Business Details
Your Local Bakery & Cafe in Manheim, PA
At Mill 72, we are proud to operate as a family-owned and locally-sourced bake shop and cafe serving the Manheim, Lititz, and Lebanon communities. Our passion for baking and coffee drives our mission to create a welcoming space where customers can connect, unwind, and enjoy high-quality specialty drinks, baked goods, and light meals. Every ingredient we use comes from local suppliers, farms, and businesses, reflecting our commitment to supporting the regional economy. The Miller family, born and raised in Manheim, PA, brings decades of baking experience and a deep connection to the community into every aspect of our operations. From our signature pastries to our carefully crafted coffee blends, we prioritize quality and authenticity in every product we offer. Our team includes trained professionals like head baker Morgan, who graduated from the Mount Joy LCCTC culinary program, and social media manager Taylor, who combines her cosmetology expertise with hospitality experience.We take pride in hosting special events, creating custom wedding desserts, and developing innovative breakfast and lunch options using seasonal ingredients. Our location along Route 72 in Manheim connects us to both our family heritagethrough our ancestors' corn meal mill legacyand our modern community needs. Whether customers visit our Manheim location at 45 North Main Street or our Lebanon branch at 1784 Quentin Road, they experience the same dedication to excellence that has defined our business since our founding. We continuously strive to balance traditional baking methods with contemporary flavors while maintaining our core values of family, community, and quality.
Services
Bakery Items
Specialty Coffee
Breakfast Service
Lunch Service
Custom Cakes
Catering
Highlights and features
- We source all ingredients from local Pennsylvania farms and suppliers
- Our family has generations of baking experience and community roots
- We offer custom wedding desserts and special event catering
- Our head baker holds professional culinary certifications
- We operate two convenient locations in Manheim and Lebanon
Services
Bakery Items
Our bakery offers a wide selection of freshly baked goods daily, including croissants, muffins, cookies, and specialty breads. Using locally-sourced ingredients, we create both classic favorites and innovative seasonal items. Each product reflects our commitment to quality and traditional baking techniques.
Specialty Coffee
We serve premium coffee drinks made with carefully selected beans and expert preparation methods. Our menu features espresso-based beverages, pour-overs, and specialty lattes. The coffee program combines professional expertise with a welcoming atmosphere for casual enjoyment or focused work.
Breakfast Service
Our breakfast menu offers both traditional favorites and creative new options using fresh, local ingredients. Available daily until 11 AM, the menu includes made-to-order omelets, breakfast sandwiches, and seasonal specials. Each dish emphasizes quality and flavor in a comfortable setting.
Lunch Service
The lunch menu features light meals including sandwiches, salads, and daily specials. Ingredients come from local farms and suppliers to ensure freshness and support regional agriculture. Meals can be enjoyed in our dining area or taken to go during regular business hours.
Custom Cakes
We create custom-designed cakes and desserts for weddings, birthdays, and special events. Our team has experience with multi-tiered cakes, cupcakes, and dessert bars. Each order receives personalized attention to match the client's vision and event theme.
People
Melanie Miller
Owner/General Manager
Melanie founded Mill 72 after years of baking for family events and weddings. She oversees daily operations and brings entrepreneurial vision to the business while maintaining hands-on involvement in product development and customer service.
Brian Miller
Principal Engineer
Brian contributes engineering expertise from his role at ELA Group, Inc. to the cafe's design and construction. He assists with technical aspects of the business while maintaining his professional engineering career in transportation projects.
Taylor Miller
Social Media Manager
Taylor manages front-of-house operations and social media presence. With a cosmetology background and event experience, she combines hospitality skills with digital marketing to enhance customer engagement and brand visibility.
Morgan Miller
Head Baker
Morgan leads kitchen operations with formal culinary training from Mount Joy LCCTC. She specializes in baking and pastry arts, applying professional techniques to daily production while mentoring kitchen staff in quality standards.
Payton Miller
Baker/Cafe Staff
Payton works across both locations as a baker and customer service representative. The youngest team member, she combines recent high school graduation with practical experience in food service and bakery production.
Questions
What locations does Mill 72 operate in?
We have two locations: 45 North Main Street in Manheim, PA and 1784 Quentin Road in Lebanon, PA.
What are Mill 72's operating hours?
We're open Tuesday-Friday 7 AM - 4 PM, Saturday 7 AM - 2 PM, and closed Monday & Sunday.
Do you offer catering or special event services?
Yes, we provide custom catering for events including weddings, corporate functions, and private parties with specialized menus.
Are your products made fresh daily?
All baked goods and menu items are prepared fresh daily using locally-sourced ingredients from regional suppliers.
Can I order bakery items online?
Yes, we offer online ordering for our full bakery selection through our website's 'Order Online' feature.
Do you have seasonal menu items?
Our menu features rotating seasonal specialties that highlight local produce and ingredients throughout the year.
Reviews (5)
D. A. Theamore
Feb 02, 2022
Report
I have been here a few times since moving to the Manheim area and I recommend visiting this bright gem of delicious food and airy ambiance. If you want to chill out drinking an excellent cup of coffee and quiet read or write. You can. If you want to strike up a fun conversation with someone new as you eat a scone. You can. Want variety that can appeal to allergy need? As someone with sensitivities to wheat and dairy, I am able to ask questions and find options that work for me. My little boy loves their peanut butter energy balls and everyone that works here are so lovely. The music is upbeat and
Tim S.
Dec 04, 2021
Report
Mill 72 in Manheim, PA is a relatively new (2018) local favorite. The cafe is quaint but busy. The staff is friendly and efficient. It is both clean and tastefully decorated. Even has seasonal bath and body works soap in the restrooms. Plenary of breakfast, lunch and coffee options as expected in a cafe. We had several breakfast sandwiches that were good. The turkey BLT is my recommendation. Cookies and pastries were great and appear to be scratch-made. Reasonably priced
Sarah V.
Nov 24, 2021
Report
Got the iced smores latte and WOW it was very good! Also had a sausage egg and cheese on a bagel which was also very good. A little less cheese would make it better but over all very delicious!
Rok
Oct 28, 2021
Report
The last time I tried to come, it was 7:04. There were people standing inside and the flag outside said open. The door begged otherwise. I knocked, someone looked at me, and nobody answered. The coffee is okay, much better than The Brick House, at least. Some of the pastries are dry and a little expensive. The location is perfect, the atmosphere it okay. A little noisy, though the seating outside is good. I disagree with the hours, though. 7:00 is too late for kids walking to school and adults going to work. What if we wanted a cup of joe on our way in? Not to mention how 4:00 is far too
Kimberly Thomas
Oct 13, 2021
Report
Im a travel nurse and love to explore local shops, not only is the food and coffee amazing! The staff is friendly and the cafe sits right next to a store full of individual boutiques. Will definitely be back.
