Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
43 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Rochester
For over four decades, Agatina's Restaurant has been a cornerstone of Rochester, NY's culinary scene, delivering authentic Italian cuisine crafted with tradition and care. As a family-owned establishment, we pride ourselves on using time-honored recipes to create meals that reflect our deep-rooted heritage and commitment to quality. Our extensive menu caters to diverse tastes, featuring homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and premium cuts of meat, all prepared by skilled chefs with decades of collective experience. We offer full-service dining in a warm, inviting atmosphere complemented by private event spaces for special occasions. Our catering services bring the flavors of Agatina's Restaurant to your doorstep, whether for intimate gatherings or large-scale events.

Beyond our restaurant walls, we share our passion for Italian cuisine through a popular line of jarred sauces available in local markets. With a focus on exceptional service, culinary expertise, and community connection, we strive to make every dining experience memorable. Our team's dedication to authenticity and customer satisfaction has earned us a loyal following and numerous accolades. From our kitchen to your table, we remain committed to upholding the standards that have defined us since 1983.
Services
Italian Dining Event Catering Private Parties Food Truck Rental Sauce Retail Takeout Service Wedding Catering Corporate Events Lunch Buffet Dinner Service
Details
  • Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
  • Over 40 years of culinary expertise in authentic Italian cuisine
  • Family-owned with deep roots in the Rochester community
  • Full-service catering for events of all sizes
  • Award-winning homemade sauces available for retail purchase
  • Consistently praised for exceptional food quality and service
What people say
Delicious food Friendly staff Timely service Perfect events Amazing chicken cutlets
Services
Italian Catering
Our professional catering team brings Agatina's Restaurant authentic Italian flavors to any event. We offer customized menus featuring homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and traditional entrees for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. With options for both formal sit-down dinners and buffet-style service, our experienced staff ensures flawless execution from menu planning to on-site service. Clients can choose from multiple pricing tiers including premium options with premium cuts and seafood selections.
Private Dining
Host special occasions in our dedicated private rooms accommodating groups of various sizes. Our semi-private and fully private spaces feature Italian-inspired decor, AV capabilities, and personalized service for birthdays, anniversaries, and business meetings. Packages include customized menus, beverage service, and event coordination support. The rooms maintain the same culinary standards as our main dining area with exclusive access to chefs for menu customization.
Food Truck
Our branded food truck delivers Agatina's Restaurant signature dishes to outdoor events and festivals. The mobile unit serves popular menu items like Chicken Parmesan, Italian sandwiches, and house-made sauces at weddings, street fairs, and corporate functions. Available for hourly rentals with options for full-service catering or self-serve stations. The truck maintains commercial kitchen standards with refrigeration and cooking equipment meeting all health regulations.
Dine-In Service
Experience traditional Italian cuisine in our welcoming restaurant atmosphere. Our menu features daily specials, homemade pasta, and classic entrees prepared using recipes passed down through generations. The dining room combines casual comfort with professional service, offering both la carte and multi-course meal options. Special accommodations include gluten-free items and children's portions while maintaining the same ingredient quality as our catering division.
Retail Products
Purchase our award-winning Italian sauces produced in-house using family recipes. Available in multiple varieties including marinara, arrabbiata, and alfredo, these shelf-stable products undergo commercial canning processes while preserving fresh-made quality. Sold through our restaurant and major regional grocery chains, the sauce line extends Agatina's Restaurant culinary expertise to home cooks seeking authentic Italian flavors with convenience.
People
Michael Fornataro
Owner
Third-generation Italian chef leading Agatina's Restaurant culinary operations with 25+ years of restaurant management experience. Specializes in traditional Southern Italian cooking techniques while innovating modern menu offerings.
Joseph Calabrese
Executive Chef
Award-winning chef with 30 years in fine dining, overseeing kitchen operations and menu development. Trained in Naples, Italy, with expertise in regional Italian cuisine and food safety standards.
Questions
Does Agatina's Restaurant offer catering for large events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events of all sizes with customizable menus and on-site coordination.
Can I purchase Agatina's Restaurant sauces online?
Our sauces are available for purchase at local retailers and through our partner Calabresella's website for shipping.
Are reservations required for weekend dining?
We recommend reservations for Friday and Saturday evenings, which can be made through our website or by phone.
Do you have gluten-free menu options?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pasta, sauces, and other menu items clearly marked on our current menu.
Is the food truck available for private parties?
Our food truck services private events with advance booking, offering a selection of popular menu items for groups.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, cash, and checks for catering services and special orders.
Reviews (6)
Cathy Sinacola
Jan 01, 2022 Report
Food always amazing! Enough for an extra meal to take home. And a selection of special cocktails, had the Blue Rochester .
Frank Ferrara
Dec 21, 2021 Report
Highly recommend. Atmosphere, cleanliness, service, portion size, quality and taste. All top notch. A bit pricey but you will leave totally satisfied and most likely thinking about when you can get back for another dining experience!
Carol McNees
Dec 18, 2021 Report
Excellent food, excellent service. Some of their rules about charging $8 for an extra plate to share entree is over kill ...otherwise it's a fantastic place to eat!
Mike Marion
Nov 13, 2021 Report
The food here was really good! My only critique is how high the prices are here and on top of that how big the serving sizes are. I feel as if the prices go down if the serving sizes were not so gigantic. Other than that, the food was great and I would love to dine here again! :)
Ken L.
Oct 18, 2021 Report
Great service and food.The chicken Parmigiano was the best I've ever had.. marinara sauce was excellent. The scallops and fettuccine pesto also got rave reviews.
Jenna F.
Oct 16, 2021 Report
I would definitely recommend having a reservation if you don't want a 45-1 hour wait. The meals were great and the perfect portions. Meals come with a house salad. The chicken Parmesan and broiled haddock were our meals of choice. The bathrooms were not clean unfortunately.