Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
10 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in Middletown, NY
At Pecorino's Pizzeria, we are dedicated to delivering authentic Italian comfort food with a focus on family hospitality. Established in 2016 in Middletown, New York, our menu features traditional pizza, pasta, salads, and dinner specialties crafted with the freshest ingredients. Our founders, Marco and Iris Coria, prioritize quality products and meaningful guest relationships, ensuring every dish reflects our passion for Italian cuisine. We offer dine-in, takeout, and catering services, with daily specials and a commitment to exceptional service.

Our kitchen emphasizes wholesome, decadent flavors evident in every meal, from classic Margherita pizzas to seafood specialties. With convenient online ordering and a beautiful dining room, we aim to make every customer feel part of the Pecorino's family. Our reviews highlight praise for our fresh, flavorful food, attentive service, and spotless environment, reinforcing our position as a community favorite.
Services
Pizza Pasta Salads Catering Takeout
Details
  • Year established: 2016
Highlights and features
  • We offer handcrafted Italian dishes using fresh, high-quality ingredients since 2016.
  • Our menu includes over 20 specialty pizzas with customizable toppings and gluten-free options.
  • We provide full-service catering for events of all sizes with custom menu planning.
  • Our online ordering system ensures quick and convenient meal pickup.
  • We maintain a spotless dining environment with attentive, friendly service.
What people say
Best fresh pizza Huge portions Excellent service Spotless environment Delicious shrimp parm
Services
Pizza
Our hand-tossed pizzas feature house-made dough topped with fresh ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, and premium meats. Customers can choose from 12 specialty pizzas or create custom combinations with over 20 toppings. Gluten-free and whole wheat crust options accommodate dietary preferences.
Catering
We provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Our team collaborates with clients to design custom menus featuring Italian favorites like pasta stations, antipasto platters, and wood-fired pizzas for groups of 10100+ guests.
Pasta
Classic Italian pasta dishes include house-made marinara, alfredo, and vodka sauces with options like spaghetti, penne, and gluten-free pasta. Signature items feature seafood, chicken, and veal preparations in traditional sauces like piccata, marsala, and francese.
Salads
Freshly prepared salads feature crisp greens, house-made dressings, and premium toppings like grilled shrimp, chicken, and house-cured meats. Options range from simple house salads to hearty chef's specials with salami, provolone, and ham.
Takeout
Our online ordering system allows customers to customize meals for quick pickup. Popular options include calzones, stromboli, and family meal bundles. Orders are prepared fresh and ready for pickup within 30 minutes during business hours.
People
Marco Coria
Co-Owner
Marco Coria co-founded Pecorino's Pizzeria in 2016, bringing decades of Italian culinary experience. He oversees kitchen operations and recipe development, ensuring traditional flavors meet modern quality standards.
Iris Coria
Co-Owner
Iris Coria co-owns Pecorino's Pizzeria with her husband Marco. She manages front-of-house operations and guest relations, creating a welcoming atmosphere that reflects their family-oriented business philosophy.
Questions
What are Pecorino's most popular menu items?
Our Margherita pizza, Chicken Parmigiana, and house-made garlic knots are top customer favorites.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events with custom menu planning and delivery options.
Are there gluten-free options available?
We offer gluten-free pasta and crust options for pizzas and calzones.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 11am-9pm and Sunday 12pm-9pm.
Can I order online for pickup?
Yes, our website allows full menu customization with quick pickup during business hours.
Reviews (6)
Terri Me Merone
Sep 16, 2021 Report
I ordered takeout tonight from Pecorinos.....as usual everything was delicious!! My favorite pizza place!
Kim Francois
Aug 19, 2021 Report
I gave them 3 stars for the following reasons. 1st they had no chicken wings. 2nd they were watching frozen when my husband walked in to pick up the pizza. Get up and address the customer. 3rd..pizza crust was good, but pizza is all about the sauce. The sauce had absolutely no flavor. Definitely not my favorite pizza place. For the size of the pizza the price was definitely not worth the food.
Felipe Mendoza
Jul 29, 2021 Report
Very friendly and I like the pizza. It's all I've ever gotten so I can't rate anything else. I would reccomend Pecorinis for pizza for sure.
Marte Garcia
Jul 01, 2021 Report
This is a gem hidden in plain sight!! Its a small family owned Pizzeria and they dont disappoint at all the service and the food is amazing. Kids loved the pizza and OMG that hot bread they give you while you wait its AMAZING!!! I could just eat that all day long!! But that cheeseburger i had with mushroom in telling you there was not "mushroom" left in me to finish it lol strongly recommend it!! 5
Toni Gundersen
Apr 15, 2021 Report
Pecorinos food never disappoints! Everything is delicious, has been our go to for years. You get treated like family. Well priced excellent portions.
Christian Enano
Mar 23, 2021 Report
Where is the best pizza from? I have been looking for it all over the place! Well i finally found it! In this friendly family owned business. The pizza is out of this world! The staff is so friendly and makes you feel welcomed. Love this place, strongly recommend to try this lovely place. 1