Business Details
39 Years
experience
Authentic Amish Dining & Bakery in Middlefield, OH
Since 1987, Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen has been a cornerstone of authentic Amish dining in Northeast Ohio's Amish Country. Owned by Dan and Rita Miller, our establishment combines generations of culinary tradition with modern convenience through our full-service restaurant, artisan bakery, gift shop, and online store. Our team of skilled Amish bakers and chefs crafts meals using time-honored recipes, ensuring every dish reflects the quality and simplicity of Amish heritage.We prioritize customer satisfaction through attentive service, carefully packaged baked goods for nationwide shipping, and flexible banquet options for special events. Located in Middlefield, Ohio, we serve both local patrons and travelers seeking genuine Amish flavors in a welcoming environment.
Services
Amish Restaurant
Artisan Bakery
Gift Shop
Online Store
Banquet Events
Details
- Year established: 1987
Highlights and features
- We've served authentic Amish cuisine since 1987 with family recipes passed through generations.
- Our bakery ships handcrafted pies nationwide with guaranteed delivery condition.
- Private banquet facilities accommodate weddings and events with customizable Amish feasts.
- Curated gift shop features Amish-made crafts and specialty food items under one roof.
- Online store provides nationwide access to our signature baked goods and pantry staples.
What people say
Best food
Great road trip destination
Excellent pies
Outstanding quality
Friendly staff
Services
Amish Restaurant
Our full-service restaurant serves traditional Amish breakfast, lunch, and dinner options daily. Menus feature homemade dishes like country fried steak, grilled chicken sandwiches, and daily soup specials. The kid-friendly menu and carryout ordering accommodate diverse dining needs while maintaining authentic Amish flavors.
Artisan Bakery
The bakery produces over 20 pie varieties, including Dutch apple and elderberry, using family recipes. Seasonal cookie trays and specialty breads are available for local pickup or nationwide shipping. All baked goods arrive carefully packaged to maintain freshness and presentation.
Gift Shop
Our gift shop offers Amish-made crafts, wooden toys, home decor, and specialty food items. Unique products include magnetic train cards, metal horse & buggy sets, and locally-made chocolates. Selected items are available through our online store for convenient shopping.
Online Store
The online store provides nationwide access to our baked goods, gift cards, and specialty products. Customers can order pies, cookies, jams, and pantry staples for delivery. The platform also facilitates gift card purchases with bonus promotions during specified periods.
Banquet Events
Private banquet facilities host weddings and events with customizable Amish feast options. Packages include all-you-can-eat meals with multiple meat and side choices, dessert selections, and beverage service. The separate event entrance features a traditional portico for guest gatherings.
People
Dan Miller
Owner
Dan Miller co-owns Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen with his wife Rita. With over three decades in the hospitality industry, he oversees daily operations while maintaining the establishment's commitment to authentic Amish culinary traditions.
Rita Miller
Owner
Rita Miller partners with Dan in managing the business. Her leadership ensures consistent quality across all departments, from kitchen operations to customer service, preserving the family-owned establishment's heritage since 1987.
Tina Rasmussen
Banquet Manager
Tina Rasmussen coordinates banquet events, designing customized menus and managing venue logistics. Her expertise in event planning ensures seamless execution of Amish wedding feasts and plated dinner experiences for groups of all sizes.
Elizabeth Koehler
Gift Shop Manager
Elizabeth Koehler curates the gift shop's selection of Amish crafts and specialty items. She manages inventory and customer inquiries, ensuring the retail space complements the dining experience with authentic regional products.
Questions
What are your operating hours?
We're open Monday through Saturday from 6:00 AM to 8:00 PM. Closed on Sundays.
Do you offer online ordering?
Yes, our online store allows ordering baked goods, gifts, and meal carryout options for local pickup.
How does the gift card promotion work?
Purchase $50 gift cards November 1-30, 2025 to receive $10 bonus vouchers valid for future purchases.
What banquet options are available?
Choose from six-course Amish Wedding Feasts, five-course plated dinners, or customized menus with all-inclusive pricing.
Do you ship baked goods nationwide?
Yes, we ship pies and baked goods nationwide with careful packaging to ensure perfect condition upon arrival.
What gift shop items are available?
Our gift shop features Amish crafts, jams, toys, home decor, candles, and specialty food items.
Reviews (7)
Kev Smith
Feb 02, 2022
Report
Cod was very tasty but a smaller portion than elsewhere. Homemade mac and cheese was not nearly as flavorful as homemade implies. Mashed potatoes were good but were barely warm. It was very near closing time. Maybe it was a fluke.
Debbie Ades
Jan 18, 2022
Report
Amazing restaurant.We really recommend,food is very tasty,generous portions. We went several times and always have a excellent service.
Dessert and bread we loved too.
Dessert and bread we loved too.
Aaron Hershberger
Jan 08, 2022
Report
Some buffets look good but taste blah... this buffet met every expectation! Kind service and a great meal! Cottage cheese and real bacon for salad as well as a full course meal, can't give it enough stars!
Corey Cresap
Dec 26, 2021
Report
Amazing. Very cute gift shop, as well. I had the roasted pork and some mashed potatoes and sweet potato fries. Very delicious, especially the butters/dips. Highly recommend getting a bite here; even for a day trip.
JoJo Bean
Dec 25, 2021
Report
I went here with my Aunt and Mother for a afternoon lunch. When we got there, it was kind of crowded but it's okay since the wait wasn't long at all. The waitress was very kind. The food was great, and I split the Chicken Dinner, it was very good but I honestly thought they would give us a but more. Also, though the bathrooms were clean, the water in them was FREEZING, would not warm up! Overall a pricey but still worth it.
Aunt Net
Oct 23, 2021
Report
WOW what a great place to get a home cooked meal in a buffet. The food and people were amazing. Fresh baked goods for sale and so delish!!
Connie Burley
Oct 14, 2021
Report
If you want comfort food, then this is your restaurant. So many great things on the menu: roast pork dinner, roast beef dinner, meatloaf and so many more. They also have the best salad bar, hot food bar. I've never had anything i didn't like. Then there's their pies. You have to try at least one slice or get it to go. So yummy!!
