Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Commack, NY
Keepsake Diamonds has served Long Island for over 40 years as a family-owned jewelry business. Our fourth-generation owner, John, is a certified diamontologist who personally curates our diamond inventory and oversees all custom designs. We specialize in engagement rings, wedding bands, and bespoke jewelry creation while offering same-day repair services for watches and damaged pieces. Our team provides personalized consultations to help clients select or design jewelry that matches their style and budget. Located in Commack, NY, we deliver Diamond District quality without requiring trips to Manhattan.

With generations of combined experience, we maintain deep expertise in stone selection, mounting, and jewelry appraisal. Our commitment to transparency ensures clients receive accurate information to make confident purchasing decisions. We serve customers from Suffolk, Nassau, and Queens, building lasting relationships through exceptional service. Our physical store at 20 Veterans Highway remains a community staple for all jewelry needs.
Services
Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Custom Jewelry Diamond Jewelry Jewelry Repairs
Highlights and features
  • We offer 40+ years of family-owned jewelry expertise
  • Our owner is a certified diamontologist with hands-on experience
  • We provide same-day jewelry and watch repair services
  • We create custom bridal jewelry tailored to personal stories
  • We maintain Diamond District-level quality standards locally
What people say
Very professional Exactly what she wanted Exceptional to work with Perfect ring selection Accommodating throughout process
Services
Engagement Rings
Our engagement ring collection features meticulously crafted pieces with certified diamonds. Clients receive expert guidance through the Four Cs (Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat) to find perfect stones. We offer both pre-designed options and custom creation services where couples collaborate with our diamontologist to develop unique rings that reflect personal stories and preferences.
Custom Jewelry
We specialize in transforming client visions into one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces. Our custom process begins with concept sketches and material selection, followed by prototype creation. Fourth-generation expertise ensures technical precision while maintaining artistic integrity. Popular requests include remounting heirloom stones and creating personalized bridal sets that match specific style preferences.
Wedding Bands
Our wedding band selection includes matching sets and individual designs in various metals and finishes. We offer both classic and contemporary styles with optional diamond accents. The service includes ring sizing, engraving options, and metal type comparisons to help couples choose durable, comfortable bands that complement engagement rings while reflecting their personal aesthetic.
Diamond Jewelry
We curate high-quality diamond jewelry including necklaces, earrings, and bracelets. Our inventory features both ready-to-wear pieces and customizable options. Certified diamonds undergo strict quality checks before inclusion in our collection. Clients receive detailed education about stone characteristics and setting options to make informed decisions about investment-grade jewelry purchases.
Jewelry Repairs
Our in-house repair service handles most jewelry and watch maintenance needs. Common services include ring resizing, clasp repairs, and watch battery replacements. Many repairs complete same-day while complex restorations receive clear turnaround timelines. We use professional tools to ensure structural integrity while preserving original craftsmanship in both modern and antique pieces.
People
John
Owner & Certified Diamontologist
Fourth-generation jeweler specializing in diamond evaluation and custom design. Oversees all stone selection and jewelry creation processes at Keepsake Diamonds. Combines family tradition with modern techniques to deliver high-quality pieces.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer?
We provide engagement rings, wedding bands, custom jewelry design, diamond selection, and jewelry repair services. Our team also offers watch maintenance and repairs.
Can you create custom bridal jewelry?
Yes, we specialize in custom bridal jewelry. Bring your inspiration photos and ideas to discuss design options with our certified diamontologist.
Do you buy used jewelry?
We purchase gold, silver, and diamond-containing jewelry. Visit our store for a free evaluation of your pre-owned pieces.
Are same-day repairs available?
Many jewelry and watch repairs complete the same day. Complex repairs receive clear completion timelines during drop-off.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Commack, Long Island, and surrounding areas including Suffolk, Nassau, and Queens.
Reviews (4)
Melissa Colucci
Dec 21, 2021 Report
I had such a wonderful experience with John Terrani at Keepsake Diamonds. We brought in my engagement ring and wedding band . I wasnt quite sure what I wanted ... as soon as we started talking i knew I was in the right place! He didn't try to get us to go bigger , he was just helpful and very knowledgeable! Great guy, great place!
Biju M.
Nov 03, 2021 Report
I did some research on jewelers in the area and came across Keepsake. They had very good reviews and decided to go there since I was shopping for diamond studs for my wife's upcoming birthday. I was greeted by Kelly and John. Both were very friendly and took the time to explain everything. Both made me feel comfortable unlike other stores which tend to be pushy and just make a sale. They assisted me in picking out what I was looking for while providing a very reasonable price. I highly recommend them. I will definitely visit them again. Thank you John and Kelly!
Marissa Forman
Oct 17, 2021 Report
I have never felt so special as when I went to see them. I needed a repair, it was done quickly and perfectly. While there i was assisted in a new purchase which was both affordable and beautiful. The entire staff was just amazing. They are the 1st booth on the left and if you don't stop by and see them it is truly your loss.
Lori Brucculeri
Aug 18, 2021 Report
We went to Keepsake to have my engagement ring redone. John and Amanda were so very helpful in walking us through the process. Honest and professional included us step by step in the design process. I highly recommend keepsake! Will definitely be returning to John and Amanda for all my jewelry needs. Thank you guys absolutely love my rings.
xo
Lori and Louie