Business Details
24 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Takeout in Durham, CT
Carmine's Pizza & Italian Take Out has been serving authentic Italian cuisine to the Durham community since 2002. Our family-owned business specializes in handcrafted New Haven-style thin crust pizzas made with the freshest ingredients available. We offer a diverse menu featuring traditional Italian dishes including homemade pastas, calzones, stuffed breads, and specialty appetizers. Our catering services provide generous portions for events of all sizes, from small gatherings to large celebrations. Every dish is prepared from scratch daily, ensuring consistent quality and flavor that keeps customers returning.We pride ourselves on using time-honored recipes passed down through generations of Italian cooking. Our commitment to excellence extends to our customer service, with staff dedicated to making every order perfect. The Tuesday special offers exceptional value with a free small mozzarella pizza when purchasing a large. While we focus on traditional flavors, we remain flexible to accommodate special requests. Our loyal customer base, including New Yorkers who appreciate authentic pizza, attests to our superior product and service.
Services
Thin Crust Pizza
Catering Services
Takeout Orders
Delivery Service
Appetizers
Pasta Dishes
Calzones
Stuffed Breads
Salads
Wings
Details
- Year established: 2002
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 2002 with authentic Italian recipes
- Daily fresh ingredients in all dishes and pizzas
- Custom catering for events up to 15 servings
- Award-winning New Haven-style thin crust pizza
- Tuesday special: Free small mozzarella pizza with large purchase
What people say
Best pizza
Fantastic food
Authentic Italian
Fresh ingredients
Reliable catering
Services
Thin Crust Pizza
Our New Haven-style thin crust pizza features crispy edges with a chewy center, topped with house-made marinara and premium mozzarella. Each pizza uses dough prepared fresh daily. Customers consistently rate our pizza as superior to regional competitors.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for events with options serving 8-15 people. Menu includes baked ziti, lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and custom salad combinations with protein upgrades. All catering orders use the same fresh ingredients as our regular menu.
Appetizers
Our appetizer menu features traditional Italian favorites like fried mozzarella, calamari, and homemade garlic knots. All appetizers use house-made marinara sauce and fresh ingredients prepared daily. Popular options include buffalo tenders and arancini with mozzarella filling.
Delivery Service
We offer delivery service within Durham with a $3.00 fee. Orders can be placed by phone for both standard menu items and catering orders. Delivery times are optimized to maintain food quality and temperature during transport.
Takeout Orders
Customers can place takeout orders by phone for pickup at our Durham location. We maintain a dedicated pickup area for convenience. All takeout orders use insulated packaging to preserve food quality during transport.
Questions
What makes your pizza authentic New Haven-style?
Our pizza uses a thin, crispy crust with charred edges, house-made marinara, and premium mozzarella following traditional New Haven methods perfected since 2002.
Do you offer catering for large events?
Yes, we provide catering trays serving 8-15 people with options including baked ziti, lasagna, eggplant parmesan, and custom salads with protein upgrades.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept cash and major credit cards for both in-store and delivery orders.
Are there any current specials available?
Our Tuesday special offers a free small mozzarella pizza with purchase of any large pizza.
How can I place an order for delivery?
Call 860-349-5411 to place delivery orders within Durham. A $3.00 delivery fee applies to all orders.
Do you accommodate special dietary requests?
While we don't have specialty menus, we can modify many dishes upon request. Please contact us directly to discuss specific dietary needs.
Reviews (4)
Mike J.
Oct 23, 2021
Report
I love heath and all been coming here since i was a kid but he has soMe of the most incompetent highschool kids working here.. they are always messing up my order on the simplest of things. I can understand once in a while but twice in one week ... come onnnnn .. they need to hire some older more experienced staff imo
Carissa B.
May 09, 2021
Report
There are quite a few pizza options in my area but we always go for Carmines. My favorite is the arugula pizza and the arugula is always fresh and crunchy; my boyfriend (from New York) had clams casino pizza and said he'd never had better. We've never gone wrong ordering from here.
Penelope L.
Mar 06, 2021
Report
Amazing amazing amazing! The pizza is great the atmosphere is great and the garlic knots are to die for. I recently moved to the area and on my moving day I decided to get some pizza for everyone with my mom and we chose the closest place well I'm glad I did, the owner found out I was new to the area and gave me a free homemade frozen pizza and it was amazing even for being frozen, and the fresh pizza and garlic knots blew me away; I'm a New Yorker and have struggled finding pizza I love adjusting to the CT style but this has to be my favorite spot in the few years I've been here
E. S.
Jan 23, 2021
Report
Live in Northford and this is our "go to" spot. Everything is so good and prices are reasonable ! The dinners have generous portions and pizzas are always delicious. Love the sauce. The ONLY reason why I give it 4 stars is because it is always generally busy (which is GREAT) but the wait time for a simple order can be long. I do understand it is a small business and wait times will happen. Nevertheless we still get food from here ALL the time. Sometimes I just get hangry (LOL) and the wait time seems like ages when really it may not be THAT bad.