All of our pizzas are made to order and start with house made dough, sauce and 100% Wisconsin cheese blend in an oldtime stone oven. Turnover made with 12 pizza dough with red sauce, pepperoni, mushrooms, mozzarella and Italian sausage. Classic style big pizza turnover with mozzarella cheese and your choice of any two toppings.
At Neely's Pizzeria, you can get a regular stone oven pizza with all of the traditional toppings or choose from one of several specialty pizzas that are distinctive creations by Jon himself. Also, check out the awesome Calzones, Salads, Stromboli and many other unique dishes. If you are looking for authentic pizza with a great taste, come on by and give us a try--you won't be disappointed!
At Neely's Pizzeria, you can get a regular stone oven pizza with all of the traditional toppings or choose from one of several specialty pizzas that are distinctive creations by Jon himself. Also, check out the awesome Calzones, Salads, Stromboli and many other unique dishes. If you are looking for authentic pizza with a great taste, come on by and give us a try--you won't be disappointed!
Services
Menu
Report
All of our pizzas are made to order and start with house made dough, sauce and 100% real Wisconsin cheese blend, in an old time stone deck oven. It's real pizza! Classic style big pizza turnover with mozzarella cheese and your choice of any two toppings. Served with sauce on the side. Turnover made with 12 pizza dough with red sauce, pepperoni, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese and Italian sausage.
Reviews
Report
In a city being overrun by a plague of corporate chains, Neely's Pizzeria offers some hope that authenticity and small business still has a place on the Northshore. Though the hours are quirky for a pizza joint, I find them to be the best place for carry out or delivery. Ranging from the delicious extremes of the Vegetarian and the Carnivore, the pies are crafted with high quality ingredients that appease even the most persistent cravings.
Reviews (10)
Cherylyn Webb
Apr 11, 2021
Report
Rebecca Wade
Mar 15, 2021
Report
Mike Nathanson
Feb 16, 2021
Report
Brian McCoy
Nov 12, 2020
Report
We have been searching high and low for a new favorite, go-to pizza place since moving here over a year ago. We have tried several, several, SEVERAL places and this one is by far the best we have had! My wife actually called the owner directly after our family devoured his pizza to tell him how thankful we are to have found them! The dough is so light and airy and the fresh ingredients homemade sauce just make it a near perfect pie.
Jeannine Brumfield
Aug 12, 2020
Report
Chris Ward
Aug 01, 2020
Report
Jesse Hasenkampf
Jul 20, 2020
Report
Really good pizza in a small family owned neighborhood restaurant. New owners recently bought the place from the original proprietors, but I’ve seen no drop in quality or consistency. The food tastes exactly like it did under the previous owners, so they obviously have all the recipes and techniques down. In all honesty, I think these owners are more friendly and engaging than the previous. I’ll keep going there for my go-to neighborhood pizza joint.
Sam Flores
Jul 16, 2020
Report
This pizzeria is a breath of fresh air! Hand made dough from a family recipe combined with high quality ingredients make for an absolutely delicious pizza. We, personally, tried the Cheese, Pepperoni, Carnivore and Margherita pizzas and my family loved all of them. We also treated ourselves to the homemade Baklava and Cannolis and I can honestly say that I have never had such wonderful delights. A perfect end to a wonderful meal.
Neely’s is owned and operated by a hard working Italian family whom are ever present in the kitchen. Their children greet you upon entering as they play in the dining
Neely’s is owned and operated by a hard working Italian family whom are ever present in the kitchen. Their children greet you upon entering as they play in the dining
Kelly Trail
Nov 17, 2019
Report
Jc Watts
Oct 12, 2019
Report
