Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Experience Authentic Italian Cuisine at Caffe Piccolo
At Caffe Piccolo, we are dedicated to delivering an authentic Italian dining experience rooted in tradition and quality. Our menu is crafted using the freshest local ingredients, from farm-fresh produce to responsibly sourced seafood, ensuring every dish reflects our commitment to excellence. Located in Pawleys Island, South Carolina, our intimate setting features a glowing fireplace and cozy booths, creating a warm atmosphere for families and friends.

With over 15 years of culinary expertise, Chef James Pronesti combines old family recipes with innovative techniques to create dishes that celebrate true Italian flavors. We pride ourselves on personalized hospitality, a carefully curated wine list, and catering services that bring our passion for Italian cuisine to local events. Our goal is to make every visit memorable through exceptional food, attentive service, and a space that feels like home.
Services
Italian Restaurant Catering Services Dinner Menu Wine Selection Fresh Ingredients
Highlights and features
  • We use only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients in every dish.
  • Our chef brings over 15 years of culinary expertise and passion.
  • We offer catering services for events with our signature Italian flair.
  • Our intimate ambiance combines comfort and elegance for every guest.
  • Our wine list is curated to perfectly complement each Italian dish.
Services
Italian Restaurant
Caffe Piccolo offers an intimate Italian dining experience with a menu rooted in traditional recipes and fresh, local ingredients. Our cozy ambiance, featuring a fireplace and dim lighting, creates a welcoming environment for families and friends. Chef James Pronestis expertise ensures each dish highlights authentic Italian flavors while embracing seasonal, responsibly sourced seafood and produce from South Carolina.
Catering Services
Our catering services bring Caffe Piccolos Italian cuisine to local events, weddings, and private gatherings. Menus are customized with handcrafted dishes and wine pairings, reflecting the same dedication to fresh ingredients and traditional flavors. With attention to detail and personalized service, we ensure every event embodies the warmth and quality of our restaurant experience.
Dinner Menu
The dinner menu features classic Italian dishes made from scratch daily, including housemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and seasonal specialties. Ingredients are sourced locally to guarantee freshness, from farm-fresh tomatoes to responsibly raised meats and seafood. Each plate is paired with a curated wine selection, enhancing the meal with complementary flavors and regional varietals.
Wine Selection
Our wine list showcases varietals carefully chosen to complement every dish on the menu, with options ranging from Italian classics to regional South Carolina favorites. Staff members guide guests through selections to enhance their meal, ensuring a perfect balance of flavors. The list emphasizes quality and diversity, offering choices for both connoisseurs and casual diners.
Fresh Ingredients
Caffe Piccolo prioritizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients, partnering with regional farmers and seafood vendors to ensure quality. Herbs, vegetables, and meats are selected for their freshness, while daily specials reflect the best available seasonal products. This commitment guarantees that every dish maintains authentic Italian taste while supporting local producers and sustainability.
People
James Pronesti
Executive Chef
James Pronesti, known as Jimmy, has over 15 years of culinary experience, driven by a passion for Italian cuisine. He honed his skills through hands-on learning and family traditions, later opening Caffe Piccolo to share his craft. His dedication to fresh ingredients and authentic recipes defines the restaurants identity.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Caffe Piccolo serve?
Caffe Piccolo specializes in traditional Italian cuisine using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and family recipes.
Are reservations required at Caffe Piccolo?
Reservations are recommended but not required. You can book online or by calling the restaurant directly.
Does Caffe Piccolo offer catering services?
Yes, we provide catering for events with customized Italian menus and wine pairings tailored to your needs.
What are the restaurant’s operating hours?
Caffe Piccolo is open daily from 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM for dinner service.
Is there a wine list available?
Yes, we offer a curated wine list featuring Italian and regional varietals to complement every dish.
Where is Caffe Piccolo located?
We are located at 9428 Ocean Highway, Pawleys Island, SC, just south of Myrtle Beach.
Reviews (7)
BobbieJo Kilbury
Dec 28, 2021 Report
Oh my goodness the stuffed banana peppers were awesome. We sat at the bar. The place is beautifully decorated. The service was excellent.
Ian Anderson
Dec 27, 2021 Report
Apps were good. Entree was one of the worst Italian dishes I've ever had. Took a long time to get it. I barely moved it around the plate but no one asked if it were good. Would never go back.
Mark Montague
Dec 27, 2021 Report
Excellent experience! Amy our bartender, and later waitress, did an excellent job of making us feel welcomed, and cared for. I am pretty sure, we have randomly found (thanks Google maps ) our new favorite Italian restaurant in the entire low country! The atmosphere is on point! And the vibe is subdued. You simply MUST try the stuffed banana peppers (appetizer) ! I lost count of how many times I said to my wife "oh my God " they ARE that good! 11/10. Will definitely come again! Most highly recommend!
Kendra Turk
Nov 30, 2021 Report
Incredible atmosphere- very romantic and warm- we went on a chilly night and sat outdoor seating- very warm with heaters and fire. The food was incredible and delicious, plenty of seafood and land dishes to chose from, the service was impeccable. Gets busy quick- next time we will do a reservation (we didnt this time we didnt wait but we got there right when they opened at 5)
Jessica Mairs
Nov 26, 2021 Report
Really great menu. Our two families brought our 12 y/o sons who came in baseball uniforms. We loved the food and the environment was fantastic. Outdoor seating had heaters and fireplaces.
Rebecca Bec Boncheck
Oct 29, 2021 Report
Nice outdoor garden seating, service was great. Food was good. Broccoli rabe a little bitter, not blanched, but was fresh. Nice wine list. Our waiter Josh was very knowledgable.
Jamie Harvell
Oct 25, 2021 Report
Lovely courtyard, pleasant servers, eggplant appetizer was incredible, tomato basil as well. Gluten free bread was unbelievable! ... More like the usual offering than i could imagine was possible. Haven't seen that anywhere! Mahi with risotto was great as my entree. Highly recommend!