Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Historic Restaurant & Pub Experience in Columbia, PA
Established in 1903, our restaurant has been a cornerstone of hospitality in Columbia, Pennsylvania for over a century. As owners Dave and Sherry, we transitioned from the insurance industry to pursue our passion for hospitality, acquiring and revitalizing this historic establishment in 2000. After 11 months of extensive renovations, we reopened with a commitment to quality cuisine and service, leveraging Dave's background in cabinetmaking and my expertise in interior design to create a welcoming environment. Our family-owned business has grown to include an 11-room inn, recognized with the C.Emlen Urban Award for Preservation in 2010. We take pride in sourcing local ingredients and developing culinary talent, with our son Adam and later Bobby Schoelkopf rising to executive chef roles. Our dedication to excellence has earned us numerous local awards, while maintaining the historic charm that makes our establishment unique. We offer a comprehensive experience combining dining, lodging, and event hosting in a setting that blends tradition with modern comforts.
Services
Restaurant
Pub
Bed & Breakfast
Catering
Beer Selection
Wine Tasting
Whiskey Flights
Private Events
Coffee Drinks
Historic Tours
Details
- Year established: 1903
Highlights and features
- We offer award-winning cuisine crafted with local ingredients since 1903
- Our historic tavern blends tradition with modern hospitality
- We maintain the largest beer selection in the Susquehanna Valley
- Our family-trained chefs have won multiple local culinary awards
- We provide boutique inn accommodations in a beautifully preserved 1903 building
Services
Restaurant
Our historic restaurant serves award-winning American cuisine with a focus on local ingredients. Our menu features daily specials and classic dishes prepared using traditional methods. The dining room maintains its original architectural details while providing modern comfort for guests seeking exceptional culinary experiences.
Pub
The pub offers an extensive selection of craft beers, premium spirits, and specialty cocktails. Our bar features a hand-carved back bar from the early 1900s and maintains one of the region's largest beer collections. Guests enjoy a casual atmosphere with regular special events and themed drink promotions.
Bed & Breakfast
The 11-room inn provides boutique accommodations in a beautifully restored 1903 railroad hotel. Each room features private bathrooms and modern amenities while preserving historic architectural elements. The inn caters to tourists, business travelers, and guests attending special events at our facility.
Catering
We offer in-house catering for private events with customized menus and venue arrangements. The facility accommodates various group sizes for weddings, business meetings, and social gatherings. Our experienced staff coordinates all aspects of event planning and execution within our historic setting.
Beer Selection
Our beer program features over 100 domestic and international selections including rare and seasonal brews. The rotating tap list includes local craft beers alongside global specialties, with tasting flights available. We maintain the largest beer selection in the Susquehanna Valley region.
People
Dave Zahm
Owner & Head Chef
With over two decades in hospitality, Dave transitioned from insurance to restaurateur, leading Bully's Restaurant & Pub Restaurant and Pub culinary vision since 2000. He oversees menu development and maintains quality standards using fresh, local ingredients.
Sherry Zahm
Co-Owner & Innkeeper
Sherry manages the business operations and inn accommodations. Her interior design expertise helped restore the historic building while ensuring modern guest comfort in the 11-room boutique inn.
Bobby Schoelkopf
Executive Chef
Graduating from Johnson & Wales University, Bobby became executive chef in 2015. He maintains culinary excellence through innovative menu development and quality control in our award-winning kitchen.
Questions
What makes Bully's Restaurant & Pub Restaurant and Pub Restaurant unique?
Bully's Restaurant & Pub Restaurant and Pub combines historic charm with modern hospitality, offering award-winning cuisine, an extensive beer selection, and a family-owned atmosphere since 1903.
Do you offer accommodations?
Yes, we have an 11-room boutique inn in the restored 1903 railroad hotel building with private bathrooms and modern amenities.
What dining options are available?
We serve dinner Tuesday-Saturday with extended kitchen hours on weekends, featuring American cuisine and weekly specialty menus.
Can I host private events at Bully's Restaurant & Pub Restaurant and Pub?
Yes, we offer in-house catering for private events with customized menus and venue arrangements for weddings and business gatherings.
What beer selections do you offer?
We maintain over 100 domestic and international beer selections including rare and seasonal brews with rotating tap options.
Reviews (6)
Lori G.
Jan 29, 2022
Report
It's been a few years since I went to this place and it's just as good if not better. The staff is really nice and food was amazing. We had the burgers, crab cakes and stuffed portobellos and everything was great. What a gem in Columbia! We will be back.
Tom Johnson-Medland
Jan 28, 2022
Report
This place has been on our list for a while. We finally made it there and were so pleased that we did. The place was clean and impeccable and very comfortable. The staff were beyond helpful, and were attentive to our every need. Food was exceptional. The flavors were robust and layered. The flavor profile was enhanced in the sauces, herbs and spices used to draw out the flavor of the meal. We had the ahi tuna and duck comfit. Both meals were exceptional. The dessert was delectable- cheesecake and cream brle. We will be back.
Bruce M.
Jan 12, 2022
Report
For anyone to rate this restaurant less than 5 stars they are brain dead. I am a classically trained chef who is very critical of restaurants. My wife and I went to Bully's for a nice night out. Little did we know walking into a nice Pub we would have the best meal I've had in years. The Duck Confit was amazing and duck is my favorite protein. Service was top notch and the beer and wine list was superb. Will be returning often. Best restaurant I've been to in years!
Jeff Snader
Oct 26, 2021
Report
Food and bar service was excellent as usual. Cameron made a great beer suggestion. Tap choices were wonderful and expansive.
Joseph McDonough
Oct 18, 2021
Report
Great beer selection on tap. Food was very good. Extensive selection. I had bangers and mash which was great.
Rose E. Mazurek
Sep 29, 2021
Report
We came to town for a wedding and were struggling to find good options in the vicinity. We found this inn in a google search and were a bit skeptical. It ended up being such a gem of a stay . The owner let us check in early to get ready for the wedding . Quiet and clean everything we needed and more. There was a nice shared area that offered coffee snacks and pastriesnice touch. Would have loved to try the restaurant but the wedding took too long. Next time!