Business Details
39 Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in New Albany, IN
Koerber's Fine Jewelry is a second-generation, woman-owned family business established in 1987 by Mike and Felecia Koerber, now led by daughter Jacquelyn. We specialize in high-quality diamonds, engagement rings, and fine jewelry from renowned designers, offering competitive pricing in a relaxed, no-pressure environment. Our commitment to exceptional customer service has earned us recognition as Kentuckiana's engagement ring destination. With over 30 years of experience, we provide personalized solutions for life's milestones, including custom jewelry design, jewelry repairs, and appraisals.Our team includes a Graduate Gemologist from the Gemological Institute of America, ensuring expert craftsmanship and knowledge. We prioritize community involvement and customer satisfaction, offering a 100% 'Peace of Mind' guarantee on every purchase. Our store in New Albany, Indiana, serves southern Indiana and Louisville, Kentucky, combining tradition with modern trends to meet evolving customer needs.
Services
Engagement Rings
Wedding Bands
Custom Design
Jewelry Repairs
Appraisals
Diamond Buying
Gold Trade-In
Watch Repairs
Gemstone Jewelry
Estate Jewelry
Details
- Year established: 1987
Highlights and features
- We offer over 30 years of experience in fine jewelry sales and design.
- Our team includes a Graduate Gemologist from the Gemological Institute of America.
- We provide a 100% 'Peace of Mind' guarantee on all purchases.
- We offer free appraisals with in-store purchases.
- We pay 20% above market value for trade-ins toward store credit.
What people say
Exceptional service
Beautiful jewelry selection
Knowledgeable staff
Personalized attention
Peace of mind guarantee
Services
Engagement Rings
We offer a comprehensive selection of designer engagement rings featuring conflict-free diamonds graded by the Gemological Institute of America. Our expert consultants help couples find perfect rings through personalized consultations while explaining the Four Cs of diamond quality. Our inventory includes solitaire, halo, and three-stone designs from renowned brands like Hearts On Fire and Simon G.
Custom Design
Our GIA-certified designers create one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces using advanced CAD technology and traditional craftsmanship. Clients can transform loose stones or heirloom jewelry into modern designs through collaborative consultations. The process includes wax modeling, metal selection, and gemstone sourcing with transparent pricing throughout the creation timeline.
Jewelry Repairs
Two master jewelers handle all repair needs using laser technology and traditional techniques. Services include ring sizing, stone setting, pearl restringing, and watch battery replacement with complimentary cleaning and inspection. Emergency repairs are available with transparent pricing communicated before work begins.
Appraisals
Graduate Gemologist Sarah Martin provides detailed insurance appraisals requiring two weeks for thorough evaluation. Each appraisal documents metal purity, stone quality, and current condition with photographic records. We offer free appraisals for in-store purchases and charge $125 for first items with discounts for multiple pieces.
Diamond Buying
We purchase loose diamonds and precious metals including gold and platinum. Our experts provide free evaluations with payments 20% above market value for trade-ins toward store credit. The process includes purity testing, weight measurement, and transparent pricing with immediate payment upon acceptance.
People
Jacquelyn Koerber
Owner
Second-generation owner with BS in Apparel Merchandising and Business from Indiana University. Former buyer for Donna Karan New York with six years of fashion industry experience. Combines family tradition with modern trends while overseeing merchandise selection and customer experience.
Sarah E. Martin
Appraiser
Graduate Gemologist from GIA (2016) with additional certifications in diamond grading and colored stones. Specializes in custom design, heirloom restyling, and rare diamond sourcing. Holds music degrees from Furman University and Indiana University's Jacobs School of Music.
Questions
What services does Koerber's Fine Jewelry offer?
We offer engagement rings, custom jewelry design, jewelry repairs, appraisals, diamond buying, and watch repairs. Our services also include financing options and trade-in programs.
How can I get a jewelry appraisal?
Schedule an appointment for appraisals requiring two weeks processing time. Bring your jewelry for evaluation by our Graduate Gemologist, with pricing starting at $125 per item.
Do you buy used jewelry?
Yes, we purchase gold, platinum, loose diamonds, and precious gemstones. We offer 20% above market value for trade-ins toward store credit or new purchases.
Can you create custom jewelry designs?
Our GIA-certified designers create custom pieces using CAD technology and traditional methods. Bring your ideas or heirloom stones for personalized consultations and design development.
What payment options are available?
We offer financing options for qualified buyers. Contact our store for details about approved payment methods and trade-in program benefits.
Reviews (6)
DPMAuto
Dec 21, 2021
Report
Wont ever return to this store. Went here to purchase product for my wife. Im no expert but received snobby responses on any of the questions I ask. they didnt even want to take time out to show me things. I wanted to put the warranty in my wifes name and the worker argued with me that I shouldnt and that my credit card needs to be in my name. I told her Im paying cash. Very poor service. To top it off I tip $10 and the worker notices my total comes to 300.05 and starts asking people if they have 5 cents for me as if I didnt have enough to pay. I said just give me the change. I dont
Gretchen
Nov 19, 2021
Report
The selection and quality at Koerber's is top notch. There is something for every budget with outstanding customer service. Emily K. listened to my idea and curated a beautiful, on-trend selection within my budget. She's my new go-to person for special gifts! Highly recommend Koerber's Fine Jewelry and Emily.
Walbip Potter
Sep 15, 2021
Report
I'm just going to say I was nervous but the individuals here made it a pleasant experience. Everyone was friendly. I couldn't imagine going to a place that was bigger.... Thanks everyone.... I appreciate it greatly.
Amy James
May 31, 2021
Report
My first visit was today and Lisa waited on my sister and myself. She was amazing! Took some pieces in to be fixed and ended up buying a beautiful estate ring! Cant wait to get it! Thank you Koerbers for such great service!!
Laurie Cunningham Vannarsdall
May 31, 2021
Report
My sister and I were at Koerbers today and worked with Lisa and she was awesome! I love this jewelry store! Emily and all of the staff are so nice! Great atmosphere!
Heidi Taylor
May 29, 2021
Report
Mina and Eddie worked very hard in getting my perfect ring. I couldn't be happier with the way it turned out. Highly recommend them, they will work with you till its exactly what you want.