Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
22 Years
experience
Your Trusted Payroll & Accounting Partner in Painesville, OH
Founded in 2004, Ohio Payroll Plus was established to address gaps in customer service and pricing transparency within the payroll industry. Our company specializes in delivering personalized payroll solutions, fully integrated accounting services, and comprehensive human resources support tailored to businesses of all sizes. With over a decade of experience, we have expanded to serve hundreds of clients across ten states, maintaining a commitment to eliminating hidden fees and simplifying complex processes.

Our team prioritizes client relationships, offering penalty-free tax filing, secure online payroll portals, and customized benefits administration. By combining local expertise with nationwide capabilities, we ensure accurate payroll processing, timely tax compliance, and strategic financial guidance. Our dedication to innovation and client satisfaction has solidified our reputation as a trusted partner for payroll and accounting needs.
Services
Payroll Processing Tax Filing Services Human Resources Benefits Administration Payroll Portals Garnishment Pay Systems Payroll Debit Cards
Details
  • Year established: 2004
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 20 years of combined payroll and accounting expertise.
  • Our team provides fully integrated payroll, tax, and HR solutions.
  • We guarantee transparent pricing with no hidden fees.
  • Our secure online portals enable 24/7 client access and communication.
  • We serve businesses nationwide with localized support in Northeast Ohio.
What people say
Accommodating, accurate, pleasure to work with Saved 50% on processing costs Higher level of service Attentive, cost less
Services
Payroll Processing
We collect payroll data, calculate deductions, and ensure accurate employee payments. Our services include direct deposit, laser-signed checks, and secure tax withholding. Clients benefit from streamlined payroll management with nationwide compliance.
Tax Filing Services
We handle federal and state tax filings, including quarterly 941 forms and annual 940/944 returns. Electronic tax payments eliminate penalties, while W-2 and 1099 processing ensures year-end accuracy for all clients.
Payroll Portals
Secure client portals enable 24/7 payroll management, document sharing, and communication. Features include real-time payroll tracking, tax filing status updates, and instant access to processed forms.
Garnishment Pay Systems
We automate complex garnishment calculations, including child support and tax levies. Our system ensures compliance with legal limits while managing payments on behalf of employers.
Payroll Debit Cards
Debit cards provide unbanked employees with secure, cost-effective pay access. Employers benefit from 100% direct deposit participation, reducing administrative burdens and distribution costs.
People
Anne McNeely
Controller at Star Precision
Anne McNeely praises Ohio Payroll Plus for exceptional service, accuracy, and responsiveness, highlighting their role in streamlining payroll operations for Star Precision.
Jeff Holden
President, Network Results, Inc.
Jeff Holden credits Ohio Payroll Plus with reducing processing costs by 50% and providing reliable local support for his company's payroll and tax needs.
Randy Carver
RJFS Registered Principal, Carver Financial Services Inc.
Randy Carver emphasizes improved service quality and cost savings after switching to Ohio Payroll Plus from a national provider.
Tom Hill
Thomas Hill Investment Services
Tom Hill highlights Ohio Payroll Plus's attentive service, cost-effectiveness, and proactive problem resolution compared to his previous payroll provider.
Questions
What payroll services do you offer?
We provide full-service payroll processing, tax filing, garnishment management, and payroll debit card solutions for businesses of all sizes.
How do you ensure tax compliance?
We handle all federal and state tax filings, including quarterly 941 forms and annual returns, with electronic payments to prevent penalties.
Do you serve businesses outside Ohio?
Yes, we support clients nationwide with payroll and tax services in all 50 states.
What accounting services are available?
We offer bookkeeping, tax planning, and business consulting to help small businesses optimize financial operations and minimize tax liabilities.
How can I access my payroll information?
Our secure online portals allow 24/7 access to payroll records, tax documents, and direct communication with our team.
What makes you different from national payroll providers?
We combine local expertise with personalized service, transparent pricing, and dedicated support that national firms often lack.
Reviews (2)
Deborah V.
Aug 23, 2019 Report
I agree with the review below. I was with OPP for almost 7 years - the first years everything was fine but within the last 2 years there have been multiple times where something was not filed - or not filed correctly. I email - call - and no response. I getting a different company to do my payroll and my taxes. Maybe if you are in the same town and they know you personally, they will maintain communication. I do not recommend them to any small business owner who is not able to follow up in person with this company.
Jennifer S.
Oct 17, 2018 Report
10/17/2018

I used them for 2 years. It was awful. At first I thought I was getting this "personal" service verses the large payroll companies. Then I started getting notices from the federal government that there were errors in my W-2's and my returns, notices that local taxes weren't paid correctly and complaints that child support payments weren't being paid promptly. I'd have to call repeatedly to try getting them to correct the errors. And once I dropped them and continued to get notices - forget it - the owners calls were being screened and I had a heck