Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
35 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Sarasota
Since 1991, Il Panificio has been Sarasota's premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine, crafted from cherished family recipes passed down through generations. Our menu features handcrafted thin-crust pizzas made with homemade dough, premium cheese, and fresh ingredients, alongside a selection of Italian appetizers, deli sandwiches, pastas, and desserts. With locations in Downtown Sarasota and Siesta Key, we offer dine-in, takeout, and catering services for events of all sizes.

Our commitment to quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods ensures every dish delivers the rich flavors of Italy. Customers consistently praise our hospitality, value pricing, and the nostalgic experience of enjoying meals prepared with century-old techniques. Whether you're a local or visitor, our cozy atmosphere and quick service make us a favorite for families and individuals alike.
Services
Italian Pizzas Catering Services Dessert Selection Deli Sandwiches Pasta Dishes Delivery Service Wine & Beer Salads Gluten-Free Options Takeout Orders
Details
  • Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 30 years of experience serving authentic Italian cuisine in Sarasota
  • Our recipes have been perfected over 100 years of family tradition
  • We provide catering services for weddings and events with Italian flair
  • Our staff delivers exceptional hospitality praised by regular customers
  • We maintain consistent quality across both Downtown Sarasota and Siesta Key locations
What people say
Best pizza in Florida Flavorful pizza Wonderful service Cozy place Perfect pizza
Services
Italian Pizzas
Our signature thin-crust pizzas feature homemade dough, premium cheese, and fresh ingredients. Each pie follows traditional Italian recipes perfected over 100 years. Available in classic and specialty varieties with delivery and takeout options.
Catering Services
We provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Our menu includes Italian pastas, pizzas, salads, and desserts prepared fresh on-site. Clients receive personalized menu planning and event coordination.
Pasta Dishes
Handmade pasta selections include baked ziti, eggplant parmesan, and sausage pepperoni dishes. All pasta is prepared fresh daily using traditional Italian methods. Available for dine-in, takeout, and catering orders.
Deli Sandwiches
Italian cold subs and hot sandwiches feature premium meats, cheeses, and house-made focaccia bread. Options include classic Italian subs, chicken parmesan, and vegetarian varieties. Served with sides and dressings.
Dessert Selection
Authentic Italian desserts include cannoli, tiramisu, and limoncello. Our pastry chefs prepare all desserts fresh daily using traditional recipes. Available by the slice or whole portions for special orders.
Questions
What makes your pizza authentic Italian style?
We use homemade dough, fresh ingredients, and traditional recipes passed down through generations for authentic Italian flavor.
Do you offer catering services for events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties with Italian cuisine options.
Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
Yes, we offer gluten-free crust options for our pizzas by special request.
What are your operating hours?
We serve daily from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM at both Sarasota locations.
Do you deliver to residential areas?
Yes, we offer delivery services to homes and businesses within Sarasota county.
Reviews (7)
Rachael Mazzoni
Jan 28, 2022 Report
Fantastic "foldable" thin crust pizza. So so good. Perfectly crispy with right amount of sauce and cheese.
Dan M.
Dec 23, 2021 Report
We tried the Margarita, which was okay, but the pepperoni and mushroom slice was an 11 out of 10. Crispy crust, great sauce, overall excellent!
Jeremy Moulton
Dec 21, 2021 Report
Hands-down absolutely best pizza in Siesta Key. Would recommend to any tourist/friend. Cheap and lots of varietys.
Emjayv V.
Aug 09, 2021 Report
Can't really give any stars for the food. Arrived at 8.30 p.m. and I was told that they were closed. BTW the sign on the door says opened 7 days a week from 9am until 9pm. I mentioned that to the guy behind the counter and he said "it's closed we close at 9pm" I said it is 8.30 he said "is over we close at 9pm" hilarious. Will be back? nahhhhhhh
Sam Goldstein
Jul 15, 2021 Report
Just received and devoured a pie and a calzone... Wife said the calzone was on point and my pizza was AMAZING ! Crispy crust and great tasting pie... Best on the Key and better than most pies ANYWHERE in Sarasota...
Erica Weinberg
Jul 01, 2021 Report
Interesting options much better than generic pizza shops, though toppings were a little lacking and dough a bit tough. Wanted gluten free, but learned it was corn based. Still probably better than the previous pizza shop purveyors.
DaveASpondy
Jun 19, 2021 Report
This is pizza. Ordered a pie over the phone for a to go order. Took about 25 minutes for a half cheese, half pepperoni like they said it would. Friggin delicious. Traditional New York style. Also, my 12 year old is very picky and he absolutely devoured the buffalo chicken slice. My wife and I had the meatball parm and chicken parm sandwiches that were spectacular.