Business Details
21 Years
experience
Experience Fine Dining at Chef Michael's in Islamorada
At Chef Michael's, we have proudly served the Islamorada community for over two decades, establishing ourselves as a cornerstone of the local culinary scene. Our commitment to quality begins with sourcing ingredients from nearby waters and farms, ensuring every dish reflects the freshness and flavor of the Florida Keys. Our team of chefs brings decades of experience from renowned kitchens across Manhattan to Martinique, crafting menus that blend global techniques with local traditions. We specialize in creating memorable dining experiences through our innovative cuisine, attentive service, and dedication to sustainability, including our initiative to combat invasive lionfish through culinary innovation.Whether you're joining us for an intimate dinner or hosting a private event, our staff ensures every detail exceeds expectations. Our restaurant's reputation as a trusted fixture in Islamorada is built on a foundation of excellence, creativity, and a deep respect for the region's natural resources. We take pride in offering both locals and visitors a taste of the Keys through dishes that celebrate seasonal ingredients and bold flavors. From our handcrafted wine list to our award-winning recipes, every element of Chef Michael's reflects our passion for hospitality and culinary artistry.
Services
Fine Dining
Private Events
Catering Services
Wine Pairing
Seasonal Menus
Details
- Year established: 2005
Highlights and features
- We source ingredients exclusively from local Florida Keys waters and farms.
- Our chefs bring decades of experience from top global restaurants.
- We offer customizable private dining and off-site catering services.
- Our menu features creative, seasonal dishes recognized by USA Today.
- We prioritize sustainability through lionfish eradication initiatives.
What people say
Creatively-inspired local cuisine
Fantastic experience
Award-winning dishes
Excellent service
Sustainable practices
Services
Private Events
Host weddings, business luncheons, or private dinners in our Islamorada venue. Our team coordinates menus, dcor, and logistics for seamless events accommodating various group sizes. With oceanfront views and customizable culinary options, we create memorable occasions for both locals and visitors.
Catering Services
Our off-premise catering brings Chef Michael's signature cuisine to your location. We offer full-service catering for corporate events, rehearsal dinners, and special celebrations. Menus feature locally sourced seafood and seasonal ingredients prepared by our award-winning culinary team.
Wine Pairing
Complement meals with our curated wine list featuring over 100 global varietals. From California Chardonnays to French Champagnes, our sommelier-recommended pairings enhance our seafood-forward dishes. Available by glass or bottle for dine-in and private events.
Seasonal Menus
Enjoy daily changing menus highlighting Florida Keys' freshest catches and produce. Our chefs create inventive dishes like lionfish Creole and tropical fruit-infused entrees. Seasonal specialties ensure optimal flavor while supporting local fishermen and farmers.
Fine Dining
Experience elevated Florida Keys cuisine in our elegant dining room. Our five-course meals feature prime cuts, sustainable seafood, and house-made desserts. The restaurant's ambiance combines sophistication with island charm for romantic evenings or celebratory meals.
People
Chef Michael
Executive Chef
With over 25 years of culinary experience from Manhattan to Martinique, Chef Michael leads our kitchen with a focus on local ingredients and innovative techniques. His expertise has earned recognition from USA Today and established our restaurant as a Keys dining destination.
Questions
What are Chef Michael's operating hours?
We serve dinner Monday through Saturday from 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Sundays and major holidays like July 4th, Thanksgiving, and Christmas.
Does Chef Michael's offer private dining options?
Yes, we host private events for weddings, business meetings, and special celebrations. Our venue accommodates various group sizes with customizable menus and décor options.
What type of cuisine does Chef Michael's serve?
We specialize in contemporary Florida Keys cuisine featuring locally sourced seafood and seasonal ingredients. Our menu includes creative preparations of lionfish, grouper, and other regional specialties.
Is catering available off-premise?
Yes, our full-service catering brings Chef Michael's signature dishes to your location. We provide complete event coordination including menu customization, staffing, and equipment rental.
Where is Chef Michael's located?
We're situated at Mile Marker 81.6 on Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, just off the main highway on the Old Road. Our address is 81671 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33070.
Reviews (4)
Steven O.
Jan 22, 2022
Report
Amazing food and service second to none. Would highly recommend and would go back again and again. Make sure to call day before to get reservations.
Ciara N.
Jan 15, 2022
Report
Best place to tantalize my golden tongue. This was literally the last meal I had in the Islamorada and it was the BEST meal I've had. If I ever come back, I sure would have booked reservation here again. The staff was excellent and very responsive. The food...... oh the food was so delicious. Everything was cooked to perfection. I never had conch or hog fish but I did enjoy it thanks to how the chef at this restaurant prepared it. I had the hog fish Juliette style with shrimp and scallops with almond slices. Yummmy
Manuel A. M.
Jan 06, 2022
Report
Utes agoNEW
Unfortunately I had experienced the worst service possible. I made a reservation a month in advance for a special occasion, for a large party. Our family got hit with COVID, I changed the reservation to two in advance. Paid (gave my credit card as a gift to the couple) when the got there they were given a sit at the bar which was tight and uncomfortable. Also the person at the front was rude to my family celebrating their bday after driving an hour. I called to find out what happened and the manager laughed and refuse to give me a name. Obviously costumer service is not their specialty
Unfortunately I had experienced the worst service possible. I made a reservation a month in advance for a special occasion, for a large party. Our family got hit with COVID, I changed the reservation to two in advance. Paid (gave my credit card as a gift to the couple) when the got there they were given a sit at the bar which was tight and uncomfortable. Also the person at the front was rude to my family celebrating their bday after driving an hour. I called to find out what happened and the manager laughed and refuse to give me a name. Obviously costumer service is not their specialty
Luka Vaicekauskaite
Jan 02, 2022
Report
Overall decent experience. -1 star as the restaurant itself is not really visually pleasant and so overpriced. $40 for a fish fillet with some WHITE rice and some veggies is not proportionate. I understand that it is a fresh catch, but nor the presentation or the flavor itself was something extraordinary. The kids menu is very good tho!! Additionally, the fish was prepared very oily, and it felt very heavy on me. To improve, I wouldnt suggest filling tge plate with the rice, but maybe add a little bit less and a side salad, to balance out the flavor.