Business Details
17 Years
experience
Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Downtown Atlanta
Since 2009, Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria has been dedicated to delivering authentic New York-style pizza crafted in Georgia's only genuine coal-fired oven. Our menu features hand-tossed pizzas with house-made dough, secret-recipe red sauce, and premium toppings alongside classic Italian salads, pastas, sandwiches, and desserts. We prioritize quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods to ensure every bite reflects our commitment to culinary excellence. Our team takes pride in creating a welcoming atmosphere where guests can enjoy freshly prepared meals in a vibrant downtown Atlanta setting.With a focus on consistency and customer satisfaction, we maintain rigorous standards for food quality, service efficiency, and dining experience. Our coal-burning oven technology, unique to the region, produces pizzas with distinctive crispness and flavor profiles developed over decades in New York City pizzerias. Whether serving individual guests or hosting private events, we strive to make every visit memorable through our dedication to authentic Italian cuisine and hospitality.
Services
Coal Oven Pizza
Italian Salads
House-Made Pasta
Private Events
Craft Cocktails
Lunch Specials
Dinner Service
Takeout Orders
Wine Selection
Craft Beer
Details
- Year established: 2009
Highlights and features
- We operate Georgia's only genuine coal-burning oven for authentic pizza preparation
- Our dough is made fresh daily using traditional New York-style techniques
- We use secret-recipe red sauce and premium quality toppings
- We offer private event space accommodating up to 100 guests
- Our menu features house-made Italian specialties beyond pizza
What people say
Awesome and delicious
Perfectly delicious
Great dough
Fresh ingredients
Super nice bartender
Services
Coal Oven Pizza
Our signature coal-fired oven creates perfectly crisp pizzas with authentic New York-style flavor. We use house-made dough, secret-recipe sauce, and premium toppings. Each 12-inch pizza serves two guests with six generous slices.
Private Events
Host gatherings in our 1,500-square-foot space accommodating up to 100 guests reception-style. Ideal for celebrations, corporate events, or special occasions in downtown Atlanta's vibrant setting.
Italian Salads
Handcrafted salads feature premium ingredients like fresh mozzarella, burrata, and house-made dressings. Options include classic Caesar, Greek, and Italian chopped salad with artisanal toppings.
Craft Cocktails
Our cocktail menu features creative combinations like the Italian Margarita and Max's Whiskey Punch. We also offer seasonal selections and classic spirits with premium mixers.
House-Made Pasta
Traditional Italian pasta dishes include spaghetti with meatballs, chicken parmesan, and shrimp scampi. All pasta is prepared fresh daily using authentic recipes and techniques.
Questions
What makes your pizza unique?
We use Georgia's only genuine coal-burning oven to create New York-style pizza with authentic crispness and flavor developed over a century in NYC pizzerias.
Do you offer private event space?
Yes, our 1,500-square-foot venue accommodates up to 100 guests reception-style with customized menus and dedicated event coordination.
What are your operating hours?
We serve guests daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM in our downtown Atlanta location.
Do you accept reservations?
We operate first-come, first-served seating but offer private event bookings through our inquiry form.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, mobile payments, and cash for all food, beverages, and event bookings.
Reviews (6)
Adam Love
Jan 28, 2022
Report
The pizzas are cooked in a coal oven, and the dough is awesome. Just a bit of crisp to hold the flavors. Sauce is a great flavor. Definitely a place to return to. Family friendly as well.
Timothy Goodyear
Jan 28, 2022
Report
Super good pizza in the heart of Atlanta! Everything was great from the apps to dessert. The toppings made the pizza. Super convenient to the GWCC and CF HOF.
Joseph Harrison
Jan 10, 2022
Report
A great local restaurant. We took a party of 9 to eat there and had a great experience. There was a variety of food ordered: meatball sandwiches, shrimp scampi, spaghetti, and of course pizza. Everyone was pleased with their meals. The pizza was exceptional - cooked in a brick oven so it had a crisp bottom and a touch of charring in a few places. Will definitely eat there again.
Nathan Duval
Dec 29, 2021
Report
Awesome place! We had went to the World of Coca-Cola and afterwards were looking for a place to get a bite to eat.
Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria is about a block away. We didn't get pizza, instead I got a Meatball Hogie and my wife got a Chicken Parmesan Hogie. Both sandwiches came out quick with a side of pasta salad. The sandwiches were both delicious! The meatballs were tender and spiced right, there was a lot of cheese and the bread was soft inside with a light crisp on the outside, perfect! The chicken parm was exactly the same in quality, lightly breaded with the right amount of sauce and cheesy
Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria is about a block away. We didn't get pizza, instead I got a Meatball Hogie and my wife got a Chicken Parmesan Hogie. Both sandwiches came out quick with a side of pasta salad. The sandwiches were both delicious! The meatballs were tender and spiced right, there was a lot of cheese and the bread was soft inside with a light crisp on the outside, perfect! The chicken parm was exactly the same in quality, lightly breaded with the right amount of sauce and cheesy
Mel V.
Dec 27, 2021
Report
Pizza and Italian hoagie with kettle chips. Also tried the lemon pepper wings. Good stuff. Service was attentive and pleasant.
Mark Robinson
Dec 17, 2021
Report
We really enjoyed this place. We were at the aquarium, which has terrible food, and found Max's within walking distance. It was a great last minute place to go. The Caesar salad was good and we really enjoyed our pizza. We got the pancetta arugula pizza. Usually the arugula is over powering on a pizza like this, but they tossed the arugula in lemon pepper and it really kicked the flavor up a notch. I would definitely come here again.