Business Details
10 Years
experience
Your Trusted BBQ Restaurant in Ontario, NY
Heintzelman's BBQ Pit is a family-owned and operated dining establishment established in 2016, located in Ontario, New York. With over two decades of experience perfecting our craft, we specialize in slow-smoked meats and house-made side dishes featuring unique flavor profiles unavailable elsewhere in the region. Our 90-seat dining space expands to accommodate 130 guests when our patio and deck are open, offering both eat-in and takeout options. We provide full catering services with a 15% service fee, including our popular Friday night fish fry for non-BBQ enthusiasts. Our team combines generational culinary expertise with modern hospitality to deliver exceptional service at accessible prices.We prioritize creating memorable dining experiences that reflect our family traditions while accommodating diverse tastes. Our commitment to quality ingredients and consistent preparation methods ensures every meal meets our exacting standards. We maintain transparency in our operations and welcome guests to become part of our extended family. Our business hours and reservation policies are designed to balance operational efficiency with customer convenience. Through continuous refinement of our recipes and service approach, we strive to exceed expectations while preserving our core values.
Services
BBQ Catering
Ice Cream Service
Takeout Orders
Dine-In Experience
Friday Fish Fry
Details
- Year established: 2016
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 2016 with 20+ years of culinary experience
- Exclusive flavor profiles developed through generational recipe refinement
- Full-service catering with professional execution
- Diverse menu featuring Friday night fish fry options
- Affordable pricing without compromising quality standards
Services
BBQ Catering
Our full-service catering provides slow-smoked meats and house-made sides for events of all sizes. We use proprietary spice blends and traditional smoking techniques perfected over 20 years. Clients receive professional service including setup, service ware, and staff support for seamless event execution.
Ice Cream Service
We serve premium Perry's Ice Cream in 16 classic and specialty flavors with multiple serving options. Our sundae boxes include customizable flavor selections and premium toppings. All desserts are prepared fresh to order using high-quality ingredients sourced from trusted suppliers.
Dine-In Experience
Our 90-seat main dining area expands to 130 seats seasonally with outdoor patio and deck access. The menu features signature BBQ dishes, weekly specials like Friday fish fry, and daily rotating sides. Reservations available with professional table service and family-style dining options.
Takeout Orders
We offer complete meal packages for pickup with reheating instructions and serving recommendations. Orders include restaurant-quality presentation with appropriate packaging for temperature control. Custom portions available for individual or family servings of our signature dishes.
Friday Fish Fry
Our Friday night fish fry features beer-battered cod with house-made sides and traditional accompaniments. This seasonal menu option provides an alternative to BBQ offerings while maintaining our commitment to quality ingredients and scratch cooking methods.
Questions
What catering options are available for large events?
We offer full-service catering with customizable menus featuring our signature BBQ dishes, sides, and desserts. Our team handles setup, service, and cleanup for events up to 130 guests.
Are reservations required for dining in?
Reservations are recommended but not required. We accept walk-ins and offer a 24-hour reservation window through our website or by calling 315-333-1235 after 3pm.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, debit cards, and cash payments for both dine-in and takeout orders. Catering invoices can be paid through our secure online portal.
Do you offer gluten-free or dietary-restricted options?
While we don't have dedicated gluten-free preparation areas, we provide ingredient lists for all menu items to accommodate dietary restrictions. Our ice cream options include lactose-free vanilla.
What are your outdoor seating hours?
Our patio and deck seating operate seasonally from 4pm-8pm Wednesday-Thursday, 12pm-8pm Friday, and 1pm-8pm Saturday when weather permits.
How should I reheat takeout meals?
We provide specific reheating instructions with each takeout order. For optimal results, we recommend reheating meats at 250°F until warmed through while keeping sides at serving temperature.
Reviews (4)
Paige Wickham
Jan 11, 2022
Report
Amazing food, especially the ribs and brisket. Love the Friday fish fry too! Always great service and they make you feel like you're part of their family. One of my favorite restaurants by far!
Walter Hresent
Dec 19, 2021
Report
The best restaurant in this area. All other restaurants in the area are merely peons compared to these guys. Rob rocks and hes brought a lot of business with him to the restaurant as well. Best ribs around and their smoked wings are phenomenal.
Bonney Milan
Nov 25, 2021
Report
The food was delicious, as was the service. The owner made his rounds of the tables to introduce himself and chat a bit...also checked to be sure we were having a good experience. Another added extra...for 1st time quests (you may need to request it) they provide a tray of sides (free) to taste to see which sides you prefer with your meal..loved the personal touch. In addition to the beverage menu, they also serve alcohol drinks...I enjoyed a glass of Red Cat.
Nicole Niles
Oct 22, 2021
Report
We enjoyed our dinner. We've heard good things and decided to check it out. The wings are delicious with Dominic's sauce on it. That's a cross of mild and garlic parm. The smoked mac and cheese and sweet potato tots were very good. The staff is very friendly and makes you feel welcome. The owner Bob even came around to check on the guests. Our server Tina was excellent. We will be back again.