Business Details
27 Years
experience
Authentic Pizza & Italian Delights in Elmira, NY
Since 1999, Vincenzo's Pizzeria has been crafting authentic Neapolitan and Sicilian pizzas in Elmira, NY, using fresh dough and high-quality ingredients. Owned by Vinnie and Dominic, our combined 50 years of culinary expertise ensure every pie reflects traditional Italian flavors. We specialize in signature pizzas like The Sinatra and Leonardo D'Vinci, alongside hoagies, salads, wings, and calzones. Our commitment to quality extends to every menu item, from garlic knots to house-made pasta.With dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, we serve both locals and visitors seeking genuine Italian cuisine. Our team prioritizes friendly service and community engagement, evidenced by partnerships with Elmira's Sister City in Japan. While our pricing remains mid-range, we emphasize freshness and portion size. Regulars praise our thin-crust perfection and hearty subs, though we welcome feedback to enhance the guest experience continually.
Services
Pizza
Wings
Salads
Hoagies
Calzones
Pasta
Stromboli
Garlic Knots
Desserts
Party Packs
Details
- Year established: 1999
Highlights and features
- We combine 50 years of pizza-making expertise to perfect every crust.
- Our specialty pizzas feature fresh, house-prepared ingredients daily.
- Friendly staff ensures personalized service for dine-in, pickup, or delivery.
- Menu includes award-winning thin-crust options praised as Elmira's best.
- Family recipes passed through generations guarantee authentic Italian flavor.
What people say
Amazing NY like pizza
Outstanding food
Best pizza in town
Great thin-crust pizzas
Service with a smile
Services
Neapolitan Pizza
Our Neapolitan pizzas feature hand-stretched dough baked to perfection with San Marzano tomato sauce and imported mozzarella. Customers praise the crisp yet chewy texture, with options like The Sinatra (chicken, bacon, tomatoes) and Leonardo D'Vinci (pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage) showcasing premium toppings. Perfect for diners seeking authentic Italian flavors in Elmira.
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian pizzas offer a thick, airy crust topped with house-made garlic white sauce and generous portions of toppings. The Prima Vera (white garlic, marinated tomatoes, basil) and Caesar's (ricotta, garlic, broccoli) highlight fresh ingredients. This style appeals to those preferring heartier slices with robust flavor combinations, available for dine-in or delivery.
Chicken Wings
Hand-tossed chicken wings come in mild, medium, hot, or garlic sauce with house-made blue cheese dressing. Served by the dozen, they feature fresh ingredients and consistent cooking. Regulars recommend pairing them with garlic knots for a satisfying starter. Available for takeout in quart containers or as part of party packs.
Italian Hoagies
Hoagies use fresh-baked bread layered with premium meats, cheeses, and house-prepared dressings. Options include Philly cheesesteak, chicken parmigiana, and Italian vegetarian. The Vinny Burger special adds fries and a drink. Hot and cold varieties cater to diverse tastes, with extra provolone cheese available for enhanced flavor.
Party Platters
Party packs serve groups with combinations of pizzas, wings, and soda. The single pack includes one large pizza and a dozen wings, while the party pack doubles portions. Ideal for birthdays, sports events, or office gatherings, these value-priced options ensure fresh, hot delivery with customizable toppings for large orders.
People
Vinnie
Co-Owner
With 25 years of pizza-making experience, Vinnie oversees dough preparation and recipe development, ensuring traditional Italian authenticity in every menu item.
Dominic
Co-Owner
Dominic manages daily operations and customer service, applying his 25-year culinary background to maintain quality standards and community relationships.
Questions
What pizza styles do you offer?
We serve both Neapolitan (thin crust) and Sicilian (thick crust) pizzas with over 15 specialty options featuring premium toppings.
Can I order online for delivery?
Yes, our website allows online ordering for delivery or pickup. Visit our 'Order Online' page to place your request instantly.
Are party catering options available?
We offer party packs serving groups of all sizes, including combinations of pizzas, wings, and drinks. Contact us directly for large orders.
What are your current business hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11 AM-9 PM, Friday 11 AM-10 PM, Saturday 3 PM-9 PM, and Sunday 4 PM-9 PM.
Do you have vegetarian menu options?
Yes, we offer vegetarian pizzas, stromboli, salads, and garlic knots. Our chefs can customize any pizza without meat upon request.
Videos
Reviews (5)
Danielle Hernandez
Feb 01, 2022
Report
Vincenzo's is hands down one of the best Italian pizza places in the Elmira area. Decent prices and variety yes, but the main thing is their quality. Absolutely delicious every time I've gone. Not to mention the cannolis and tiramisu available there, sooo good. My favorite is the Dinero pizza, but I love trying out whatever specialty slices they have on hand for a quick bite.
Chad Maphis
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Sadly overpriced for additional toppings, and not even a top 50 for returning. Wings were mild and lacked flavor, tasting more like they were coated in the oil they were fried in! Not a place I may ever try ordering from again!!!
Terri Kozier
Sep 26, 2021
Report
My husband and I ordered two pizzas for our wedding party two&1/2 months ago, I had several pieces left over so in the freezer they went ! I just pulled the leftovers out for lunch and they were as delicious as they were on July 2nd !!! Fantastic job you guys, BRAVO ! I WILL order any of their pizzas, especially the Frank Sinatra Sincerely, Richard and Terri Bywater ! Elmira, NY
Rena Banks
Sep 12, 2021
Report
We were passing through Elmira on a road trip and stopped to grab Subway. We saw Vincenzos beside Subway and a guy walking out with a sub so we decided to stop in there instead. Best decision ever! We had an Italian and a tuna sub. We didnt know they were coming with fries so that was an awesome surprise. The subs were so delicious! The bread was warm and crispy and was my favorite part but the tuna I had was also so good. 10/10 would go here again if I ever find myself in that town again!
Anthea Cavallaro
Aug 12, 2021
Report
The pizza here is good. It's hard to find NY style pizza in Elmira so I'm glad to have found Vincenzo's. They're cheesecake is also amazing! Prices are fair and they deliver. If you want real pizza (not chain restaurant pizza) definitely check out Vincenzo's.