Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Wylie, TX
Founded in 1898, Wylie Insurance Agency stands as the oldest business in Wylie, Texas, with a legacy built on trust, community, and personalized service. Our independent agency model allows us to prioritize client needs over insurance company interests, offering tailored coverage options from top-rated providers. With over 120 years of local expertise, we specialize in auto, homeowners, business, and benefits insurance, serving Wylie and the broader DFW Metroplex. Our team of licensed professionals, including Certified Insurance Counselor John Yeager, combines decades of experience with ongoing education to navigate complex insurance landscapes.

We emphasize personal relationships over policy numbers, reflected in our seven consecutive 'Wylies Best Insurance Agency' awards and active community involvement through local boards and charities. Our commitment to transparency, competitive pricing, and advocacy for clients has sustained generations of families and businesses in their most critical moments.
Services
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance Benefits Insurance
Highlights and features
  • We offer 120+ years of independent insurance expertise in Wylie.
  • Our independent agency model prioritizes client needs over insurer interests.
  • We provide tailored coverage from multiple A-rated insurance providers.
  • Our team includes Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) professionals.
  • We maintain seven consecutive 'Wylies Best Insurance Agency' award recognition.
What people say
First class customer service Lowest rates Great customer service Family owned business Personal touch
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance policies protect against financial losses from vehicle damage, theft, or accidents. We offer collision and comprehensive coverage options to safeguard vehicles and provide liability protection for medical and legal expenses. Our independent agency helps clients compare policies from multiple insurers to find optimal coverage and value.
Homeowners Insurance
Homeowners insurance covers property damage, personal liability, and living expenses during repairs. We provide tailored policies for houses, condos, and rentals, including scheduled coverage for valuables. Our agents help clients select appropriate limits and deductibles while ensuring protection for their most significant asset.
Business Insurance
Business insurance protects companies from operational risks through general liability, property, auto, and workers' compensation policies. We offer customized solutions for Texas businesses, comparing multiple carriers to balance protection and cost. Our expertise includes commercial umbrella policies for lawsuit protection.
Benefits Insurance
Benefits insurance includes group health, dental, vision, and disability coverage to attract and retain employees. We design cost-effective benefit packages while navigating regulatory requirements. Our team advocates for employers to secure competitive rates and comprehensive coverage options for workforce needs.
People
John Yeager
President & CIC
John Yeager has led Wylie Insurance Agency since 1973, maintaining its status as Wylies oldest business. A Certified Insurance Counselor, he prioritizes client advocacy over insurer interests. Active in community boards, he emphasizes personalized service and has expanded coverage options while preserving family-owned values.
Kylie Reising
Vice President
Kylie Reising serves as Vice President, continuing the family legacy of client-focused insurance services. With expertise in policy customization, she helps clients find competitive rates while maintaining personal relationships. Active in the Wylie Chamber of Commerce, she represents fourth-generation leadership at the agency.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, homeowners, business, and benefits insurance with coverage options tailored to individual and organizational needs across Texas.
How do you help clients find the best rates?
As an independent agency, we compare policies from multiple A-rated insurers to find competitive pricing without compromising coverage quality.
Do you serve areas outside Wylie?
While based in Wylie, we serve clients throughout the DFW Metroplex and across Texas for all our insurance products.
What sets you apart from other agencies?
As Wylie’s oldest business with seven 'Best Insurance Agency' awards, we combine generational expertise with independent advocacy for client interests.
Are your agents certified professionals?
Our team includes Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) professionals with ongoing education to maintain expertise in evolving insurance regulations.
Reviews (5)
Stephanie S.
Jan 04, 2022 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
I was referred by my real estate agent and have been a customer for eight years. I recommend Wylie Insurance for home and auto insurance because the rates are competitive, and the agents provide excellent service in a way that's understandable and quick.
Jan Arrant
Dec 17, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
I am a very happy camper. I switched my insurance to Wylie Insurance Agency and it's been awesome. I got great service, improved coverage and someone I know I can trust when I need them!
Jennifer Vandergriff
Dec 15, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Best insurance company hands down! Very professional, very responsive and always out to make sure Im receiving the best possible rates. Kylie and her team have had my business for many years and I wouldnt trust my insurance needs anywhere else!
Mechelle Smith
Dec 04, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Hands down the best company! When my homeowners was time to be renewed Kylie noticed a huge increase. She found a better deal with another company and notified me immediately. This is why Wylie Insurance will always have my business.
Gilbert Welch
Nov 17, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
I have chosen to utilize Wylie Insurance Agency for my insurance needs and they work to provide the best coverage for the best price. I am very pleased with the professionalism and courtesy exhibited by their entire staff and I am very happy that I made this decision. I do feel comfortable recommending Wylie Insurance Company.