Business Details
11 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in Olmsted Falls
We are proud to continue the legacy of Matteo's Casual Italian in Olmsted Falls, where we've served the community since 2015. Our team of longtime friends and local residents brings decades of combined culinary experience to create an authentic Italian dining experience rooted in family values. We specialize in Abruzzo/Rome regional cuisine, offering a welcoming environment for families and guests seeking memorable meals.Our commitment extends beyond food to fostering community connections through private events, catering services, and a dedication to evolving with our customers' needs while maintaining our core traditions.
Services
Lunch Service
Dinner Service
Catering
Private Events
Online Ordering
Details
- Year established: 2015
Highlights and features
- We offer authentic Italian cuisine rooted in Abruzzo/Rome traditions
- Our team includes local residents with deep community connections
- We provide full-service catering with customizable menus
- We accommodate dietary needs with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options
- Our private party room hosts events up to 50 guests
Services
Catering
Our catering service brings Matteo's authentic Italian flavors to your special events. We offer customizable menus with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Our experienced team handles everything from menu planning to on-site service for weddings, corporate events, and private parties.
Private Events
Host gatherings in our dedicated private party room accommodating up to 50 guests. We provide full-service bar, buffet options, and professional staff for occasions like rehearsal dinners, birthdays, and business luncheons. Our team ensures seamless execution of your event details.
Lunch Service
Enjoy our lunch menu Tuesday through Saturday starting at 11:30 AM. The menu features traditional Italian dishes in a casual setting. We offer both main dining and lounge area seating for quick business lunches or relaxed family meals.
Dinner Service
Experience authentic Italian cuisine during our dinner hours Tuesday through Sunday. Our evening service includes expanded menu options and a warm atmosphere perfect for family dinners or special occasions. Reservations recommended for weekends.
Online Ordering
Order Matteo's Italian favorites for pickup through our online system. We offer a 10% discount for first-time online orders. The service provides convenient access to our full menu for enjoying our cuisine at home or the office.
People
Craig Allenbaugh
Co-Owner
Co-owner with extensive culinary experience and deep roots in Olmsted Falls community. Committed to maintaining Matteo's legacy while introducing fresh perspectives to Italian dining.
Deserai Satullo
Co-Owner
Co-owner dedicated to creating welcoming dining experiences. Active community member focused on family values and quality Italian cuisine that brings people together.
Jessica Cliff
Co-Owner
Co-owner with strong local ties, emphasizing community engagement through food. Works to maintain Matteo's reputation as a gathering place for families and special occasions.
Daniel Cliff
Co-Owner
Co-owner combining culinary expertise with community focus. Committed to preserving Matteo's legacy while enhancing its offerings for modern diners.
Questions
What Italian regional cuisine does Matteo's specialize in?
We specialize in Abruzzo/Rome regional cuisine, featuring traditional recipes with authentic flavors from these areas of Italy.
Do you offer catering services for special events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with customizable menus, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options for weddings, corporate events, and private parties.
Can I host a private event at Matteo's?
Yes, our private party room accommodates up to 50 guests with full-service bar, buffet options, and professional staff for your special occasion.
What dietary options are available?
We offer vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options across our menu to accommodate various dietary needs and preferences.
How long has Matteo's been in business?
We've been serving the Olmsted Falls community since 2015, continuing our tradition of authentic Italian dining.
Reviews (5)
Laura Swope
Jan 12, 2022
Report
Had a wonderful shower I went to there. The staff was amazing and attentive and the food was fantastic. Such a cute little place to walk around
Alison Bennington
Dec 30, 2021
Report
Dinner, wine, desserts, & service were all wonderful! (I believe our server's name was Marisa, she was great.) Food came out quickly & was delicious. We had a great time, we'll definitely be back!
Seth Tollett
Dec 22, 2021
Report
Food was pretty decent and the service wasnt bad (other than server being bothered by asking for an extra loaf of bread). However if youre waiting a table, you should make sure that your customers are out the door before you start making nasty remarks about them. We apologize that we have children and they arent perfectly neat and that we cant stop every thing they do wrong at the dinner table, but at least we left 30% tip to try offset the little bit of extra cleaning. The least you could do was wait till we were out of the place to be so rude. Some peoples only interest in the
Jeannine Docherty
Dec 21, 2021
Report
We have held our annual Christmas OF Football Moms dinner the past 2 years at Matteo's and have been so pleased with the location, service and menu. We reserve the upstairs which offers a wonderful spot for a larger gathering and allows us to also do a gift and cookie exchange. We celebrated the season with some wonderful peppermint martini's last night - they were delicious. The food - as always was amazing! And the service was top notch. We plan to continue this tradition at Matteo's!
Brent Green
Dec 13, 2021
Report
This is one of my wife and I's favorite restaurant. The owner was more than accommodating and the wait time was more than reasonable. Once we were sat, the waitress did an excellent job getting drinks, explaining menu items, and continued to check on our party. If you are looking for affordable and delicious Italian cuisine, this is the place to go.
