Business Details
39 Years
experience
Overstuffed Italian-American Sandwiches in Mamaroneck, NY
Anthonys Deli has been a cornerstone of the Mamaroneck and Harrison communities since 1987, specializing in authentic Italian-American sandwiches crafted with fresh ingredients. Our commitment to quality and value has earned us a reputation for serving overstuffed, flavorful sandwiches at fair prices, including signature items like The Godfather and Breakfast Barge. With decades of experience, we offer daily specials, catering services, and a diverse menu that caters to breakfast, lunch, and event needs. Our neighborhood-focused approach emphasizes generous portions, traditional recipes, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers returning. We pride ourselves on maintaining consistency in taste and portion size while adapting to modern dietary preferences through customizable options. Our catering division extends this dedication to quality for events of all sizes, featuring party wedges and platters made with premium meats and cheeses.Open six days a week with extended morning hours, we accommodate busy schedules while preserving the personal touch of a family-owned business. Our menu reflects Italian culinary traditions with Americanized twists, balancing classic favorites like eggplant Parmigiana with innovative creations like the Inferno sandwich. We maintain rigorous ingredient standards, sourcing high-quality meats, cheeses, and fresh-baked breads to ensure consistent flavor and texture. Customer feedback drives our continuous improvement, with popular items like the Chicken Ranchero and Philly Cheesesteak evolving based on community preferences. Our team of skilled sandwich artisans combines technical expertise with passion for food, ensuring each order meets exacting specifications. This combination of heritage, quality, and customer-centric service establishes Anthonys Deli as a trusted local institution.
Services
Italian-American Sandwiches
Catering Services
Daily Specials
Breakfast Menu
Signature Sandwiches
Details
- Year established: 1987
Highlights and features
- We've served Mamaroneck since 1987 with consistent quality and portions
- Our signature sandwiches use premium meats and cheeses daily
- Catering division handles events from 10 to 100+ guests
- Daily specials feature rotating traditional Italian-American dishes
- Customizable menu accommodates diverse dietary preferences
Services
Italian-American Sandwiches
Crafting authentic Italian-American sandwiches since 1987 using premium meats, cheeses, and fresh-baked breads. Our menu features both traditional favorites and innovative creations with customizable options. Each sandwich combines generous portions with balanced flavor profiles for a satisfying meal experience.
Catering Services
Full-service catering for events of all sizes featuring party wedges, platters, and hot dishes. We accommodate dietary preferences while maintaining presentation quality and portion consistency. Orders require 24-hour advance notice for optimal preparation and delivery timing.
Daily Specials
Daily rotating specials featuring traditional Italian-American dishes like lasagna, meatloaf, and grilled chicken. Menu changes weekly with multiple protein options available each day. Combines heritage recipes with contemporary preparation techniques for consistent quality.
Breakfast Menu
Full breakfast service featuring made-to-order egg dishes, French toast, and signature sandwiches like the Breakfast Barge. Available daily with customizable meat and cheese options. Focuses on hearty portions to satisfy morning appetites.
Signature Sandwiches
Unique specialty sandwiches including The Godfather with seven premium meats and the Inferno with spicy wing sauce. Each creation features specific ingredient combinations and preparation methods. Designed for customers seeking bold flavors and generous portions.
Questions
What catering options are available for large events?
We offer party wedges and platters serving 10-100+ guests with Italian, American, or Chicken Cutlet varieties. Orders require 24-hour advance notice for optimal preparation and delivery timing.
What are your regular business hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 6:00am-5:00pm and Sunday 6:00am-4:00pm. Holiday hours may vary - please check our website or call for specific dates.
What makes The Godfather sandwich unique?
Our signature sandwich features seven premium meats including salami, pepperoni, ham, cappicola, mortadella, prosciuttini, and sopresatta, plus provolone cheese and traditional toppings on Arthur Avenue Italian bread.
Do you use fresh ingredients daily?
Yes, we prepare all sandwiches with fresh-baked breads, premium meats, and cheeses daily. Our vegetables are prepared fresh for each order to maintain optimal quality and flavor.
Can I customize my sandwich order?
Absolutely! We offer full customization including meat/cheese substitutions, extra toppings, and bread choices. Our staff works with you to create the perfect sandwich combination for your preferences.
Reviews (5)
John T.
Jan 19, 2022
Report
I tried the Triple Play hero today and was not disappointed. Melted American cheese on top of two deep breaded chicken cutlets and a nice dollop of homemade chili. I have to tell you it exceeded all my expectations! The chili was so good that I'm going to order it on future sandwiches from this place and the hero is so huge it made for two lunches. I can't wait to order from this gem of a deli, again . You won't be hungry after eating this one !
Lisa Williams
Jan 02, 2022
Report
For those boomers out there...Dagwood Bumstead sandwich and for the newer kids on the block, Shaggy and Scooby would be impressed! It's a real neighborhood deli with sandwiches so stacked I believe all these fast poison places should be paying Anthony royalty's for the 'super size' meal, and his doesn't cost extra! The hot cooked meals are better than some I had at home. Sorry dad, you can't throw any old leftovers into a can if Campbell's soup and think it's a meal, smh . If you've had an Anthony's sandwich you know what I'm talking about. If not, you've only got four more hours to go
Ally Venable
Nov 30, 2021
Report
Im traveling from Texas, we stopped into Anthonys Deli today and I was very shocked at how great and filling the sandwich I got was. I asked what they recommended and they made me a chicken cutlet sandwich with ranch and bacon. Best sandwich Ive ever had. Highly recommend this place.
SpalatoAntiques
Nov 13, 2021
Report
The BEST deli in New York, hands down! Not just in Westchester County, but in all of New York. Set back behind it's own parking lot, on Halstead avenue. If the parking is full, there is plenty of spaces on Halstead ave, please don't be lazy to walk a bit, it is well worth it. Breakfast is awesome, all combinations, and if you are really starving go for the "Breakfast Barge", that will definitely do the job. Lunch, just go with your own favorite, they will knock you off your feet. Besides, they have their own special sandwiches like "Godfather", or "Balboa", etc. The quantity of meat in sandwiches
Louise R.
Oct 19, 2021
Report
Generously stuffed cold cut sandwiches. Prices are more than reasonable. Some "specials of the day " disappoint once in a while. Overall my favorite deli!
