Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Plymouth, WI
Nesemann's Diamond Center has been serving customers since 1919, establishing itself as a trusted name in fine jewelry. Our family-owned business in Plymouth, WI specializes in engagement rings, wedding bands, and custom jewelry design with a bench jeweler available for personalized modifications. We offer an extensive selection of diamonds, gemstone jewelry, and luxury watches alongside giftware for special occasions. Our in-house repair services ensure all work is completed by owner Alex Nesemann without outsourcing. We provide professional engraving and appraisal services to meet diverse customer needs.

With over a century of experience, we combine tradition with modern techniques to deliver exceptional craftsmanship. Our knowledgeable team assists clients in selecting perfect pieces while maintaining competitive pricing across all collections. We pride ourselves on maintaining continuous operations at our Plymouth location since 1957. Our commitment to quality extends to comprehensive jewelry care guidance and maintenance services. By focusing on personalized service, we ensure every customer receives attention tailored to their specific requirements.
Services
Engagement Rings Diamond Earrings Wedding Bands Jewelry Repair Appraisals Custom Design Gemstone Jewelry Luxury Watches Engraving Services Giftware Selection
Details
  • Year established: 1919
Highlights and features
  • We have a dedicated bench jeweler available for custom modifications
  • Our family-owned business has served Plymouth since 1957
  • All jewelry repairs completed in-house by experienced professionals
  • We offer comprehensive engraving and appraisal services
  • Maintain extensive inventory of diamonds and luxury watches
What people say
Exceptional service Knowledgeable staff Quality craftsmanship Personalized attention Trusted expertise
Services
Jewelry Repair
Our in-house jewelry repair service handles all types of jewelry restoration and modifications. With owner Alex Nesemann personally overseeing each project, we ensure precise craftsmanship without outsourcing. Services include ring resizing, stone setting, and antique restoration while maintaining original integrity.
Engagement Rings
We offer extensive selection of engagement rings featuring certified diamonds and precious metals. Our collection includes solitaire, halo, and three-stone designs with customization options through our bench jeweler. Every piece comes with detailed documentation and appraisal services.
Gemstone Jewelry
Our gemstone collection features sapphires, emeralds, and rubies in various jewelry forms. Each piece undergoes quality verification before being offered to customers. We provide detailed information about stone origins and care requirements for long-term maintenance.
Appraisals
Professional appraisal services determine accurate values for insurance and estate purposes. We evaluate diamonds using GIA standards and assess precious metals according to current market rates. Documentation includes detailed descriptions and photographic records for verification.
Engraving
We provide precision engraving services for adding personal messages to jewelry pieces. Our equipment handles various fonts and designs on different metal types. This service enhances sentimental value while maintaining structural integrity of the original piece.
People
Alex Nesemann
Owner & Bench Jeweler
Third-generation jeweler with over 25 years of experience in fine jewelry craftsmanship. Specializes in custom design and intricate repairs while maintaining family tradition of excellence in Plymouth since 1957.
Questions
Do you offer custom jewelry design services?
Yes, we provide custom design services with our in-house bench jeweler available for personalized modifications and creations.
Are repairs completed on-site?
All jewelry repairs are completed in-house by owner Alex Nesemann without outsourcing to third-party facilities.
Do you provide appraisal services?
We offer professional appraisal services for insurance and estate purposes with detailed documentation for all jewelry pieces.
What payment options are available?
We accept financing options through our 'Shop now, pay later' program for qualified purchases.
How long have you been in business?
Nesemann's Diamond Center has operated continuously since 1919, serving Plymouth customers since 1957.
Do you carry certified diamonds?
Our diamond inventory includes certified stones with full documentation and verification of quality characteristics.
Reviews (5)
Brenna McCurnin
Jun 15, 2021 Report
Renee Statz-Gilmour and I needed a necklace engraved for a family members passing. We called in and the customer service was very helpful! In under an hour we had the perfect gift, not to mention done with beautiful craftsmanship. We are so greatful for the help and are completely satisfied with the service we recieved. If you need a quick service and helpful guidance, look no further than Nesemanns Diamond Center!
Brenda OMalley
Apr 14, 2021 Report
So happy I chose to go to Nesemanns Diamond Center to get my wedding ring repaired. The entire prong and diamond broke off and I was hesitant to repair it. I spoke with Alex and I felt assured that my 30 year old ring was in good hands. My intuition was spot on!!! What a beautiful job he did!! My ring never left the store as Alex does his own work right there at the store. So glad I chose to go where my husband bought the ring. Thank you!!!!
Jenny Seehaver
Feb 03, 2021 Report
Nesemann's Diamond Center is extremely accommodating and is always willing to go the extra mile for their customers! I had a short timeline to purchase a piece of jewelry as a gift for a baptism (under 24 hours notice for the jeweler!) - Alex Nesemann customized a necklace for me and dropped it off at my house so that it would be ready the next day when I got home from being out of town, to take to the event that day! Extremely impressed with the customer service and their options!
Jill Arrowood
Sep 15, 2020 Report
My husband chose the best possible place to buy an engagement ring!!! I have the most beautiful ring & wedding band that I've ever seen and have had the most amazing service at Nesemann's over the last 4 + years! They have been great with cleanings, small repairs/sizings, etc. and even hand delivered my ring next door at the hair salon after a cleaning/adjustment. I am so thankful my husband chose a local friendly jeweler rather than a big box store. I couldn't be more thankful for the service I have received over & over again! Thank you Nesemann's!!
Erik
Oct 13, 2019 Report
Alex is the BEST! I am so glad I went to Nesemanns during my search for an engagement ring because Alex was extremely helpful and honest about what I was looking at. To be honest I didnt really know what exactly I wanted or even much about diamonds or rings in general and other jewelry stores I went to prior were not helpful and just wanted to sell me anything. Nesemanns was completely different. Alex knows his stuff and explained what I was looking at, how to get the most bang for my buck and worked with me to pick out and design the exact ring I was looking for. Going back to him for