Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in Wyckoff, NJ
Pizzeria Mandara is a family-owned Southern Italian restaurant rooted in tradition and authenticity. Since 1960, we have carried forward the legacy of our founder Alfonso Mandara, who brought his passion for Italian cuisine from Positano to Brooklyn before establishing our Wyckoff location. Our menu reflects generations of culinary heritage, featuring handcrafted pizzas, housemade pastas, and classic Italian dishes prepared with fresh local ingredients and time-honored techniques. We prioritize quality and hospitality, creating a warm atmosphere where guests experience the Italian philosophy of gathering around the table to share meals and stories.

With over 60 years of combined family expertise, we maintain rigorous standards for ingredient sourcing, recipe authenticity, and service excellence. Our commitment to preserving traditional flavors while embracing modern culinary expectations positions us as a trusted destination for Italian cuisine in Northern New Jersey.
Services
New York-style pizza Southern Italian cuisine Family recipes Gluten-free options Lunch & Dinner
Details
  • Year established: 1960
Highlights and features
  • We serve authentic Southern Italian cuisine using family recipes dating to 1960.
  • Our menu features fresh local ingredients and quality imports from Italy.
  • Third-generation family ownership maintains rigorous culinary and hospitality standards.
  • We offer a warm, welcoming atmosphere inspired by Italian dining traditions.
  • Our chefs combine traditional techniques with modern culinary innovations.
Services
New York-style pizza
Hand-tossed New York-style pizzas baked in a brick oven with housemade sauces and premium toppings. Available in classic combinations or customizable options with fresh mozzarella, imported ingredients, and traditional preparation methods. Serves families and individuals seeking authentic Italian flavors.
Southern Italian cuisine
Authentic Southern Italian dishes featuring housemade pastas, slow-cooked sauces, and family recipes passed through three generations. Menu includes seafood specialties, meat entrees, and vegetable-forward options prepared with seasonal ingredients and traditional techniques from Positano.
Family recipes
Time-honored recipes originating from the Mandara family's hometown of Positano, Italy. Includes housemade meatballs, slow-cooked ragus, and signature pasta dishes that preserve the flavors and techniques of Southern Italian home cooking traditions across six decades.
Gluten-free options
Dedicated gluten-free menu items including pizza crusts and pasta alternatives. Prepared with separate equipment and ingredients to accommodate dietary restrictions while maintaining authentic Italian flavors and quality standards for guests with special needs.
Lunch & Dinner
Open daily for lunch and dinner with consistent hours seven days a week. Offers full menu service during operating hours, including takeout, dine-in, and catering options for special occasions with advance reservations recommended for peak times.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Pizzeria Mandara serve?
We specialize in authentic Southern Italian cuisine featuring wood-fired pizzas, housemade pastas, and traditional dishes from Positano, Italy using family recipes dating to 1960.
Are reservations required?
Reservations are recommended but not required, especially during peak hours. You can make reservations through our website or by calling (201) 848-9336.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we provide gluten-free pizza crusts and pasta alternatives prepared with dedicated equipment to maintain quality while accommodating dietary restrictions.
What are your operating hours?
We're open daily: Monday-Thursday 11:30AM-9PM, Friday-Saturday 11:30AM-9PM, and Sunday 12PM-8:30PM for lunch and dinner service.
Can I order food online?
Yes, our full menu is available for online ordering through our website. You can also place orders by phone at (201) 848-9336 for pickup or delivery.
Do you accommodate food allergies?
Our kitchen handles common allergens but takes precautions. Please inform us of allergies or dietary restrictions when ordering to ensure safe meal preparation.
Reviews (7)
Joshy E.
Jan 30, 2022 Report
Attitude comes a long a way. The waiter I had tonight was completely rude. I felt completely rushed to order and felt as if they wanted me out. Good food but the staff environment is completely disgraceful to their guests.
Richard L.
Jan 15, 2022 Report
Maybe a mistake or an omission happened. When I got the pizza home it was made with the regular crust instead of the thin crust that I ordered. We were so hungry we ate it. It tasted okay other than the spongy crust it had. Next time we'll stick to the Amy's thin crust pie rather than spend $29 on this one. In hindsight, when dissatisfied with a food order it's best to call the business to alert them of the issue.
Hannah M.
Jan 01, 2022 Report
We placed a pre order for New Years Eve at 2:30 for our meal to be ready at 7:30. When we arrived, we were told it would be an additional 15 minutes which we were fine with because we understand kitchens can get backed up and it was a holiday! However, after 15 minutes we checked on our order and we were told an additional 20 minutes. After 45 minutes our food finally came out, the staff was rude and uncommunicative about wait times and our frustrations. This situation is even worse because this exact same issue happened with another takeout order we placed a few months ago which was ready 45 minutes
Jan Mark L.
Jan 01, 2022 Report
Food is amazing however their systems gotta be better during dinner. Ordered ahead and was told it'll be about 1.5 hours which is understandable since it's New Year's Eve. However upon arrival I had to wait an extra 1 hour and 3 minutes to be exact. Pizza cold since the pizza has been on waiting for over an hour for the other orders. The people in the queue to pick up are pissed because everyone was told over an hour to pick up and all have to wait an extra hour. I would definitely reconsider ordering from here if it's a busy night or a holiday otherwise food is definitely
Stephy G.
Dec 14, 2021 Report
Pizzeria Mandara is a fairly large Pizzeria / restaurant with lots of seating, every time I've visited I've never ran into an issue of having to wait 30+ minutes for my table which is gold especially when you make plans to visit on the fly. Service is spotty to be honest, on some visits I'll have the most attentive waiters/waitresses however on others I'll have those who lack social skills and basically forget to check in.

Pizza's are delicious - my favorite is the vodka pie, but you can never go wrong with a plain cheese pie though my husband would argue that the best
Beth M.
Oct 01, 2021 Report
Food is good but staff is not accommodating. There was 2 of us for dinner and the restaurant was 1/2 full. I asked for a booth (2 out of the 3) were empty but they wouldn't let us sit there because there had to be 4 people To get a booth.
1/2 hour later they sat 2 people at the booth and the other booth was empty rest of the night .......
Toni G.
Feb 03, 2021 Report
This is the best Italian restaurant and pizzeria in the area. Excellent EVERYTHING! Always consistent in quality and service. I've been eating here for many years, never disappointed, not even once!!! Oh by the way, I'm 100% Italian!! My grandparents were amazing cooks!