
Current Manager
Fourth-generation family member overseeing daily operations, maintaining high service standards while preserving the restaurant's historic character and culinary authenticity.
Scott Guarino Jr
Operations Manager
Fourth-generation team member ensuring consistent quality across all dining experiences, from private events to casual meals in Cleveland's oldest restaurant.
Questions
What makes Guarino's Restaurant historically significant?
Established in 1898 by Sicilian immigrant Vincenzo Guarino, we're Cleveland's oldest continuously operating restaurant. Our Victorian decor, trumpet vine from Sicily, and original recipes preserve over a century of Italian-American heritage.
What Italian specialties do you serve?
Our menu features house-made pasta, seafood specialties, and classic entrees using recipes perfected over four generations, including 50-year-old lasagna, house-seasoned calamari, and traditional marinara sauce.
Can you accommodate large private events?
Yes! Our Victorian Parlors accommodate 8-40 guests indoors, while our climate-controlled garden patio seats 100 guests. We host weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations with full catering service.
Is parking available near the restaurant?
Valet parking is available across the street ($8) during peak hours. Street parking in Little Italy can be limited, especially on weekends, so we recommend arriving early or using valet service.
Do you offer live music?
Yes! Regular live music performances feature local musicians, including our popular lounge band. The volume maintains conversational comfort while enhancing our authentic Italian ambiance.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept all major credit cards, cash, and mobile payment options. Reservations require credit card guarantee, and private event deposits can be made via check or electronic transfer.
Reviews (6)
Curt Caden
Jan 23, 2022 Report
Food was very good with generous portions. Laid back atmosphere. Friendly and helpful parking lot attendant.
Joy Visnjic-Flaherty
Jan 16, 2022 Report
Haven't been here in years! Came for my friend's birthday lunch. Was so delicious!! Just like I remember!! So cute inside. The bathrooms are cute too. Love the nostalgia. We will definitely be back. Great service too.
Nick Hanson
Jan 11, 2022 Report
Just an absolutely phenomenal restaurant. By far the best Italian food Ive ever experienced while dining out. Beautiful interior with a large outdoor patio that I cant wait to try out in the summer. This place looks fancy but the prices are incredibly reasonable for the ambiance and the quality of the food. Be sure to ask about the beads! Marilou was so hospitable and told me the whole history of the place. I just moved to the neighborhood and cant wait to be back to try more. Cant recommend this place enough!
Adele Arias Cruz
Dec 15, 2021 Report
Lasagna was excellent. Atmosphere was very nice. Delicious spumoni. Olive appetizer was amazing! The only downside. My sister in law and I wanted to share the lasagna. We knew there would be a charge to do so. Waitress told us it would be too small to share. She showed us with her hands how big the piece would be. So we ended up getting our own separate meals. The lasagna came out about four times the size she told us. We could have easily shared. I don't like being lied to. And then she ignored us when we asked for more bread. We noticed she brought more bread to all her other tables.
Kristin Palocko
Dec 11, 2021 Report
Old school Italian-so old it's apparently the oldest restaurant in Cleveland! Wonderful perk that it has attached parking available and accepts reservations. Food was tasty, cocktails around $12. Our waitress made us feel very rushed for the restaurant not being that busy, but we still enjoyed our evening.
Stevo
Nov 10, 2021 Report
Good authentic Italian food. Very good coffee. Vegetarian options available (the eggplant parmigiana is very good). Quaint interior with pleasant atmosphere. Clean facilities. Service was slow but thats understandable since theyre short staffed like most restaurants. No Covid protection, however. Staff was unmasked, so get that booster shot before you go. Overall good experience that Id recommend while you visit little Italy