Business Details
42 Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Penfield, NY
MGM Associates of Rochester has been a trusted name in the insurance industry since 1984, providing tailored solutions for individuals and businesses across New York. As an independent agency, we prioritize client needs by offering competitive rates from multiple carriers, ensuring comprehensive coverage that aligns with unique requirements. Our family-owned operation combines decades of local expertise with a commitment to transparency, delivering personalized service that builds lasting relationships.Recognized as a Best Practices Agency by the Independent Agents Association five times, we leverage our industry partnerships to simplify complex insurance decisions. Located in Penfield, our team works directly with clients to compare policies, address claims, and provide ongoing support that prioritizes long-term security over short-term gains.
Services
Business Insurance
Personal Insurance
Employee Benefits
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Commercial Property
General Liability
Workers' Compensation
Cyber Liability
Umbrella Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1984
Highlights and features
- We are an independent agency offering competitive rates from multiple carriers.
- Awarded Best Practices Agency by the Independent Agents Association five times.
- Experienced team with deep local market knowledge.
- Comprehensive insurance solutions for personal and business needs.
- Family-owned and operated since 1984.
Associations and certifications
- Independent Agents Association
Services
Business Insurance
Our Business Insurance solutions protect companies across New York with policies tailored to industry-specific risks. We offer coverage options including liability protection, property insurance, and workers' compensation. Our independent agency compares multiple carriers to find cost-effective, comprehensive plans that safeguard your operations and assets.
Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance policies provide financial protection against accidents, theft, and damage. We offer customizable coverage for standard vehicles, motorcycles, and classic cars. Our team helps clients compare rates while ensuring compliance with New York state requirements and addressing unique driving needs.
Home Insurance
Home Insurance policies cover residential properties against risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. We provide options for homeowners, renters, and landlords across New York. Our agency ensures clients understand policy details while finding competitive rates that match their property's specific needs.
Employee Benefits
Employee Benefits programs help businesses offer health, life, and retirement plans to attract talent. We assist companies in designing cost-effective group benefit packages. Our services include comparing provider networks and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements for New York-based employers.
Umbrella Insurance
Umbrella Insurance provides additional liability coverage beyond standard policy limits. We help clients protect assets against major claims through supplemental policies. Our agency ensures seamless integration with existing home, auto, and business insurance plans for comprehensive risk management.
Questions
What does it mean to be an independent insurance agency?
As an independent agency, we partner with multiple carriers to compare rates and coverage options, ensuring clients receive tailored solutions without being tied to a single provider.
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Request a free quote online through our website or call us at 585-381-7008. Our team will review your needs and provide competitive options from trusted carriers.
What areas do you serve?
We serve clients throughout New York, including Penfield, Buffalo, Syracuse, and surrounding communities, offering localized insurance expertise.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal and commercial insurance, including auto, home, life, health, business policies, employee benefits, and specialized coverage like cyber liability.
How do I file a claim?
Contact us directly at 585-381-7008 or use our online service request form to initiate a claim. Our team guides you through the process with prompt assistance.
Are you affiliated with any insurance carriers?
We maintain partnerships with multiple top-rated carriers but remain independent to prioritize client interests over carrier relationships.
Reviews (4)
Helen Moore
Aug 27, 2021
Report
I attempted to reach out to MGM Associates for a cheaper homeowner insurance policy around late May 2021. Four calls over three weeks went unanswered, so I purchased a policy with another provider. When I asked for cancellation papers, it took another 2.5 weeks. I signed the cancellation request on 7/23/21, and received a letter of cancellation due to nonpayment on 8/24/21. When I called the insurance company about the issue, they said MGM never sent the cancellation notice to the insurance company. I just had to do it myself. Would not recommend.
Maria Melnik
Aug 18, 2020
Report
In short, voice mail each time I called, no timely response to emails and when expressed my dissatisfaction, I was just handed over to another person. Im was good with that, however, that did not get me anywhere either. They would not call back nor take the call, however, I would get one word question here and there via email, which just postponed the time by over two weeks. Until I looked for an option B.
Tim Wadsworth
May 18, 2018
Report
Do not bother with this, I called three times, got the same receptionist, and was transferred to someone but the person did not answer. I am not going to waste my time and move onto the next.
Levent Engin
Sep 20, 2017
Report
Great company to do business with! We currently have multiple business insurance policies with MGM and and have been doing business with Mike and team for around 8 years. Definitely a great group of people to work with.
