Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
35 Years
experience
Family-Owned Pizza & Italian Cuisine in Windham, NH
Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated eatery established in 1991, rooted in tradition and quality. Our commitment to excellence began with founder John Souliotis, who built the business on principles of hard work, customer care, and culinary integrity. Over three decades, weve perfected our signature secret sauce, unique crust recipe, and cheese blend, creating a distinctive pizza experience. Our menu evolved through customer feedback, offering diverse options from gourmet pizzas to Greek specialties. We maintain rigorous ingredient standards, personally inspecting deliveries to ensure freshness.

Generational expertise informs every dish, with owners Taso and Angelo continuing their fathers legacy of hospitality. Our welcoming atmosphere fosters community connections, with regulars becoming part of our extended family. Transparency in sourcing and preparation remains central to our operations. Customer satisfaction drives continuous improvement, from recipe adjustments to service enhancements. Today, we remain Windhams trusted destination for handcrafted Italian cuisine, blending tradition with innovation.
Services
Pizzas Calzones Subs Salads Dinners Side Orders Greek Specialties Burgers Chicken Wings
Details
  • Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
  • Weve served Windham since 1991 with generational pizza-making expertise
  • Our secret sauce recipe has been perfected over three decades
  • We use only the freshest ingredients inspected daily by owners
  • Custom menu options accommodate diverse tastes and dietary needs
  • Our welcoming atmosphere turns first-time guests into regulars
What people say
Best secret sauce Fresh ingredients Family-friendly vibe Generational expertise Consistent quality
Services
Pizzas
Handcrafted pizzas made with fresh dough, secret sauce, and a unique cheese blend. Available in classic and gourmet varieties with customizable toppings. Perfect for any occasion.
Calzones
Stuffed folded pizzas filled with premium ingredients and baked to golden perfection. Choose from traditional or specialty recipes for a hearty meal.
Greek Specialties
Authentic Greek dishes including gyros and specialty pizzas with feta cheese, olives, and Mediterranean seasonings. Served with house-made sides.
Dinners
Full-course meals featuring Italian classics like pasta, chicken parmesan, and roast beef. Includes salad, fries, and onion rings for complete satisfaction.
Side Orders
Shareable sides including mozzarella sticks, chicken wings, and garlic bread. Perfect for starting meals or complementing any entree.
People
John Souliotis
Founder
Established the pizzeria in 1991, developing the secret sauce and quality standards that remain foundational to the business today.
Taso Souliotis
Co-Owner
Continues family tradition with hands-on management, ensuring recipe consistency and maintaining customer relationships built over decades.
Angelo Souliotis
Co-Owner
Oversees daily operations while preserving the familys culinary legacy and commitment to using only the freshest ingredients.
Questions
What makes your pizza unique?
Our secret sauce recipe, developed over 30 years, and custom cheese blend create our signature flavor profile.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full catering for events with custom menu options and delivery within Windham.
Are there gluten-free options available?
We offer gluten-free crusts and can accommodate special dietary requirements with advance notice.
What are your most popular menu items?
Customers love our Cobbetts Pond Special pizza, Greek gyro, and Chicken Alfredo entree with broccoli and ziti.
Do you deliver?
Yes, we offer delivery within Windham and surrounding areas through our website ordering system.
Reviews (5)
Michael Maillet
Sep 25, 2021 Report
Honestly not great. Ive gone here a few times because they are the closest to me but they really arent good. Food isnt that good and you dont get a lot. Honestly wont go back. Kept trying to find something good and I just cant
MamaBear
Sep 12, 2021 Report
First time going here and definitely won't be the last. I got the basic cheese pizza but I swear it was made with love. It's was so good. The service was fast and efficient. Hands down the best little spot.
B. M.
May 30, 2021 Report
This is easily the best pizza place in Windham and Ive tried them all over the last 20 years. Great pizza, subs and salads and the prices are good too. On top of that, its a family owned business with the same father and sons running it since it opened. If you want great food and a staff that actually cares about you and the quality of the food they serve you, look no further than Cobbetts Pond Pizzeria.
Nicholas Bozovic
Feb 19, 2021 Report
The pizza here is a grease fest. And im not talking about some gross mess. Im talking a real old school greasy pepperoni pizza. Its like the cure for a hangover and depression baked to perfection.
Im not sure what it is about this place, be it fresh ingredients, or just the comfort food appeal, but something here really rocks. There isn't another place i can even think of that makes a pie quite like the one found here. The flavor is so satisfying, the grease is so indulgent, and yet, I don't feel like absolute garbage after eating even a whole pizza. Good job everyone.
Alex Quinto
Dec 24, 2019 Report
The food is fine nothing spectacular they have what you need for a pizza and sub shop. Unfortunately they take forever to have your order ready even when the place is empty; it feels like they forgot about you until you place your order and then when you ask for it they start making it. They also NEVER toast my sub even when I say extra! They cannot toast a sub if their lives depended on it. Every time I ask for it toasted and every time its soggy bread. Its sad because out of the pizza shops in the area this is the best one! Theyd have an amazing business if they just stepped up the service