Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
35 Years
experience
Your Trusted Pizza & Sports Bar in Sarasota Since 1991
Shaner's Pizza has been serving Sarasota, FL since 1991 with a commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional customer service. Founded by former MLB pitcher Shane Rawley, our establishment combines decades of baseball experience with a passion for crafting delicious thin crust pizzas, gourmet sandwiches, and fresh salads. Every dish is made with care using premium toppings and house-made sauces, ensuring a memorable dining experience whether you're visiting our sports-themed restaurant or ordering takeout.

Our team takes pride in creating a welcoming environment where families, sports enthusiasts, and pizza lovers can enjoy great food and personal interactions with our owner, who brings over 30 years of hospitality expertise. With multiple accolades during Shane's 16-year professional baseball career, our establishment maintains the same dedication to excellence that defined his time on the field.
Services
Thin Crust Pizza Takeout Sports Bar Sandwiches Salads Appetizers Wings Dinners Delivery Sports Memorabilia
Details
  • Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
  • We use fresh, high-quality ingredients daily in all our dishes
  • Owner Shane Rawley offers a unique baseball-themed experience
  • Family-friendly environment with sports memorabilia from our owner's MLB career
  • Serving Sarasota since 1991 with consistent quality and service
  • Variety of menu options beyond pizza including award-winning sandwiches and salads
What people say
Delicious pizza Friendly service Sports-themed atmosphere Great place for games Quality ingredients
Services
Thin Crust Pizza
Our signature thin crust pizza features hand-tossed dough made fresh daily with premium toppings. Available in three sizes with customizable options, including specialty pizzas like the Margarita and Supreme. Each pie showcases our commitment to quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods.
Sports Bar
Combining sports memorabilia with live game coverage, our sports bar offers a unique atmosphere for fans. Featuring multiple screens and a full bar with craft beers and wine, it's the perfect spot to enjoy games while savoring our signature dishes.
Sandwiches
Gourmet sandwiches include classics like the Philly Cheese and innovative creations like the Smash Burger. Each sandwich uses premium meats, fresh vegetables, and house-made sauces served on brioche buns with optional sides.
Appetizers
Our appetizer menu features crowd-pleasers like homemade mozzarella sticks and jalepeo poppers. Wings come in various sauces with dry rub options, while seafood selections include grilled shrimp and lobster escargot.
Salads
Freshly prepared salads range from traditional Caesar to specialty options like the Pecan Pear and Greek. All salads use crisp greens with premium toppings and feature house-made dressings for authentic flavor.
People
Shane Rawley
Owner
Former MLB pitcher with 16-year professional career, including 12 major league seasons. Opened Shaner's Pizza in 1991, combining baseball experience with passion for quality food. Known for personal interactions with customers and card tricks.
Questions
What makes Shaner's thin crust pizza unique?
Our thin crust pizza uses hand-tossed dough made fresh daily with premium toppings selected for quality and flavor.
Is there a connection between the owner and baseball?
Yes, owner Shane Rawley played 16 years professionally including 12 major league seasons with teams like the Mariners and Phillies.
What are the restaurant's operating hours?
We're open daily from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM, with Sunday hours starting at 3:30 PM.
Are there takeout and delivery options available?
Yes, we offer both takeout and delivery through our website and delivery partners for your convenience.
What other menu items are available besides pizza?
Our menu includes gourmet sandwiches, fresh salads, appetizers, and entrees like pasta dishes and chicken parmesan.
Is the restaurant family-friendly?
Yes, we welcome families with a sports-themed environment suitable for all ages and special interactions with our owner.
Reviews (4)
Alan D.
Jan 11, 2022 Report
Had a 14" pizza last week to go. It was topped with sausage.
Enjoyed the pizza as bit was crispy and thin crust. Not too saucy which I liked. Everyone who greeted me was nice. Had to wait 5-10 minutes as they were busy, no big deal. Going back to eat there tonight.
Mike G.
Dec 05, 2021 Report
Again. I try to like this but when your prices are $21 for a large two topping and the toppings only are worth .50 to a $1 and you get hardly anything on it. Kind of a joke. One sausage per tiny slice.
Heidi Hollermann
Dec 01, 2021 Report
Pizza was great and the guy that took our order was very nice! The reason I am giving a 2 star review is because the manager was VERY rude. We were quoted 40 minutes and ended up getting it 2 hours after we placed it! There was confusion with our delivery so the driver decided to get us a new pizza, but we were never told this, instead we were told they would be there within a few minutes. When we finally got our pizza, I asked for the manager to call me back to provide feedback and he just blamed all his other employees. We ended up not paying for our pizza, but the manager made the whole situation
Carol A.
Nov 15, 2021 Report
We kept hearing about this place for the best Chicago "pub" style pizza so decided to try it. We were skeptical when they said pick up in 15 minutes... I will say the flavors were there, but hardly any toppings. There is also a big difference between a thin and crispy crust compared to the flimsy undercooked crust we received. It could not hold any of the toppings or be picked up without falling apart. We had to try and finish baking it by putting it in our oven at home. Maybe they were busy, understaffed or another reason but quality of food is important to these born and raised Chicagoans