Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Saint Johns, MI
Established in 1964, McKenzie Agency has served Michigan communities as a trusted independent insurance provider. Our locally owned and operated agency specializes in personalized auto, home, life, health, commercial, and flood insurance solutions tailored to Michigan residents' unique needs. With decades of combined experience, our team prioritizes client education and value-driven coverage. We maintain strong relationships with top insurers to secure competitive rates while delivering responsive, community-focused service.Our commitment to innovation ensures clients receive modern insurance solutions backed by time-tested expertise. As neighbors ourselves, we understand Michigan's specific insurance challenges and work diligently to protect what matters most to our clients.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Flood Insurance
Health Insurance
Farm Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1964
Highlights and features
- We've served Michigan communities since 1964 with insurance expertise
- Local knowledge helps us address Michigan-specific insurance needs
- Independent agency model provides access to multiple carriers
- Bundle discounts available for combined home and auto policies
- Personalized service from experienced, certified insurance professionals
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect Michigan drivers with liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options. We offer competitive rates through multiple carriers while maintaining personalized service. Special discounts available for safe drivers and multi-policy bundling.
Home Insurance
We provide homeowners insurance covering dwelling, personal property, and liability protection across Michigan. Our policies include standard coverage with optional endorsements for specific risks. Bundle with auto insurance for additional savings.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect Michigan businesses with property, liability, and specialized coverage options. We serve diverse industries including retail, manufacturing, and professional services. Policies include business interruption and workers' compensation options.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance policies to secure your family's financial future. Our agents help determine appropriate coverage amounts and policy types. Competitive rates available through multiple carrier partnerships.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance policies protect Michigan properties against water damage from heavy rains and natural disasters. Coverage includes building and personal property protection. Available as standalone policies or endorsements to existing home insurance.
People
Todd Hunt
President
Todd Hunt leads the agency with expertise in personal and commercial insurance sales. Joined in 2021, he focuses on strategic operations and client relationships while maintaining active insurance licensing.
Amy Shinabargar
Office Manager
Amy manages daily operations and specializes in commercial insurance solutions. With 20 years of agency experience, she provides exceptional customer service and policy management expertise to business clients.
Callahan Brogan
Commercial and Personal Lines Producer
Callahan handles both personal and commercial insurance policies. A Michigan State University graduate with business management expertise, he brings fresh perspective and technical knowledge to client coverage solutions.
Janean Walker
Commercial and Personal Lines Producer
Janean serves clients with 8 years of insurance experience covering personal and commercial lines. Her background includes life insurance and risk management strategies for Michigan businesses and residents.
Daniel O'Toole Jr.
Commercial and Personal Lines Producer
Dan provides insurance solutions for personal and business clients. A Michigan State University finance graduate, he specializes in matching client needs with appropriate coverage options across multiple insurance carriers.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, home, life, health, commercial, and flood insurance for Michigan residents and businesses. Our independent agency model provides access to multiple carriers for comprehensive coverage options.
Do you serve areas outside Saint Johns?
Yes, we serve all Michigan residents including Clinton, Gratiot, Ionia, Shiawassee, Ingham counties, and Lansing area. Our local expertise covers Michigan's unique insurance requirements across multiple regions.
Can I get discounts for multiple policies?
Yes, we offer bundle discounts for combined home and auto insurance policies. Ask about our multi-policy savings when requesting your free insurance quote.
Are you open after regular business hours?
Our standard office hours are Monday-Friday 9:00am-5:00pm. We offer special appointments outside these hours by request to accommodate client schedules.
Reviews (2)
Jacoblindquist
May 18, 2018
Report
I have worked with Mathew through Jim McKenzie agency Inc. for two 6 month auto insurance terms now. He searches through several insurance providers each time and he has worked diligently to find me the best policy available. My auto insurance has dropped from $880/6 months, down to $422/6 months. I obviously highly recommend using the service that Jim McKenzie, Mathew and co provide. Very happy with my experience with them. 5 stars! *****
Charles Truesdell
Nov 12, 2015
Report
Best insurance agency around. Great people....great service! C.H. Truesdell III, owner True Built Construction
