Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
46 Years
experience
Your Trusted Source for Rare Coins and Custom Jewelry in Louisville
Cherokee Coins & Jewelry has been a trusted family-owned and operated business since 1980, built on a foundation of honesty, integrity, and fair pricing. Our expertise spans over four decades of buying and selling rare coins, jewelry, and collectible memorabilia, with a commitment to serving both seasoned collectors and first-time customers. We prioritize personalized service, offering appraisals, custom jewelry design, and a curated selection of key date coins, silver, gold, and antique pieces.

Our reputation is rooted in repeat customers and word-of-mouth referrals, supported by memberships in prestigious organizations like the American Numismatic Association and Professional Coin Grading Service. We combine deep industry knowledge with a passion for numismatics and craftsmanship, ensuring every transaction reflects our dedication to quality and customer satisfaction.
Services
Coin Sales Jewelry Sales Appraisals Custom Jewelry Design Collectible Memorabilia
Details
  • Year established: 1980
Highlights and features
  • We are a family-owned business with over 40 years of experience in numismatics and jewelry.
  • Our team offers personalized appraisals and custom jewelry design services.
  • We maintain memberships in top-tier industry organizations like PCGS and ANA.
  • We guarantee fair pricing for all purchases and sales.
  • Our inventory includes rare, hard-to-find collectibles and investment-grade coins.
Associations and certifications
  • American Numismatic Association (ANA)
  • CoinNet
  • Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS)
  • Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC)
Services
Coin Sales
We offer a wide selection of rare coins, including key date, silver, gold, and commemorative pieces. Our inventory caters to collectors and investors seeking high-quality numismatic items. With decades of expertise, we ensure authenticity and competitive pricing for every transaction.
Jewelry Sales
Our store features antique and modern jewelry, including diamonds, estate pieces, and collectible designs. Each item is carefully curated to meet the tastes of discerning customers. We combine historical craftsmanship with contemporary styles for unique offerings.
Appraisals
We provide expert appraisals for coin collections, jewelry, and memorabilia. Our process ensures accurate valuations based on market trends and item rarity. Appointments are recommended for detailed assessments and personalized guidance.
Custom Jewelry Design
Our custom design service creates tailored engagement rings and heirloom pieces. Clients collaborate with our team to transform ideas into unique jewelry. We prioritize quality materials and craftsmanship for lasting results.
Collectible Memorabilia
We specialize in rare collectibles, including paper money, Morgan Dollars, and historical artifacts. Our inventory changes regularly to showcase new acquisitions. Collectors find unique items with historical significance and investment potential.
People
Steve Kommor
Owner
Steve Kommor founded Cherokee Coins & Jewelry in 1980 after discovering a passion for numismatics at age seven. He brings decades of expertise in rare coins and collector markets, maintaining a national reputation for trustworthiness.
Susan Kommor
COO
Susan Kommor oversees operations, marketing, and financial planning at Cherokee Coins & Jewelry. Her background in finance enhances the business's strategic growth while ensuring personalized customer service for all clients.
Questions
What services does Cherokee Coins & Jewelry offer?
We specialize in rare coin sales, jewelry sales, appraisals, custom jewelry design, and collectible memorabilia. Our expertise spans numismatics and antique items.
Are you certified by any industry organizations?
Yes, we are members of the American Numismatic Association, PCGS, NGC, and CoinNet for coin grading and trading standards.
Do you buy items from customers?
We purchase gold, silver, platinum, rare coins, and collectibles. Contact us for a fair, transparent valuation process.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Louisville, KY, but work with collectors nationwide through our online store and consultations.
Reviews (6)
Matthew Raggard
Nov 13, 2021 Report
Steve and his team are fantastic to work with, especially when sharing their knowledge of your coins and their varieties, as well as next steps towards preserving or grading them. Definitely appreciate the time they spent with me, and looking forward to the next Saturday that I can stop in!
Donald O'Loughlin
Nov 04, 2021 Report
I went there because my wife has some coins she wanted to sell. The two gentlemen working were very helpful and my wife and I were happy with the deal that was struck.
Joel A. Gitter
Oct 26, 2021 Report
First Time here, great experience. Learned a lot more about how to care, and how the values work. I will be back in the future for life
10 out of 10
Buster Brown
Aug 21, 2021 Report
Great prices, very helpful people, honest and they always give me a good deal... He's such a great guy, he gave me a silver 1947 nickel in my change. HIGHLY RECOMMEND, check out the vintage jewelry! Wow... Your not going to find a better deal in Louisville! If you walk away without getting a deal, it's because you wasn't wanting one... I get a deal on something, everytime I stop in Cherokee Coins & Jewelry Inc.
Dna
Aug 06, 2021 Report
I think I would've gotten a better dealer if I was a little older and whiter. I'm not intending to play the race card, but that's truly how I feel. I felt I was treated much differently than two older white male customers.
Meka Sylvester
May 26, 2021 Report
Sold a ring there and they offered me more than I expected. Really good customer service. I recommend Cherokee Coin to anyone who has jewelry to sell. I'll definitely be back.