Business Details
37 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza & Pasta in Sarasota, FL
At Ricos Pizzeria, we take pride in delivering authentic Italian and Sicilian cuisine crafted with generations-old family recipes. Since our relocation from New Jersey to Sarasota in 1989, the Dentici family has maintained a commitment to quality, using fresh, house-made ingredients for every dish. Our hand-tossed pizzas, prepared on a pizza peel to stone, feature thin or Sicilian thick crusts topped with house-made sauce and premium ingredients. We offer a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere across four locations in Sarasota, St. Armands, and Lakewood Ranch/Bradenton. Our menu extends beyond pizza to include handcrafted pasta dishes, salads, baked specialties, and desserts like our renowned cannoli.We prioritize customer satisfaction through attentive service and a dedication to culinary excellence. Our catering services bring the same quality to events, with customizable platters and dishes for any occasion. Open daily with extended hours on weekends, we strive to accommodate our guests' schedules. Recognized for exceptional service and gluten-free options, we ensure every visit reflects our passion for Italian tradition. Join us to experience the flavors of Sicily in a welcoming environment where every meal tells a story of heritage and care.
Services
Pizza
Pasta
Catering
Salads
Desserts
Details
- Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
- We serve authentic Sicilian recipes from our family since 1989.
- All dishes are made from scratch with fresh, house-made ingredients.
- Four convenient locations in Sarasota, St. Armands, and Lakewood Ranch.
- Award-winning customer service with attention to detail and accuracy.
- Custom catering services for events with menu items for every taste.
What people say
Delicious gluten free pizza
Amazing customer service
Excellent cannoli
Fantastic service
Best pizza in Sarasota
Services
Pizza
Hand-tossed pizzas with thin or Sicilian thick crusts, made on a pizza peel to stone. Toppings include house-made sauce, fresh vegetables, meats, and specialty options like Buffalo Chicken. Gluten-free crusts are available for select pizzas. Every pie emphasizes quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods.
Pasta
Handcrafted pasta dishes featuring house-made sauces, meats, and vegetables. Options include baked ziti, lasagna, stuffed shells, and specialty entrees like Chicken Cacciatore. Ingredients are prepared fresh daily, with attention to authentic Italian flavors and textures.
Catering
Full-service catering for events with customizable platters and dishes. Includes appetizers, salads, baked dishes, pasta, and desserts. Available in half or full trays, with delivery options and setup assistance. Ideal for weddings, corporate events, and family gatherings.
Salads
Freshly prepared salads with house-made dressings. Options include Garden, Caesar, Greek, and Antipasto salads. Add grilled chicken or shrimp for protein upgrades. Served in half or large trays for individual or group portions.
Desserts
Classic Italian desserts like mini cannoli, brownies, lemon bars, and cookies. Available in small or large trays for sharing. House-made daily to complement meals or serve as standalone treats for events.
Questions
Does Rico's offer gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, Rico's provides gluten-free pizza crusts for select menu items, ensuring dietary needs are accommodated without compromising taste.
What are Rico's catering options?
Catering includes customizable platters of appetizers, salads, baked dishes, pasta, and desserts in half or full trays with delivery available.
Are there vegetarian options on the menu?
Yes, Rico's offers vegetarian dishes like baked ziti, eggplant parmesan, and fresh mozzarella caprese salads.
What locations does Rico's operate in?
Rico's has four locations in Sarasota, St. Armands Circle, Lakewood Ranch, and Bradenton, Florida.
Does Rico's deliver orders?
Yes, delivery is available with a 10% minimum charge. Contact your local Rico's location for details.
What are Rico's operating hours?
Hours vary by location but generally run from 11 AM to 10 PM daily, with extended Friday hours until 11 PM.
Reviews (6)
Jennifer Iannitti
Jan 26, 2022
Report
Pepperoni pizza was good, garlic knots were tasty and the white chocolate chip cheesecake with raspberry sauce was a nice finishing touch. Our server, Kayle, was exceptionally attentive to our needs, upbeat & friendly.
Yvonne Wright
Jan 18, 2022
Report
Love their homemade sauce! (Ask for extra on everything!) We order lots of different things here and have never been disappointed. Their chicken wings are particularly good. We also like that they serve hard alcohol so we can get rum and Cokes.
Joe Carranti
Jan 18, 2022
Report
Friendly fast service and good New York style pizza. The only complaint I have is the dough needs salt. A great pizza with good ingredients can be ruined with a bland dough. As a born and raised New Yorker it's hard for me to give pizza a 5 star rating, but overall enjoyable experience!
Clifford Tennyson
Jan 16, 2022
Report
Ive eaten here 3 times. Pizza would be great if they cooked the crust longer. 2 of the 3 times I asked for extra crispy. All 3 times it was a disappointment. Under the toppings crust is droopy, uncooked and lacking flavor. Who likes a soggy pizzzzzzza?!?!? Ordered some pasta dish wish was tasted ok. But the bread they give was like a Lightning hockey puck. Too bad because the pizza could be great if attention to cooking pizza was paid attention too. Having a crispy crust is half the enjoyment of a pizza. Good luck all-
Alicia Cerrito
Dec 31, 2021
Report
Love their food, but I will not order from them any longer. They have forgotten about our entire delivery order, even after calling once and them saying it was on the way. I asked to speak to a mgr. which was denied and they refused to make any ammemds for their 2 hr. mistake. On a previous delivery the driver told me they didn't carry cash to give change, which I later found out was a lie. Leaving him more of a tip than the price of the meal itself. Very disappointed in their customer service, especially because they offered no apology or refund or offer to rectify the issues. For a small home
Rachel Smith
Dec 03, 2021
Report
This place had gross ravioli pasta. When we told them that the sauce was to sweet we got told that's how it's made and they have made it that way for 25 years. Well not everyone can handle sweet sauce and something could have been done to please the customer. I would have had a different sauce if offered. We won't be back. My point was when I said we didn't like it I wasn't offended something else to eat. So no I won't be back and the staff member was also rude. Some people can't handle sweet sauce like a diabetic person for example. But no worries because of the rude staff and poor customer service