Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
26 Years
experience
Best Pizza in Penfield, NY | All Star Pizza
Since 2000, All Star Pizza has been dedicated to delivering exceptional pizza experiences in Penfield, NY. Our commitment begins with fresh dough made daily and locally sourced vegetables during peak seasons. We offer three distinct crust optionsNew York style, traditional, and thickcrafted using a proprietary recipe perfected through years of culinary exploration. Our signature sauces, including house-made red, garlic, and wing varieties, reflect our passion for flavor. As a women-owned business, we prioritize community engagement, supporting local organizations while maintaining strict quality standards.

Our team travels to learn authentic techniques, such as New York-style dough preparation, ensuring our crusts meet exacting expectations. Catering services accommodate events from intimate gatherings to large parties, with delivery available seven days a week. We maintain transparency about supply chain challenges while striving to exceed customer expectations through consistent quality and service improvements.
Services
Pizza Delivery Catering Services Gluten-Free Options Specialty Pizzas Wing Orders
Details
  • Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
  • We make fresh dough daily using a proprietary recipe
  • Our vegetables are locally sourced during peak seasons
  • We offer catering services for events of all sizes
  • Women-owned business with deep community roots
  • Three distinct crust options available for all tastes
What people say
Best pizza in Penfield Fresh ingredients Great crust Excellent catering Loyal fans
Services
Pizza Catering
Our catering service provides fresh, handcrafted pizzas for events of all sizes. We offer customizable options including three crust types, 20+ toppings, and specialty pizzas. Menus accommodate dietary restrictions with gluten-free and vegan options available. Serving platters and delivery included.
Specialty Pizzas
We craft 10 signature pizza varieties featuring house-made sauces and premium ingredients. Options include Meat Lovers, Veggie, Four Cheese, and unique creations like Chicken Wing Pizza. Available in four sizes from personal to sheet pizzas.
Gluten-Free Options
We provide certified gluten-free pizza options using dedicated preparation areas and ingredients. Our 10-inch gluten-free crust supports all standard toppings. Vegan cheese alternatives available upon request for most menu items.
Wing Orders
We prepare fresh chicken wings in bone-in or boneless styles with eight sauce options. Orders range from 5-piece appetizers to 50-piece party platters. Served with blue cheese and celery upon request. Custom wing splits available.
Salad Catering
Our catering menu includes five fresh salad options serving 10-24 people. Features include house-made dressings, locally sourced vegetables, and premium proteins like grilled chicken. Available with advance notice for events.
Questions
What areas do you deliver to?
We deliver to Penfield, East Rochester, and Browncroft, NY with a 15-mile delivery radius from our location.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we cater events from 10+ guests with pizza, subs, salads, and wings. Minimum 24-hour notice required for large orders.
Are gluten-free options available?
Yes, we offer certified gluten-free pizza crusts and maintain separate preparation areas to prevent cross-contamination.
What are your operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11am-10pm, Friday-Saturday 11am-11pm, and Sunday 11am-10pm.
Do you have vegan cheese options?
Yes, vegan cheese is available as a topping option for all pizza and calzone orders.
Reviews (7)
Ewaters
Jan 12, 2022 Report
All Star has stopped caring about the quality of their food and customer service. wings made with old nasty oil and wrong toppings on poorly cooked pizza. Traci the owner and Justin the manager need to stup up their game
Jacob Hooker
Dec 31, 2021 Report
Was in search of a Penfield area pizza and tired of the local chains. Saw a recommendation for All Star and decided to give them a try. They do a great, no frills, pepperoni pie. There are lots of options for cook time and crust thickness that I appreciate. No sloppy slices, just a solid thin crust cooked well done and ready in
Jake Mazza
Dec 25, 2021 Report
Great place for a slice, good prices and the employees are friendly. The bad reviews are from people who dont understand that NY pizza is a completely different style then the doughy garbage we get here in upstate NY.
Brandy Faith Osorio
Dec 19, 2021 Report
This was our family’s first time trying their pizza; we had the thin crust with pepperoni and mushrooms and it was DELICIOUS! Definitely recommend them and look forward to eating there again and trying some of their other items.
Remy Fenster
Nov 16, 2021 Report
One of the best pizza places in town. Nice thin crust, flavorful sauce and the right amount of cheese.
Shawna Finein
Oct 18, 2021 Report
We ordered a large pizza with double pepperoni. A cheese pizza was delivered instead. When we called to let them know, they sent out a new pizza within 20 minutes and let us keep the mistake pizza. When leaving, we mentioned our pet that we had lost that day. The driver called 5 minutes later saying there was a cat outside, and wondered if it was ours. It wasnt, since we had to put ours down, but it was super nice that he thought to call just in case.
Chris V.
Sep 21, 2021 Report
Feel the quality has gone down. Its thin pizza and I feel expensive for what you get. I was a fan but either my taste changed or I've had better pizza for less. I normally really enjoy thinner pizzas. I will say the barbeque wings are very good but I had a 10 minute wait while they remade my wings because of an order mix up.