Business Details
12 Years
experience
Fresh Seafood Restaurant in Hilton Head Island
Since 2014, Carolina Crab has been a cornerstone of Hilton Head Island's dining scene, offering fresh seafood in a welcoming atmosphere. Located in the historic Palmetto Bay Marina, we combine coastal charm with culinary excellence, serving dishes ranging from classic crab cakes to innovative seafood creations. Our owners Brendan, Thomas, and Keith Reilley prioritize quality ingredients and approachable pricing, ensuring memorable dining experiences for locals and visitors alike.With daily service from 12:00 PM to 9:30 PM and a pet-friendly outdoor patio, we cater to diverse preferences while maintaining our commitment to Southern hospitality. Our menu features both traditional Lowcountry fare and contemporary seafood specialties, complemented by craft cocktails and regional beer selections.
Services
Seafood Entrees
Crab Cakes
Shrimp Boils
Lobster Dishes
Fish Tacos
Seafood Pasta
Cocktail Bar
Outdoor Dining
Lunch Service
Dinner Service
Details
- Year established: 2014
Highlights and features
- We offer Hilton Head Island's best crab cakes since 2014
- Our menu features fresh-caught Lowcountry seafood daily
- Pet-friendly outdoor dining available year-round
- Three generations of Reilley family seafood expertise
- Open daily serving lunch and dinner
What people say
Best seafood
Friendly staff
Perfect crab portions
Knowledgeable service
Delicious drinks
Services
Seafood Entrees
Our seafood entrees feature locally sourced ingredients prepared with Lowcountry traditions. From seared scallops with Parmesan risotto to blackened Mahi Mahi with mango salsa, each dish showcases coastal flavors. The menu changes seasonally to highlight fresh catches while maintaining classic favorites like our award-winning crab cakes.
Crab Cakes
Handcrafted using lump blue crab meat and traditional Southern techniques, our crab cakes are a Hilton Head culinary icon. Served with signature aioli and seasonal sides, this dish represents our commitment to quality. The recipe has been perfected over generations by the Reilley family's seafood expertise.
Shrimp Boils
Authentic Lowcountry shrimp boils served with kielbasa sausage, red potatoes, and corn. Available in multiple portion sizes including family-style servings. Prepared using time-honored steaming methods that preserve natural flavors while offering customizable spice levels for modern palates.
Cocktail Bar
Full-service bar featuring coastal-inspired cocktails like the C3 Breeze and Gin Dragon. Extensive beer selection includes regional craft brews and tropical lagers. Wine list showcases both domestic and international varietals complementing seafood dishes through carefully curated pairings.
Outdoor Dining
Pet-friendly outdoor patio with waterfront views of Palmetto Bay Marina. Available year-round with seasonal heating and cooling solutions. Combines casual atmosphere with premium service, offering full menu access and live music entertainment during peak seasons.
People
Brendan Reilley
Owner
Third-generation seafood expert with 15+ years in coastal restaurant management. Oversees menu development and quality control, ensuring traditional Lowcountry recipes meet modern culinary standards while maintaining family values.
Thomas Reilley
Owner
Operations specialist with extensive hospitality experience. Manages daily restaurant functions and staff training, maintaining consistent service excellence since the company's founding in 2014 through hands-on leadership.
Keith Reilley
Owner
Marketing and customer relations director with background in tourism development. Focuses on community engagement and digital presence, ensuring Carolina Crab remains Hilton Head's premier seafood destination through authentic guest experiences.
Questions
What makes your crab cakes special?
Our crab cakes use fresh lump blue crab meat with minimal filler, following a family recipe perfected over generations for authentic Lowcountry flavor.
Do you offer outdoor seating?
Yes, we have a pet-friendly waterfront patio open year-round with seasonal climate controls and live music entertainment during peak months.
Are reservations recommended?
Reservations are strongly advised for weekend evenings and peak season, though we accommodate walk-ins based on availability at our Hilton Head location.
What are your signature seafood dishes?
Our award-winning Carolina Crab Cake, Lowcountry Seafood Pasta with three types of seafood, and All You Can Eat Shrimp Boil on Mondays are customer favorites.
Do you serve lunch?
Yes, we offer full lunch service daily from 12:00 PM with a selection of seafood baskets, sandwiches, and small plates available until dinner service begins.
Reviews (7)
Tim P.
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Wife and I had dinner here 2 nights ago and were pleasantly surprised with the food. I had fried oyster basket with she crab soup and wife got the crab cakes. Being former residents of Calvert co Md and having a bunch of watermen friends we didn't expect really good crab cakes but we were wrong. Not exactly as good as Md but very well done. If you go try to get Valentina for service.
A. H.
Nov 05, 2021
Report
Our server was great, he had the entire patio and bar area, so he was busy. Outdoor seating and a portable heater since it was a bit chilly. We had the flounder, fish tacos, crab cakes and the steak. Very tasty, everyone was happy.
Brenda Cameron
Oct 18, 2021
Report
I was excited to try this place as it was part of the crab club and I had tried crazy crab earlier in the week an it was delicious. When I arrived with no reservations I was seated quickly. I was asked if I wanted to sit outside and I said sure only to be seated outside in a hallway or something. I was not able to see anything but the bar that was between me and outside. That was okay as I as I could watch the football games. I sat there for about 12 minutes before the bartender can over and asked if I had been helped. I told her no. She brought me some water and was nice to take my order. I wished
Deb W.
Sep 17, 2021
Report
Seated quickly. Band from the Black Marlin was overly loud on a shared porch. Lump crab cake was not lumpy And only half warmed half cold french fries were tepid with no flavor. Shrimp tasted very fishy? Spoiled? Fish tacos were enjoyed two of our party
Rod Pell
Sep 16, 2021
Report
Just because you're a "crowd favorite", it doesn't mean it's ok to skip details. This was one of the "okayest" meals I've had in a while. Our server was great though.
Keith G.
Sep 14, 2021
Report
The haddock sandwich is fantastic. It's more than a sandwich! The piece of fish is huge. Lightly fried and topped with a slice of cheese is an unusual combination but it works. Service is always good, view is nice and often has live music (sometimes from the other restaurant).
Sharon Tipmore
Sep 12, 2021
Report
We were a party of five with a 6:15 reservation. We were seated promptly and our server, Isaiah, took our drink order. The Painkillers and Bloody Marys were fantastic! Our dinner was ordered and served without delay. I had the crab stuffed flounder. One of the best meals Ive ever eaten! The roasted red pepper risotto was heavenly! Everyone around the table loved their meal. Our server Isaiah shared his beautiful smile and exceptional service throughout our meal. Well be back next trip!!