Business Details
37 Years
experience
Expert Jewelry Appraisals in Carle Place, NY
Jewelry Judge has been a trusted name in jewelry appraisal services since 1989, founded by Barry S. Block, a Master Gemologist Appraiser with decades of industry experience. Our mission is to blend art and science to preserve the past and protect the future through impartial, expert appraisals. We specialize in diamond, gemstone, watch, and fine jewelry appraisals for insurance, estate, divorce, and personal evaluation purposes. Unlike retail jewelers, we do not buy or sell jewelry, ensuring complete objectivity in every appraisal. Our process is transparent, educational, and conducted while you watch, with detailed documentation including high-resolution images of each item.With certifications from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), National Association of Jewelry Appraisers (NAJA), and American Society of Appraisers (ASA), we uphold the highest standards of integrity and professionalism. Our clients benefit from our commitment to accuracy, ethical practices, and unmatched customer service, making us the gold standard in the jewelry appraisal industry.
Services
Diamond Appraisals
Engagement Ring Appraisals
Watch Appraisals
Gemstone Appraisals
Insurance Appraisals
Estate Appraisals
Divorce Appraisals
Jewelry Authentication
Replacement Value Analysis
Expert Witness Services
Details
- Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
- We offer impartial appraisals with no conflict of interest.
- Our team holds elite certifications from GIA, NAJA, ASA, and AGA.
- Transparent 'While You Watch' appraisal process with detailed documentation.
- Over 30 years of experience in jewelry valuation and gemology.
- Commitment to ethical standards and client education.
Associations and certifications
- Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
- National Association of Jewelry Appraisers (NAJA)
- American Society of Appraisers (ASA)
- Accredited Gemologists Association (AGA)
What people say
Honest appraisal
Expert knowledge
Transparent process
Educational experience
Accurate valuations
Services
Diamond Appraisals
Our diamond appraisals analyze the 'Four C's'color, cut, clarity, and carat weightto determine accurate market value. We provide detailed grading reports, including internal characteristic plots for diamonds over 1 carat. Clients receive computer-generated documents with itemized descriptions and photographs, ensuring transparency and reliability for insurance or resale purposes.
Engagement Ring Appraisals
Specialized appraisals for engagement rings assess diamond quality, metal purity, and craftsmanship. We verify authenticity and provide replacement value estimates, ensuring proper insurance coverage. Our process educates clients on their ring's specifications while maintaining impartiality, as we do not engage in jewelry sales or purchases.
Watch Appraisals
We appraise luxury and vintage watches, focusing on brand authenticity, condition, and market demand. Our reports include detailed descriptions of materials, movement, and provenance. Clients benefit from our expertise in horology and access to current market trends, ensuring accurate valuations for insurance or estate planning.
Gemstone Appraisals
Our gemstone appraisals identify and value colored stones based on cut, color, clarity, and origin. We detect treatments like heat or irradiation and provide certification for natural characteristics. Clients receive comprehensive documentation with high-resolution images, supporting insurance claims or resale transactions.
Insurance Appraisals
We create detailed insurance appraisals that establish replacement costs for jewelry, ensuring adequate coverage. Our reports include market analysis, comparable sales data, and digital images. These documents protect clients from overpayment of premiums and ensure fair replacement in case of loss or damage.
People
Barry S. Block
President/CEO
Barry S. Block is a Graduate Gemologist (GIA) and Master Gemologist Appraiser (ASA) with over 50 years in the jewelry industry. He founded Jewelry Judge in 1989 and specializes in impartial appraisals for insurance, estate, and legal cases. His expertise includes diamond grading, gemstone identification, and expert witness testimony.
Questions
What services does The Jewelry Judge offer?
We specialize in impartial jewelry appraisals for diamonds, gemstones, watches, and fine jewelry. Services include insurance, estate, divorce, and pre-purchase evaluations.
Why choose The Jewelry Judge over other appraisers?
We are independent and certified by GIA, NAJA, ASA, and AGA. Our transparent 'While You Watch' process ensures no conflict of interest and full client education.
How do appraisals help with insurance coverage?
Our detailed reports establish accurate replacement values, preventing overpayment of premiums and ensuring proper coverage for lost or damaged items.
Can The Jewelry Judge appraise jewelry purchased abroad?
Yes, we evaluate jewelry from all sources, including international purchases, and identify potential issues like misrepresented quality or value.
What credentials do your appraisers hold?
Barry S. Block holds Graduate Gemologist (GIA), Certified Senior Appraiser (NAJA), and Master Gemologist AppraiserĀ® (ASA) certifications, ensuring industry-leading expertise.
Reviews (7)
Maristella V.
Jan 02, 2022
Report
My recent appraisal with Barry Block was one of the most professional, informative and pleasant business transactions. He appraised a Cartier watch and he was very knowledgeable and thorough. I feel I got a very fair appraisal but more than that, it was a great overall experience because he stayed engaged while sharing interesting stories and his thoughts on the watch he was appraising. The office was also very well protected with plastic sheets separating staff from customers. Very reasonable in price, too.
Josh G.
Sep 03, 2021
Report
Order in the court! All rise for the honorable Jewelry Judge...well, if you do visit this judicial-sounding fellow, it won't take place in a courthouse, and better yet, no actual judges will be present. Instead, you'll be dealing with Barry Block and his jewelry appraising business. That's just what my fiance and I did back in late July as we wanted to see what her engagement ring was truly worth.
I'll build on that word "worth" for a second because it's important to start off saying that Barry's business is 150% worth visiting, especially if you have
I'll build on that word "worth" for a second because it's important to start off saying that Barry's business is 150% worth visiting, especially if you have
David F.
Mar 13, 2021
Report
Don't. If you do bring it to another place for a 2nd assessment. He can tell you all about the size and clarity of your stones but his retail assessment is so askew that he should be reported to the BBB but cant be because it's a subjective pricing. When I got a 2nd and 3rd opinion one of the people actually knew of him and started ranting about what a fraud he is. In short he assessed my stones and gave them a RETAIL price of 3K. When I purchased I was told 18k. When I got a 2nd opinion I was told 18-20K. Throw away the money he will take from you and go somewhere else.
Gebe G.
Jul 11, 2020
Report
Great experience with Barry Block today. He was very responsive to e-mail and it was super easy to make an appointment. Pleasure to be around, you can tell he is extremely knowledgeable in his craft. He also takes all the appropriate measures for safe distancing during this pandemic (everyone in masks, a clear plastic barrier between him and you while you watch him work). Will definitely be back for future appraisals! Thank you so much!
Rebecca P.
Jan 10, 2020
Report
Very pleasant experience. I have total confidence in his work. I will absolutely go back if I need another appraisal someday.
Paul G.
Jan 07, 2020
Report
Was recommended to see Barry from a close friend of mine. Barry is an absolute professional ; gives you every bit of information possible and does a thorough appraisal job. Just a pleasure to be around. Honest and fair. thank you for all your help !
Lyla L.
Jan 03, 2020
Report
I recently purchased a diamond ring and was curious to find out if I had gotten a good deal. My sister in law recommended the Jewelry Judge. The moment you walk in you're at ease. Mr. Block is extremely friendly, reassuring and a downright professional. This is the only place to go