Business Details
26 Years
experience
Your Trusted Source for Fine Jewelry & Rare Collectibles in Bellport
Established in 2000, Bellport Jewelers & Rarities has grown from a modest storefront to a trusted anchor business on Main Street. Our expertise spans custom fine jewelry design, rare collectibles (including coins, sports memorabilia, and antique oddities), and comprehensive repair services. We employ a GIA-trained gemologist and certified appraisers to ensure precision in valuations and craftsmanship. Our commitment to personalized service has fostered multigenerational customer relationships, emphasizing integrity and trust. We offer in-house jewelry and watch repairs, estate sale assistance, and specialize in repurposing heirloom metals into bespoke creations.As members of leading numismatic agencies (NGC, PCGS, ANACS, CAC), we guarantee authenticated collectibles. Licensed and bonded by Suffolk County, we prioritize transparency in all transactions, from diamond sourcing to appraisal documentation. Our community-focused approach combines technical expertise with a dedication to preserving sentimental and historical value in every piece we handle.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Jewelry Repair
Coin Grading
Estate Appraisals
Bullion Sales
Watch Repair
Collectibles Trading
Diamond Sourcing
Antique Restoration
Appraisal Services
Details
- Year established: 2000
Highlights and features
- We offer over 20 years of experience in fine jewelry and collectibles.
- Our GIA-trained gemologist ensures precise gemstone evaluation.
- Custom designs crafted from heirloom metals with no hidden fees.
- In-house repair and refurbishment services for jewelry and watches.
- Certified appraisals for insurance and estate planning needs.
Associations and certifications
- NGC
- PCGS
- ANACS
- CAC
- Suffolk County Department of Consumer Affairs
What people say
Exceptional custom design skills
Knowledgeable staff
Authentic collectibles
Trustworthy appraisals
Heirloom restoration expertise
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Our GIA-trained gemologist and master designer, Pietro Romano, creates one-of-a-kind pieces using your heirloom metals or our premium materials. From concept sketches to final polish, we ensure ethical sourcing and meticulous craftsmanship. Clients receive detailed guidance on metal options, gemstone selection, and design iterations for wearable art that reflects personal stories.
Coin Grading
As members of NGC, PCGS, ANACS, and CAC, we provide certified grading for US and world coins. Our process includes authenticity verification, condition assessment using standardized scales, and market value analysis. This service caters to collectors and investors seeking accurate valuations for insurance, sales, or portfolio management purposes.
Estate Appraisals
Attorneys and families rely on our certified appraisers for comprehensive evaluations of jewelry, coin, and stamp collections. We document provenance, material quality, and market trends to deliver defensible valuations for legal proceedings or insurance coverage. Our reports adhere to industry standards for accuracy and transparency.
Jewelry Repair
Our in-house technicians handle repairs ranging from simple resizing to intricate antique restoration. Using precision tools and traditional techniques, we preserve structural integrity while maintaining aesthetic value. Services include prong rebuilding, polishing, and watch battery replacement with turnaround times communicated upfront.
Bullion Sales
We offer investment-grade gold and silver products, including American Eagles, Maple Leafs, and sovereign coins. Each item comes with purity certification and market-backed pricing. Our inventory caters to both novice investors and seasoned collectors seeking diversification through tangible assets with verifiable liquidity.
People
Peter J. Romano
Master Jewelry Designer
Italian-trained master jeweler with 20+ years of experience creating bespoke pieces. Specializes in transforming heirloom metals into modern designs while preserving sentimental value through meticulous craftsmanship.
Questions
What services do you offer for heirloom jewelry?
We specialize in restoring, repairing, and redesigning heirloom jewelry using original materials while preserving historical integrity.
Do you provide certified appraisals?
Yes, our certified appraisers document jewelry, coin, and collectible values for insurance, estates, or sales purposes.
Can you create custom pieces from my existing metals?
Absolutely. We melt down and refashion heirloom gold/silver into bespoke designs tailored to your preferences.
Are your collectibles authenticated?
All coins and currency undergo verification through our membership in NGC, PCGS, ANACS, and CAC grading agencies.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept cash, credit cards, and wire transfers. Financing options are available for qualifying purchases.
Reviews (7)
J. Ramsawak
Nov 04, 2020
Report
Dianne and Peter do quality work, they care about their customers and their reputation. Almost 5 years ago they helped me create custom engagement and wedding rings, they shopped the diamonds for me and built extraordinary rings. They still remember me and always take good care of me. Worth the drive whenever I need the rings cleaned, they've even done this for me on the house! I would trust them to repair any jewelry- Peter is a pro craftsman. My wife (she's a nurse) has been tough on these rings going on 5 years and she still gets compliments on a regular basis, no problems with quality! It is
Jackie Raad
Nov 27, 2019
Report
Diane and Pete take a personal involvement in the care and wishes of their clients. Im not only thrilled with my ring that I picked up this week, but I cant tell you many compliments Ive gotten. They do excellent work, stand behind their product and LISTEN to what you desire! I highly recommended them! We will be back! Thank you we are thrilled
Lydia Montalvo
Aug 01, 2018
Report
Very honest and down to earth ! Quality is good! I needed to replace a very small diamond that had fallen of my ring and they replaced and it looks way better than the original !! Now I want to replace the other original !!!! Thank You !! Bellport Jeweler ! Dianne & Peter
Heather Legnosky
Aug 19, 2017
Report
Went in the other day and it was fantastic! They were so helpful and I found exactly what I needed. Easily the best jewelry store on Long Island.
Jerilyn Toole
Jul 28, 2017
Report
I went in last week needing the glass to my watch fixed. They were extremely helpful and nice. I was greeted once I walked in the door! That's something hard to find nowadays! When I got my watch back it looked brand new. I was more than satisfied. An amazing establishment that everyone should go to!
Kathy Sieglinger
Jul 02, 2017
Report
I have been doing business with Peter & Dianne Romano for over 10 years. They run a top shelf jewelry store with a very friendly neighborhood feeling. Peter has designed quite a few "one if a kind" pieces for me, some using my own gold and diamonds. They may be a small local store but there is nothing small about the quality of work they do! You come up with a design and Peter will create it! If you can't find what you are looking for Dianne will do her best to find it for you.
Neville Mullings
May 15, 2015
Report
My family- Wife and son have been customers for over 20 years going back to Great Neck.These are wonderful,honest,courteous and highly professionals.We have always been satisfied with their products and service.They are top notch-the best.I moved from NY to NC and still deal with them.I would not hesitate to recommend them highly.
Neville/Lynn and Gordon Mullings.
Neville/Lynn and Gordon Mullings.