Business Details
Trusted Fine Jewelry Store in Manitowoc Since 1889
Since 1889, Rummeles Fine Jewelry has been a trusted name in Manitowoc, Wisconsin, delivering exceptional quality and service in fine jewelry. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our partnerships with premier manufacturers and rigorous quality control processes. As a family-owned business for over 130 years, we combine generational expertise with modern craftsmanship to offer timeless pieces that meet the highest standards. Our team of certified professionals, including Registered Jewelers with the American Gem Society and Diamond Grading experts from the Gemological Institute of America, ensures every customer receives personalized care.We specialize in engagement rings, custom jewelry, and repair services, backed by our lifetime warranty on gold and platinum settings. Our mission is to help clients find meaningful, durable jewelry while maintaining transparency, integrity, and community-focused service.
Services
Engagement Rings
Jewelry Repair
Custom Design
Diamond Grading
Estate Jewelry
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1889 with generational jewelry expertise
- AGS-certified jewelers and GIA-trained diamond graders on staff
- Lifetime warranty on gold and platinum jewelry settings
- In-house jewelry repair by a master goldsmith with 25+ years experience
- Custom design services for personalized, one-of-a-kind pieces
Associations and certifications
- American Gem Society (AGS)
- Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
Services
Jewelry Repair
Our master goldsmith with 25+ years experience handles all jewelry repairs in-store. Services include ring sizing, stone setting, prong repair, and complete remounts. We inspect and restore damaged pieces to their original condition using professional techniques. Customers receive personalized attention for both simple adjustments and complex restorations.
Custom Design
Transform your vision into wearable art through our custom design process. Our experts collaborate on sketches, materials, and gemstone selection to create unique pieces. We guide clients from concept to completion, ensuring every detail meets their specifications. Services include CAD modeling, wax carving, and hand-fabricated designs for rings, pendants, and more.
Engagement Rings
We offer a curated selection of diamond engagement rings and wedding bands in various styles. Our certified staff assists with center stone selection, metal choices, and setting options. Services include ring sizing, engraving, and lifetime maintenance support. Customers can choose from classic solitaires to modern designer collections.
Diamond Grading
GIA-certified professionals provide accurate diamond and gemstone grading. We assess cut, color, clarity, and carat weight using industry-standard tools. Services include appraisal documentation, certification verification, and valuation for insurance purposes. Our team educates customers on quality factors when selecting stones.
Estate Jewelry
We curate pre-owned fine jewelry with historical craftsmanship and unique designs. Our collection includes antique, vintage, and modern estate pieces. Services include authentication, restoration, and appraisal for estate jewelry. Customers find distinctive options for engagement rings, heirlooms, and statement accessories.
People
David Pahmeier
Owner
David has served Rummele's since 1982, becoming owner in 2000. A Registered Jeweler with AGS and GIA-certified diamond grader, he combines technical expertise with personalized service. He oversees operations and customer relations.
Julie Pahmeier
Owner
Julie co-owns Rummele's with her husband David. As a third-generation jeweler, she brings family tradition and GIA-certified expertise to client consultations. She focuses on customer service and jewelry selection.
Questions
What services does Rummele's Fine Jewelry offer?
We provide engagement rings, custom jewelry design, in-store repairs, diamond grading, and estate jewelry sales. Our services also include free ring cleaning, private appointments, and financing options.
Do you offer jewelry repair services?
Yes, our master goldsmith handles repairs including ring sizing, stone setting, prong replacement, and complete remounts. Most repairs are completed in-store within a few days.
Can I get custom jewelry designed?
Absolutely. Our designers collaborate on custom pieces using sketches, CAD modeling, or wax prototypes. We guide you through material selection, gemstone choices, and production for unique creations.
What is your warranty policy?
We offer a lifetime warranty on gold and platinum settings against defects. This covers free repairs or replacements for manufacturing issues, excluding damage from accidents or normal wear and tear.
Are your diamonds certified?
Many diamonds come with GIA certification. Our staff includes GIA-trained graders who evaluate all stones for quality. We provide documentation for diamond characteristics and value assessments.
Do you offer financing options?
Yes, we provide free financing with up to 36 months no interest. Our financing program helps customers purchase fine jewelry with flexible payment plans approved at checkout.
Reviews (7)
Kymberly Meredith
Dec 27, 2021
Report
Hard days deserve hard gems. Rummeles made my day! Great selection and prices, found that little something that lifted me up! Customer service is superb and after my day, it was just nice to have them erase all the bad today!
Moist Yearold
Dec 14, 2021
Report
I was buying my fianc a ring and a man on a Bike rode buy and ripped it out of my hands to my surprise it was Lemicky i was astonished. Get a real ring Lefraud.
B. Gilbert
Nov 02, 2021
Report
First-class customer service! Thank you very much for the service on my watch. I will always be happy to recommend you to anyone looking for fine jewelry.
Erine Swanson
Oct 31, 2021
Report
Service was great. I needed a watch band mounted on my watch an the job was accomplished for a reasonable price.
Andrea Destree
Sep 17, 2021
Report
Highly recommend! We worked with Amanda to pick out an engagement ring and she was absolutely wonderful to work with! Very knowledgeable, prompt and courteous. She ordered in a couple of stones and was extremely patient and helpful with my indecisiveness :) she made this a great experience and we are very happy with our purchase. Will definitely be back!
Brian W.
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Quality locally owned jewelry store. This is my go to jewelry store. Much better than any chain jewelry store and better quality and service. Thankful that we have a top notch jewelry store locally.
Rachael Larzelere
May 17, 2021
Report
I had been trying to find a new wedding/engagement ring for months. I had a vision and they were able to make it happen. So helpful during the entire process from start to finish. Their customer service is beyond incredible!