Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Dining in New Canaan, CT
Since 1967, Joe's Pizza has been a cornerstone of New Canaan's culinary scene, offering authentic Italian cuisine crafted with generations-old recipes. Founded by Neapolitan immigrants Giuseppe and Annunziata Colella, our pizzeria has remained family-owned and operated, now led by Lorenzo Colella. We specialize in homemade pizzas, pastas, and entrees, using time-honored techniques and fresh ingredients. Our commitment to quality is evident in every dish, from Nunzia Colella's legendary meatball recipe to our handcrafted Detroit-style pizza. We take pride in serving the community during major events and emergencies, including providing homemade beef stew to first responders during blizzards.

With over five decades of experience, we continue to uphold our tradition of excellence while embracing modern innovations like gluten-free options. Our cozy, family-friendly atmosphere and dedicated staff ensure every customer experiences the warmth and authenticity that define Joe's Pizza. We prioritize transparency in our sourcing and preparation methods, maintaining the highest standards of food safety and quality. Our menu reflects both our Italian heritage and our commitment to catering to diverse dietary needs, including gluten-free and vegetarian options. Through consistent quality and community engagement, we've earned our reputation as New Canaan's premier pizzeria.
Services
Pizza Pasta Catering Gluten-Free Options Wings Calzones Salads Desserts Beverages Wraps
Details
  • Year established: 1967
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1967 with generations of Italian culinary expertise
  • House-made recipes using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients daily
  • Offers gluten-free and vegetarian options without compromising quality
  • Recognized for exceptional service during community emergencies
  • Features multiple pizza styles including Detroit and Sicilian
What people say
Best gluten-free pizza Cozy atmosphere Awesome staff Excellent Grandma pizza Superb food quality
Services
Pizza
Our pizza features multiple styles including New York, Sicilian, Detroit, and gluten-free options. Each pie uses house-made dough and organic tomato sauce with premium toppings like Wisconsin brick cheese and Ezzo pepperoni. Customers consistently praise our crispy crusts and creative combinations like the Truffled Shroom and Hot Capi pizzas.
Catering
We provide full-service catering for events of all sizes featuring our signature dishes. Our catering menu includes baked ziti, penne vodka, and grinder platters that serve 10-50 guests. Clients appreciate our reliable delivery and presentation that maintains food quality for events at corporate offices, schools, and private homes.
Gluten-Free Options
Our certified gluten-free menu includes pizzas, pasta, and calzones made in a dedicated preparation area. We use separate utensils and fryers to prevent cross-contamination while maintaining the same quality standards. Customers with dietary restrictions consistently praise our gluten-free options as some of the best they've experienced.
Wings
We offer jumbo wings in nine specialty flavors including Mike's Hot Honey and Asian-inspired orange ginger. Our wings use fresh, never-frozen chicken marinated for 24 hours with house-made sauces. Regular customers specifically mention our wing flavors as a key reason for repeat visits and weekend gatherings.
Pasta
Our pasta menu features traditional Italian dishes like baked ziti and penne vodka with house-made sauces. We offer gluten-free rigatoni as an alternative and allow customization with proteins like grilled chicken or Italian sausage. Regular patrons highlight our creamy penne pesto and family-style portions as standout offerings.
People
Lorenzo Colella
Owner
Third-generation pizzaiolo Lorenzo Colella now runs Joe's Pizza, continuing the family tradition started by his grandparents in 1967. He oversees daily operations while maintaining the original recipes and quality standards that have made the restaurant a local institution.
Giuseppe Colella
Founder
Neapolitan immigrant Giuseppe Colella opened Joe's Pizza in 1967, establishing New Canaan's first pizzeria with his wife Annunziata. Their traditional Italian recipes and commitment to quality created the foundation for the restaurant's enduring success across three generations.
Questions
What makes Joe's Pizza different from other local pizzerias?
We use generations-old family recipes with house-made ingredients daily, including our Detroit-style pizza with Wisconsin brick cheese and our certified gluten-free menu options.
Do you offer catering services for events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering with options serving 10-50 guests, featuring baked ziti, penne vodka, and grinder platters delivered fresh to your location.
Are there gluten-free options available?
We offer a certified gluten-free menu including pizzas, pasta, and calzones prepared in a dedicated area with separate equipment to prevent cross-contamination.
What are your most popular menu items?
Customers consistently praise our Detroit-style pizza, Truffled Shroom pizza, and house-made wings, particularly our Mike's Hot Honey flavor.
How can I place an order?
Orders can be placed by calling (203) 966-2226 or through our online ordering platform at slice.com/joescanct.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Wednesday-Thursday 4-9 PM, Friday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM, and Sunday 4-9 PM, with Mondays and Tuesdays closed for regular service.
Reviews (7)
David Smith
Nov 02, 2021 Report
You have probably heard a lot of people talking about Bitcoin, some people don’t like the idea of money just sitting in a savings account. You've likely heard of Coinbase, the largest of these exchanges. It is a life changing opportunity to join the moving train now. This professional Mr David Smith can walk you through the steps of how you can… have your own bitcoins and grow them for maximum profits so you can be a part of this massive wealth transfer. I hope I just fulfilled my promise sir. Text/WhatsApp 323 741 2749 Mail info@aivestcapital.xyz
Chaz B.
Jul 26, 2021 Report
Outrageously good pizza. Due to the fact that I live like 40 minutes away, I grabbed two pies, a Grandma with sausage (sounds inappropriate when I read it out loud) and a plain Detroit style, which is very difficult to find in the northeast. Both were really amazing and seemed to be made with high quality ingredients. Without question, I'm making the trip there again, and probably sooner than later. My buddy told me I was nuts to drive so far "just for pizza"; I told him to enjoy his Domino's.
Always Sunny
May 01, 2021 Report
Genuinely my favorite pizza place around. Their food is fresh, hot and delicious. Everytime!!! I have not been disappointed...
... Lorenzo, the owner, is a sweet man. Always pleasant, always makes me feel welcomed. Local kids and drivers are respectful and prompt and courteous. I recommend Joe's Pizza very much so!
Marie A.
Apr 18, 2021 Report
Probably the best pizza in the immediate area. The Sicilian is super fluffy, I love it, but if you don't like it, ask them to leave off the Parmesan cheese. The sauce us a little thick and over-spiced but that's my only complaint. It's quite good. Not as good as I can get if I want to drive towards New Haven or towards Mount Vernon but definitely can recommend.
Jacci D.
Apr 10, 2021 Report
I'm annoyed that I haven't tried this place yet! Best grandma pie around! I got the house tomatoe pie on a grandma crust. Wow.
John W.
Apr 09, 2021 Report
I discovered Joe's Pizza fairly recently. Being from Bay Ridge, BKLYN originally...we're 'pizza and Italian Food 'Snobs'...I mean great pizza in toney New Canaan, CT?!...Larry 'shut my big mouth' Their flavors, sauce and OMG The Crust?!...fuhgeddaboutit!!! This place is a wonderful find for a New Yawker and BKLYN Boy like me! I can't wait to try their pasta, wedges, etc. You gotta' add JOE's to your 'must try' List! Ciao! Johnny W
Ivanka B.
Mar 02, 2021 Report
I'm an idiot for not trying this pizza sooner! Less than a mile from work and easy pickup window but what took them over the top was offering that fresh burrata on top!! So few places offer my favorite, decadent cheese and this cut the saltiness of "original" cheese pizza underneath. Crispy, yeasty crust and delicious sauce with fresh basil - I was in heaven on a Tuesday. Perfect combo :-)