Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & Dining in Randolph, NJ
Paisano's Pizzeria has been serving the Randolph, NJ community since our establishment, dedicated to delivering authentic Italian cuisine rooted in Brooklyn traditions. Our commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients ensures every dish reflects the flavors of classic New York-style pizza and entrees. As a family-owned business, we prioritize creating meals that bring families together, emphasizing time-honored recipes passed down through generations. Our menu features a diverse selection of handcrafted pizzas, house-made pasta dishes, and catering options designed to meet both casual and event-specific needs.

With a newly renovated dining space, we provide a welcoming environment where guests can enjoy our food and hospitality. Our teams expertise in Italian cooking techniques and local market preferences ensures a dining experience that balances tradition with modern convenience. We maintain rigorous quality standards in food preparation and sourcing, earning trust as a reliable neighborhood eatery. Customer satisfaction drives our continuous improvement in service delivery, from dine-in experiences to timely takeout and delivery options.
Services
Pizza Delivery Catering Services Italian Restaurant Online Ordering Takeout Event Catering Pasta Dishes Gluten-Free Options Wine Selection Private Events
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned and operated with deep roots in Italian culinary traditions
  • Uses only fresh, high-quality ingredients for consistent flavor excellence
  • Authentic New York-style recipes perfected over multiple generations
  • Offers full-service catering for events with customized menu options
  • Maintains a welcoming, family-friendly dining environment with modern amenities
Services
Pizza Delivery
Enjoy hot, fresh pizza delivered directly to your door within 3 miles of our Randolph location. Our delivery service operates daily from 4pm-8pm with a $25 minimum order requirement. We maintain strict temperature controls during transport to ensure optimal food quality.
Catering Services
Provide customized catering solutions for corporate events, family gatherings, and special occasions. Our catering menu includes tray-sized portions of popular menu items, with options for both hot and cold presentations to suit any event type.
Italian Restaurant
Experience authentic Italian cuisine in our newly renovated dining space featuring both traditional and contemporary Italian dishes. Our restaurant accommodates families and groups seeking a comfortable atmosphere with attentive service and quality food.
Online Ordering
Convenient 24/7 online ordering system for takeout and delivery requests. Customers can place orders for our complete menu offerings at their convenience through our user-friendly digital platform with real-time order tracking.
Takeout
Efficient takeout service for customers preferring to enjoy our meals at home or office. We package all takeout orders with care using insulated containers to maintain food temperature and quality during transport.
Questions
Does Paisanos Pizzeria offer catering services for large events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events of all sizes with customizable menus. Our catering packages include hot food trays serving 7-15 people, with advance ordering required.
What are the restaurant's operating hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 10:00am-9:30pm and Sunday 11:00am-9:00pm. Delivery service operates daily from 4pm-8pm within our 3-mile service area.
Are there gluten-free options available on the menu?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza crusts and pasta alternatives to accommodate dietary restrictions while maintaining authentic Italian flavors.
Can I order food online for pickup or delivery?
Yes, our 24/7 online ordering system allows customers to place takeout and delivery orders at any time through our website with real-time tracking capabilities.
What payment methods does the restaurant accept?
We accept major credit cards, cash payments, and online payments through our digital ordering platform for both in-store and remote transactions.
Is the restaurant family-friendly?
Yes, our newly renovated dining space is designed to accommodate families with children, featuring a welcoming atmosphere suitable for all age groups.
Reviews (4)
Siddharth Srivastav
Dec 29, 2021 Report
Great Pizza and sandwich place, good ambience and friendly staff. I recently tried eggplant parmesan sandwich, it was very nice. Pizza over here tastes good and better than other pizza places in Randolph, NJ.
Trevor Waldron
Nov 22, 2021 Report
The staff is really great and kind treat their customers really good. Great recommendation from Fernando and Izzy for the buffalo chicken really enjoyed it, had a great kick to it. Very great place to hang out with friends and grab a good meal, quick service.
Natasha Rivera
Oct 22, 2021 Report
Food is ok. They need to warm up their slices more. Told them we wanted them hot. They were warm. And they were cold before we finished eating them.
Anthony Quinones
Feb 22, 2021 Report
This place used to be scilicis pizza. Scilicis pizza was some of the best greasy pizza in the area. Once these people opened the shop back up under Paisano's I went back to give it a shot, really hoping the new pizza place was good since I lived close. Mannnnn I couldn't even finish the slice. Like it's not that it wasn't great. It's that it wasn't even good. My parents decided to try it before asking me if I have, and came to me the next day saying they had a full pizza with a few bits out of 2 slices missing. I just feel for the price you can do way better. Delicia's in Dover has one dollar slices