Business Details
37 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Catering in Ithaca, NY
Sal's Pizzeria has been a family-owned cornerstone of Ithaca's dining scene since 1989, dedicated to crafting authentic Italian cuisine using time-honored methods. Our commitment to quality begins with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, house-made dough and sauces, and traditional stone-oven baking techniques perfected over decades. Founded by Salvatore Melice, a Sicilian immigrant with deep culinary roots, our establishment has maintained its reputation for excellence through three generations of leadership. We specialize in creating memorable dining experiences through our signature pizzas, family recipes, and exceptional catering services for events of all sizes. Our team's collective 80+ years of pizza-making expertise ensures every slice meets the highest standards of flavor and authenticity.We take pride in serving our community with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that reflects our family values and dedication to customer satisfaction. From our kitchen to your table, we maintain strict quality control over every ingredient, preparation method, and service interaction. Our recent transition to new leadership under Sabrina and Abbey ensures continuity of tradition while embracing modern hospitality standards. We offer flexible dining options including dine-in, carry-out, and limited-area delivery with carefully maintained service hours. Through decades of operation, we've built lasting relationships with local suppliers and customers, reinforcing our position as Ithaca's trusted destination for genuine Italian cuisine.
Services
Pizza Delivery
Catering Services
Dine-In Dining
Carry-Out Orders
Stone-Oven Pizzas
Details
- Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1989 with 35+ years of pizza-making tradition
- Uses fresh, locally sourced ingredients in all house-made recipes
- Offers catering services with 24-hour advance order requirement
- Maintains 3.5% cash discount for loyal local customers
- Led by team with combined 80+ years of pizza industry expertise
What people say
Amazing traditional pizza
Family-friendly atmosphere
Reliable catering service
Fresh ingredients daily
Community staple for years
Services
Stone-Oven Pizzas
Our signature stone-oven pizzas feature house-made dough, fresh tomato sauce, and premium toppings cooked to perfection. Each pizza uses family recipes passed through generations for authentic flavor. Available for dine-in, carry-out, and limited delivery within Ithaca.
Catering Services
Full-service catering for events includes fresh-prepared pizzas, antipasti, and Italian specialties. Requires 24-hour advance notice to ensure quality preparation. Serves office parties, birthdays, and community events with delivery options.
Dine-In Experience
Enjoy our warm, family-friendly atmosphere with table service and full menu access. Open daily except Tuesdays, offering lunch and dinner service with seasonal holiday hours adjustments for community celebrations.
Carry-Out Orders
Freshly prepared pizzas and Italian dishes available for immediate pickup during operating hours. Features expedited service for customers preferring to enjoy meals at home with 3.5% cash discount option.
Limited Delivery
Delivery service covers specified Ithaca areas with set time windows matching kitchen preparation schedules. Maintains food quality through insulated packaging during transport to ensure optimal dining experience upon arrival.
People
Salvatore Melice
Founder
Sicilian immigrant who opened Sal's Pizzeria in 1989 after 15 years in the restaurant industry. Established the business's commitment to traditional pizza-making methods and fresh ingredients.
Joe Tilton
Former Partner
Joined in 1990 with pizza-making experience since 1982, became business partner in 1999. Contributed 30+ years of operational expertise before retiring in 2024 while maintaining quality standards.
Sabrina Tilton
Current Partner
Joined family business in 2020 after healthcare career, learned operations from Sal and Joe. Focuses on continuing legacy of quality food and community relationships through third generation leadership.
Abbey
Current Partner
Became business partner in 2024 with Sabrina, trained by previous owners in traditional methods. Committed to maintaining authentic pizza-making practices while modernizing customer service approaches.
Questions
What makes Sal's Pizzeria unique?
We're a family-owned business since 1989 using traditional Sicilian methods with fresh, house-made ingredients for authentic Italian cuisine.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for events with 24-hour advance notice, offering fresh-prepared pizzas and Italian specialties for pickup or delivery.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept Visa, MasterCard, Discover, American Express, Apple Pay, and cash with a 3.5% discount for cash payments.
Are there delivery options available?
Yes, we offer limited-area delivery within Ithaca during specified time windows matching our kitchen preparation schedules.
What are your operating hours?
We're open daily except Tuesdays, serving 11AM-8:30PM Sun/Mon/Wed/Thu and 11AM-9:30PM Fri/Sat, with holiday schedule adjustments.
Reviews (6)
Frances Rose
Aug 21, 2021
Report
We ordered a pizza and wings for delivery to the marina and it was absolutely delicious!!!!!The wings were perfection!!!!We will definitely order again from Sals.EXCELLENT!
Aaron SMith
Aug 17, 2021
Report
Impossible. A large half chicken wing half pepperoni pizza and an antipasto salad arrived at my door 17 minutes after I called. It was delicious and well cooked.
Krystin Boland
Aug 11, 2021
Report
Me and my son had a date day today. We hiked Tauganouk Falls and went looking for lunch. I googled best pizza in Ithaca and Sal's came up!! Best pizza is an understatement! Some of the best pizza I ever had and cheese steak sandwich did not disappoint! I highly recommend this place!
Leon Anderson
Aug 01, 2021
Report
I have been going to Sals for 30
Years! They have the best Pizza in the area, their wings are amazing and I love everything they have! Great place to eat and the Family that owns Sals Pizza are amazing! They treat you like one of the family! I would recommend going to Sals Pizzaria over any other restaurant in Ithaca!
Years! They have the best Pizza in the area, their wings are amazing and I love everything they have! Great place to eat and the Family that owns Sals Pizza are amazing! They treat you like one of the family! I would recommend going to Sals Pizzaria over any other restaurant in Ithaca!
Dave Wisdom
Jun 22, 2021
Report
Your neighborhood pizza - sounds, smells, and feels like everything you would expect. The service was excellent from Addy (spelling?), the pizza was delicious and the beer was fresh.
Smruti Chokhawala Parekh
May 20, 2021
Report
Highly recommend the Pizza joint.
Pesto pizza was outstanding. We order well done pesto pizza with jalapeos, onions and green pepper. Spicy delight.
Veggie pizza was yummy too. We substituted mushrooms with pineapple. This mom and pop pizza place is something worth trying and it's value for money and time. In the end my tummy was happy. The helpers here are very friendly and accommodating. We are vegetarian family and we had no hard time explaining them anything. They really knew what we were talking and asking for.
Pesto pizza was outstanding. We order well done pesto pizza with jalapeos, onions and green pepper. Spicy delight.
Veggie pizza was yummy too. We substituted mushrooms with pineapple. This mom and pop pizza place is something worth trying and it's value for money and time. In the end my tummy was happy. The helpers here are very friendly and accommodating. We are vegetarian family and we had no hard time explaining them anything. They really knew what we were talking and asking for.