Business Details
26 Years
experience
Trusted Payroll Services for Small Businesses in Northeast Ohio
Founded in 2000 by Tom Finucane, Compass Payroll Services has established itself as a trusted partner for small businesses and nonprofit organizations across 25 states. Our team brings decades of combined experience in payroll processing, tax compliance, and HR solutions, guided by core values of integrity and exceptional customer service. We specialize in providing all-inclusive payroll packages that handle tax filings, direct deposits, and regulatory reporting with precision and timeliness. Our personalized approach ensures clients receive tailored support from seasoned professionals who understand the unique challenges of small business operations.With a proven track record of accuracy in payroll tax payments and document management, we empower businesses to focus on growth while we handle complex administrative tasks. Our commitment to continuous improvement drives us to stay ahead of regulatory changes and implement technological advancements that benefit our clients. Backed by long-term client relationships and industry recognition, including designation as a COSE preferred provider, we deliver reliable payroll solutions that combine local expertise with national service capabilities.
Services
Payroll Processing
Tax Filing
HR Support
Direct Deposit
New Hire Reporting
Details
- Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
- We offer 25+ years of specialized payroll expertise across multiple states
- Our all-inclusive pricing covers comprehensive tax filing and reporting services
- We guarantee timely payroll tax payments with 99.9% accuracy rate
- Our local team provides personalized service with national service capabilities
- We implement proactive compliance monitoring for evolving tax regulations
What people say
Personalized service
On time every time
Responsive staff
All-inclusive pricing
Proactive compliance monitoring
Services
Payroll Processing
Full-service payroll processing handles all aspects of employee compensation including check preparation, earnings statements, and tax withholding calculations. Our system manages federal, state, and local tax deductions while maintaining accurate year-to-date records. Clients receive detailed reporting including cash requirements, general ledger entries, and department-specific payroll analysis.
Tax Filing
Comprehensive tax filing services cover quarterly federal Form 941, state unemployment returns, and annual Form 940 submissions. We handle W-2 and W-3 processing, new hire reporting, and multi-city tax filings with guaranteed on-time delivery. Our system automatically updates for regulatory changes to ensure complete compliance.
HR Support
Our HR solutions include employment poster updates, benefit plan reporting, and garnishment management. The support center provides guidance on payroll-related regulations while our client portal offers 24/7 access to payroll documents and tax forms. We also assist with new business registration requirements.
Direct Deposit
Secure direct deposit service ensures timely employee payments without paper checks. Funds are automatically transferred to employee accounts on payday while maintaining complete audit trails. This service integrates with our payroll processing to handle recurring payments and vacation accruals.
New Hire Reporting
Automated new hire reporting meets state requirements through electronic submissions. Our system tracks reporting deadlines and handles all necessary documentation to maintain compliance with child support and garnishment regulations while maintaining employee privacy.
People
Thomas P. Finucane
Founder
MBA graduate from John Carroll University with 30+ years payroll industry experience. Founded Compass Payroll Services in 2000 to provide personalized payroll solutions for small businesses while maintaining strict compliance standards.
Katy Finucane
President
Business leader with extensive payroll management experience. Oversees daily operations and strategic direction while maintaining focus on client satisfaction and service excellence across multiple states.
Andrew Mathay
Operations Manager
Manages payroll processing operations with emphasis on accuracy and efficiency. Implements process improvements that maintain 99.9% error-free tax filing rate while ensuring timely delivery of payroll services.
Tamantha Ford
Client Success Manager
Dedicated client advocate with 15+ years payroll processing experience. Provides personalized support to small businesses while maintaining proactive communication about regulatory changes affecting payroll operations.
Peggy Jackson
Administration
Handles client communications and document management with attention to detail. Ensures smooth onboarding process for new clients while maintaining organized records for audit readiness.
Questions
What payroll services do you offer for small businesses?
We provide full-service payroll processing including tax filings, direct deposit, W-2 processing, new hire reporting, and HR support with all-inclusive pricing.
Do you handle multi-state payroll requirements?
Yes, we support businesses in 25 states with specialized expertise in Ohio BWC reporting and cross-state tax compliance.
How does your all-inclusive pricing work?
Our pricing covers electronic tax payments, regulatory filings, unlimited payroll processing, and dedicated client support with no hidden fees.
What security measures protect payroll data?
We use 256-bit SSL encryption, multi-factor authentication, and regular security audits to ensure complete data protection.
How quickly can I get payroll setup completed?
Most new clients complete payroll setup within 3 business days with dedicated onboarding support from our team.
Reviews (4)
Rachel Kabb-Effron
Jan 03, 2021
Report
Our firm has used Compass Payroll for the last 10 + years and they are fabulous. They are professional, on time, budget friendly and it is great to have a local company instead of a huge chain where you get lost in the shuffle. In fact during the C-19 pandemic, they led with critical information and strategy at each juncture. Can't go wrong with Compass.
Jake Lohser Lohser Real Estate Group
Dec 03, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Tom Finucane and his team at Compass are by far the best payroll company I have ever used. If you are considering a new payroll company I would call Compass today!!
Tom Finucane and his team at Compass are by far the best payroll company I have ever used. If you are considering a new payroll company I would call Compass today!!
Kelly Danko
Nov 20, 2018
Report
I have been using Compass Payroll Services for years. They make it so easy and I know everything is done correct and on time every time. That helps me to focus on my business and to be honest payroll doesn't even cross my mind now that I know they have it covered.
Jennifer Corso
Jun 14, 2016
Report
Several of my clients use Compass Payroll and are incredibly happy with their services. Tom is an expert in his field, has both payroll and tax experience, and helps guide small business owners through the payroll process. I have recommended Compass to my clients and will continue to do so.